eCommerce Strategies and the Business Model Canvas with Yoni Kozminski
Yoni Kozminski joins the Successful eCommerce Strategies podcast to discuss the Business Model Canvas applied to eCommerce, operational systems, and building MultiplyMii and Escala from zero.
What this conversation covers
- Applying the Business Model Canvas to eCommerce operations
- How MultiplyMii serves the $1M–$50M eCommerce operator
- Building Escala: process consulting before offshore hiring
- What makes a business scalable vs. one that breaks at growth
Full transcript12,051 words · YouTube auto-captions
and we're live jenny kuzminski welcome to the show man how are you doing michael it's an absolute honor and a pleasure to be sitting down with you here thank you goodness you can tell we've both been working with americans for a long time because we say overly polite but uh where are you coming to swim in the world i i don't detect and uh do i detect an australian twang there tell tell me about where you where you are so to your first point yet way too much time uh working with and in the us so yeah we're being way too polite to one another uh but uh that is an australian accent but i'm coming to you live from tel aviv israel excellent so you're a man of a great international um well i guess you worked in three continents right at least so that's that's pretty yeah apart from antarctica you've covered most of them trying to collect passports yeah amazing well so today we're going to be talking about the whole thing of um successful e-commerce strategy what that even means but also i think it's a very much abused word strategy right i mean tell me about your thoughts on that before we kick off the main podcast yeah it's funny and we use scale in one of our websites as terminology i think that outside of strategy scale probably the most overused and under and least understood terms uh so yeah we can we could probably do a whole session on on on language and terminology and uh what's real and what isn't but uh yeah i'll let you do the driving no that's cool i mean one of the things i would say but straight shape from the office that people use the word strategy for something i would just call a little tactic or even a hack i i would define a hack as a tactic that is going to go away either tomorrow or within two months or something there's a huge amount of that in any e-commerce space and certainly amazon is is you know one of the worst places for that so yeah what we're talking about here is not little pictures it's the biggest picture of the the business i guess and often neglected because we're all busy beavering away trying to build a business right and or trying to actually just survive and not build a business so much just run the thing so i guess we're talking about really working on your business not in it really um so um i'm just making a note of that by the way but it's also always one of those phrases that people are searching for google and then you look up the stuff and people talk about it but actually do it is is another matter all together isn't it so i thought the term as well came uh it came from the emea yes indeed yeah which is a great a great book by the way but again it's it's uh i think i've got it very near me and that's a physical i've got a handful of books i really value literally next to me on my desk but it's one of those books where the the theory of it is nice but the implementation side is a little bit sort of vague and it's a bit old-fashioned as well so it's a great book to read but i think it's yeah we need some help with that um so anyone who's listening live or if you're listening we don't tend to publicize this with live i'm not a social media creature really i try but i love podcasts in the end so this is going to be a live podcast recording guys but having said that do post any comments um either when you're listening live or if you um catch this after it's live quite likely do pop any comments down and we'll get you only to answer any uh questions that you've got as well or we'll we'll address them in the podcast if they come up for you so with without further ado yeah you up for doing the actual podcast itself let's let's give it a good radio let's go radio here we go i'm into it that's that's fortunate uh we were both so americanized it's hilarious like are you getting to do this yeah man you should say awesome i'm stoked that's the only permissible language that's the minimum level i've become americanized i'm actually i'm sitting here almost embarrassed no i do the same thing i'm saying man but anyway so i must almost stop uh you're all you're all good bro yeah yeah like what yeah i believe that's that's probably a positive thing right let's let's do this thing ladles and jellies please boys and girls of the internet welcome to the 10k collective podcast the place to be for six seven and eight figure amazon sellers who are rapidly becoming e-commerce sellers not just amazon sellers because it's getting hot in the water out there so today we are talking to yoni kuzminski we are talking about how to work on not in your business or while the transition is working on i guess and what strategy means and actually having a plan and there's a particular tool the business model canvas so yenni welcome to the show man yeah like i said before and i'll say it again it's uh it's a pleasure being here mate and uh i'm gonna throw in the mate there just yeah that feels a bit more yeah it feels a bit better doesn't it yeah it does yeah we're just chatting before um we kicked off the podcast recording about how americanized would become which is fine i mean like headset marketing is kind of an american invention but you gotta own where you come from so just remind us where you're coming from the only way there's a bit of an australian twang there there's the mate so i'm getting a feeling that you're australian is that right or is that i am exactly that i am a part of the commonwealth originally from australia and uh moved over actually spent some time in the us before now four years on i'm coming to you live from tel aviv israel excellent so um i've got here my little sort of one line about you is that you're the founder of multiply me and scala which enables e-commerce business owners to work on their business not in it by making it more professional so yeah tell me a bit about that sort of mission what what is it you guys do yeah so so our mission is pretty simple uh there's a lot of incredible entrepreneurs and amazon and e-commerce business owners coming up into the world very very quickly learning things you know as as quickly as the rate changes in this space and our sole purpose is how do we help you achieve and unlock more by finding either professional talent out of the philippines and helping with that lower cost of living work arbitrage in the philippines or from our consulting solutions how do we help build better systems to enable you like you said michael to work on your business rather than in it oh um the multiply me bit is where you hire people you can hire people in from the philippines is that right absolutely and escala is the consulting side yeah so so multiply me as a as a baseline end-to-end executive search and hr function into the philippines so it's effectively done for you helping you understand the right roles the right responsibilities the right job description who you actually need for your business and then we'll do everything from sourcing that person to integrating them into your business and helping you make sure that you can run remote teams and escala we effectively deploy seal team six into your business which is typically two consultants and we'll help audit or assess because audit is not a sexy word at all so we'll assess what's happening in your business from a process perspective and we'll effectively build you a better system the right people the right sops training videos documentation and the right technology to enable that to live on so that you're not diving deep in day and day great so that sounds quite sort of uh corporate and complex so i guess um you've got a quite a corporate background having so tell us a little bit about your background and then let's plunge into today's topic but just before we do that yeah so real quick i spent 10 years in creative advertising in marketing so i was the creative side of the suit life um you know when you talk about corporate world so i used to work with mastercard sony mercedes-benz medtronic large enterprise clients delivering digital strategy but always from smaller businesses i was the 10th employee in australia we grew to about 35 i was the 15th in l.a grew to 40 and so the whole position i've had historically is professional client services but now the approach is how do we actually enable the small to medium enterprise space how do we help service the people that need it the most rather than waiting until you're the size of apple to be able to afford effectively a consulting team like accenture or deloitte or you know kpmg etc so that's that was my background until i found my way into the amazon space myself i helped take a business from two to five million in 12 months that was effectively acquired by thracio and on the back of that created these two solutions to enable what we did for that amazon business for all e-commerce businesses globally and this has just continued to roll and the service delivery model continues to evolve and our ability to help and you know you know impact more lives and effectively have them doing the things that they're best at rather than the things they're forced to do day in day out yeah do what they're best at yeah i guess that's the dream isn't it so but just to reflect on what you're just saying i guess what what you've had is you've had a blend of consulting with big corporate clients but within a smaller company so you're very used to being small part of a small fast-moving company and then he brought that to a very specific relevance to amazon sellers so that's really fantastic um level of relevance is is fantastic so you've done what many dream of which is to sell a business although we need to talk about that what do you do afterwards question which you flagged up week when you put a pin in that and revisit that but um so obviously growth is one thing but i one one of the questions uh that i guess there are before we get into the even the plan thing what is it we're trying to achieve because everyone talks about growth they seem to be obsessed with that do you think that's actually what is the word that what is the thing that we're growing and do you think that's even a valid approach yeah well i could tell you now on on the end of a very uh very immense growth period um that i don't think that growth is the term that you should really focus on it should be either scale or efficiency or really understanding what it is you want to achieve in life and i literally had someone on another podcast you know i i was asked he was asked a question like you know what's the growth being like how's it going i said well we had a team of four in january of 2020 we're now at 140 you know a little over 12 months on and they said to me i'm so so sorry for you and so while people push growth they don't really think about the implications of well what does it mean let's talk about an amazon business what does it mean where now i'm doing you know a million dollars of revenue versus 5 million versus 10 million what does that mean for your capital how much money do you actually need to continue to reinvest what is that what's that actually going to cost you how many people do you need do i need to now become a manager so i think that it's probably a little short-sighted just to focus on growth and as someone who's been through this journey now multiple times i would say that think a little bit more about the end game and the driving desire of what your life should look like and what you want to achieve before obsessing over i need to grow more revenue i need to sell more product i need to sell more services i need to bring on more people really consider what those implications might look like yeah i like that the reality check is everyone obsessed with growth but i think the massive danger within amazon business is that you without even realizing it i was going to say you don't just swallow the kool-aid you imbibe the atmosphere that amazon creates that that literally millions of third-party sellers engage in and that is growth at all costs and what that generally means is actually you know obsessing about ranking which means that you're selling more units that definitely makes amazing more money at least make some revenue i mean but as a third-party seller i think it makes some profit as well i mean that their first body sales lose them a lot of money so um but what i'm always concerned is i see so many amazon businesses they get to a million dollars mark and they go well i'm making five percent profit margin but when i get to three million dollars growth then i'm going to get to pay myself and i'm always very alarmed at that point because i think this obsession with revenue is is just amazon's game for us what's your thought about that i know it's we haven't got onto the how to do it yet but i just think it's the goal piece is important so let's talk about that i mean is that is revenue even something you should target is it something you should target but with with care what are your thoughts about that well i would i would uh i would come back to you and say it depends what your end objective is if it's to sell your business then you know in its current state ebitda would be the thing that i would be thinking about just given that amazon businesses typically are looked at as a effectively a new asset class and a commodity that's being sold to aggregators and beyond but um to answer your question about the obsession around revenue another person i spoke to recently and he'd be a great guest for you if you haven't had him before his name's tyler jeff coates and he's the founder and ceo of seller accountant they're a fractional cfo and accountancy for amazon businesses and he actually did a study and he said that amazon businesses business owners are typically most profitable between zero and 1.5 million and then when they hit that 1.5 million mark they start to lose that profitability if they can get past that 4 to 5 million mark that's when they start to reclaim some of that profitability and that really breaks down to when you are an owner operator and you're you know solopreneur or founder whatever and you go through that process you can get to a certain number of things in any given day so you can handle your ppc management your inventory and the supply chain and logistics and the manufacturing but as soon as it gets without you know out of that range of you know i can touch it i can actually handle that much work that's when you start to really lose those efficiencies so for anyone who can figure out how to create those economies of scale and those processes and systems to get them above that you know i'm just using arbitrary numbers here based on their findings but if you can get past that level of 4-5 million that's when you start to recoup those things or if you're really smart and maybe when we get into the topic about planning for you know starting a business you can avoid all those you know those pitfalls all together if you're very calculated and precise on how you approach it that's a very interesting set of numbers that that the what's his name jeff we ought to let people talk tyler jeff tyler jeff coates okay well i'll look him up i mean sounds like a good person for people to check out and we'll definitely get on the podcast by the sound of it sounds very relevant but it's very interesting numbers but that would tie in with my experience with my clients because you can basically be a solopreneur with no team not even a va up to 1.5 million dollars is about the limit i've seen certainly you've got a couple of clients that do one's doing about four million dollars a year run rate the other one's getting closer to 10 and at that rate you know they've normally got staff and there's a real jump actually because those guys have got some legacy businesses but they've both got the staff i think 20 and 40 respectively and actually the 40 staff is with the 4 million business which worries me but you know they've been in business for generations so i guess they know what they're doing doesn't necessarily mean it's efficient i mean that would be a fascinating place to send your your consultants in to do an audit or assessment but uh um yeah it's interesting that there's certainly a jump and i think that that's presumably where the money goes right it's staff i i imagine is is that really your understanding yeah i would say that it probably goes into a whole lot of um areas uh yes staff i mean you stop managing your ppc as efficiently as you might have once and so then you start to lose money i would say you know think about think about everything that happens as you grow the business so more inventory is required that means more shipments need to come through so as you're going through this process every single thing that was once this very clearly defined very niche small circle becomes ever expansive so i would say that that becomes bleeding across each of them you know you maybe you try and you hire your first few people you bring on the va they're not really delivering all of a sudden you know you're out of stock there becomes a lot of moving pieces in that puzzle and it just becomes more complex if you don't build out the right processes to to actually give it the same attention i'll give you one really simple example is as you have say from move from three product skews to 35 most people struggle to actually take real control over the entire gamut of every single screw they have in their arsenal so the top three products will effectively become the best performers and then everything else gets left behind and as a result you're bleeding money into products that aren't yielding you a positive roi but here you go there you go michael you've got your growing revenue which everyone wants but you're not really looking at the profitability and in a lot of cases you're probably losing money on you know those bottom five six seven products yeah and that sadly i see a lot of that and it's interesting that i've always thought that the answer is to consider chopping them out but maybe the answer is what you're implying is just work on the the processes and the efficiency and yeah some products won't make money and you've got to look at that but it's interesting that that um yeah there are certain points that show up quite repeatedly and i think the patterns are quite consistent it's odd isn't it you're saying that number the cfo guy jeff um tyler tyler jeff coats and i see the same thing so there's a consistency about it silica i think we clarified that just growing revenue isn't in the aim that we got some some blocks to overcome i guess um is planning the answer to this i know entrepreneurs are are not big fans of planning and to some extent you know they just do it nike kind of um slogan hopefully they'll not listen to this and come after me for ip infringement here but um you know that that idea is very very popular it's almost like a sort of quasi-religious belief um why is what you mean you mean hustle harder hustle hardy yeah why is the hustle thing so you know not enough i mean look i'm just talking about my personal experience here and for me i find it somewhat of a frustrating uh term because you know the great equalizer in life is that we all have 168 hours in the day so every time someone turns around and says you're not working hard enough well i would argue that there's only so many hours and if you you know you tell me one entrepreneur who came to you and said right my objective was to start this business and work 225 hours a week every week you know um whatever you know that that's not that's not the goal i would imagine of most entrepreneurs unless they are clinically you know labeled a a workaholic here so i would say that when you have effective planning and when you actually understand what it is you set to deliver on that's when you can start to make good decisions on how best to invest your time so that you can split it up you know accordingly i would even take it further and saying that you know your your reference point of you know you're seeing a lot of the same thing tyler jeff coats makes the same notes is that maybe you should cut some of your products but maybe you should just realize that with that time allocation if you were to allocate the same amount of time to you know whoever's writing your copy and your image design and your listing review and your ppc and you actually did you know a clear planning on how much time and resource and allocation is needed then you'd be more inclined to hire the right people for the right tasks and scale effectively rather than you know becoming almost i would say firstly being burnt out but also you know resenting the thing that you once loved so much yeah that's excellently presenting the thing you once loved so much is that's one of the saddest outcomes i think that we have this weird relationship to the business especially with amazon because we kind of don't own the business in in some ways the most important elements of it and no traffic conversion um you know customer trust customer relationship all those things that i'd want really for a business with an amazon based business and even even the language is conflicted and weird and they can't find good language that's the hint that you're never going to find it because it's not really your business and that that relationship to amazon's a whole different therapist needs a therapy right but you're absolutely right that that's a really sad outcome and as you say nobody comes into the business say i work x hours but yeah if you're not a workaholic that's a weird thing to say if you are a workaholic you need help and yet there seems to be just as you know i don't know being an alcoholic was once you know and being addicted to cigarettes was once almost kind of supported by the culture like marlborough man all the guys smoking in the movies the 30s 40s 50s people drinking all over the place you know i i would argue some you know porn addiction has be kind of almost normalized but that's a whole different thing but i mean also workaholism seems to become almost normalized in a specific subset and you make a very good point that that's exceptionally not only really unhealthy but it's not why you entered the the pool in the first place is it so so how do we do we banged the nail on the head enough of people are probably going out yes i get it i'm experiencing that so how do we overcome this how how do we create the the planning without sort of drowning in yet another you know um back-breaking task involving spreadsheets as one of my clients put it recently you know he's doing millions a year he said yeah basically my life is email and spreadsheet so how do we get outside of that that detail and get a bigger picture yeah well like i was telling you before we jumped on um one of the things that i did uh when i was looking to build multiply me as a business outside of that amazon business that i that i walked into so that was already established is i built something called a business model canvas and a business model canvas is effectively a one-page business plan the goal is very simple it's broken up into i believe about seven sections and i'll see if i can remember them all but effectively what you're looking to do is you're looking to understand well how is my business going to run so you know what are the key partners that i need to have in this business what is the cost structures that drive it you know what what are the revenue streams how am i going to generate money are three key areas inside of it what resources do i need what are the activities that i need to perform you know i think most importantly before you even get into any of these things around where's the revenue coming from what are the cost structures is what is my value proposition so what am i bringing to market that i uniquely am delivering that my perceived customers which customer relationships is another one is are gonna add value to their lives so for me i'm also a huge believer in that uh businesses shouldn't exist to sell products they should exist to create value and so i think from a from a starting point rather than just jumping into it and starting an amazon business and figuring out like i'll give you one hot tip make sure that you're doing accrual versus cash-based accounting that's a mistake that i would say 90 percent of amazon businesses who just jump into it will make but back to business model canvas you know understanding the right channels and the customers segment so those are i think each of the topics here to be totally honest i'm reading off a business model canvas in front of me so i can say it but you know those are some key things that you really need to look at is is why am i creating this business who is who is this person or these people who are the customers that are going to want to buy into it and you know where's the profitability forget the long-winded excel spreadsheets which in my advice would come next um because you really have to understand it i wish that everything i was doing was not for profit and i was working at a ngo and you know i think ultimately that'll become my my outcome in life but for right now unfortunately we live in a capitalistic world and these are all things that you should probably consider when you start a business excellence but spoken like a amon israel and censor television it's funny that i know um so it's slightly irrelevant but not really to the value the the values that we hold i don't want to go down a rabbit hole here but since you've referenced it i think there's often a conflict between this kind of and i think that's part of the hassle culture it's a kind of the objective is money which is never enough i think freud said um what everyone needs is love and work he didn't say sex and money uh i think the introduce internet's trying to be reductionist and make sure it's all about sex and money so to your point we have to have something we care about i guess in israel they have that the tradition i know a couple where the guys literally got a company to go in public so he'd be worth tens of millions of pounds soon and uh the wife was grew up in the kibbutz which is very kind of hippie in 60s right so that it's not it's not the tel aviv is the perfect location on the planet to sort of try and combine those two ideas right the high tech startup thing and also the heart thing but slight slight digression but what i would say is um just reflecting what you're just saying i guess what you're saying is the ups it offers it to the just do it then so you're actually suggesting that people think before they leap which is almost heretical are you even allowed to say that the guys would be crunching through the ceiling when you go back to la next but joking apart i think this is um from what i see yes i see people that hesitate and overthink before they start and those are the people we're addressing but the people who are in it and and struggling and sweating and experiencing all the things you're saying working you know crazy hour weeks i like your 200 hour a week by the way that's like the opposite to the four hour work week haven't really got any idea from the conceptual level of why their business exists and what it is they're even doing they're just doing the do as one of my clients puts it and not coincidentally um very very little profit so so let's let's work through this uh business model candace by the way the fact that you're working off something a simple thing in front of you and that's how you remember it is an excellent idea to have the thing you know so we are going to give people a version of this aren't we so if you go to just while i think of it we'll mention it again at the end uh amazingfba.com forward slash multiply m-u-l-t-i-p-l-y although if you can't spell multiply there might be an issue here anyway but um so we will give you a version of this business model canvas tool so let's talk through which is the the most important thing out of all the things you mentioned which is the starting point would you say well do you know what before i jump into that you actually um you actually touch on i would say an important book and an important person in tim ferriss and the four hour work week and one of the things that he did and you know when you talk about what's my value proposition which i think is probably the most important thing about business model canvas but he made a decision i read this about him where he understood for him to go to an ivy league school and to make all these relationships and to do all the things that would enable him to create businesses he actually said well you know what that's gonna cost me a hundred thousand dollars or two hundred thousand dollars to enroll and to pay for board and all these things what if i invested that money differently because his objective was to learn so he actually ended up buying into uh i don't know how many businesses it ended up being but somewhere in the vicinity of 50 to 100 businesses if i'm not mistaken one of them i think was even uber uh where he bought enough he put enough money into each of these businesses small small investments i think he was saying like everything was under 30 000. most were under five thousand dollars and he would have enough seats to sit on the board and learn and give advice and have value even without having it at that point so you know when you're starting a business uh and tim ferriss is a great example of really thinking about what's my desired outcome what i want to achieve in this business is it just to make money then who really gives a what it is look at the profit margins look at the customer base understand what you can sell and and off you go but if it's something more if it's something that is you know uh an area where you want this to live uh for a long period of time then you know you probably want to look a little deeper than just you know like you said sex and sex and money yeah love and work right i mean the thing is that a lot of people who have zero need to work financially ever again including jeff bezos elon musk and also some some people that i know personally and and people like seth godin whatever that's still working because that's part of what defines us although the workaholic defines ourselves perhaps only by work but it is part of what we do it's not just you know make passive income which is a total not a myth anyway isn't it i mean let's let's just knock that one out and also um sitting on a beach in thailand i mean that's a kind of slightly meaningless life i mean it might work for some people but i can swear by everything that's holy that it will not work for the sort of person who's is capable of creating business as tim ferriss put it memorably in a four-hour work week if you're the sort of person that's capable of working hard enough to retire um after a week of retirement you'll be so bored you'll be sticking bicycle spokes in your eyes which is a very visceral image i remember that piece of language but to your point people take an awful lot of the wrong things from than tim ferriss and i think the four-hour workweek title is the least good thing he ever produced and that he probably regretted it ever since and that's because he he got it by google advertising which is a great way to it's direct response thinking right um so he got a title that would give a good response but unfortunately a title of a book's a branding decision and that should not be driven by the right response i'm sure he's totally aware of that and i and regretted it since but people throw the baby out with the bathwater there sometimes so i i really like that that little story about him that's that's worth bearing in mind so let's get into the the business model canvas details itself so we you the first thing you said is value proposition is that right so tell us more about that what is it so so so you know what i think just using multiply me and i could even potentially pull this uh up and i'd be happy to even share the the you know assuming there's nothing sensitive in there but i can't imagine there would be i'd be happy to share the multiple me's original business model canvas when i looked at so when i looked at the multiply me business i i effectively had built this internally inside of an amazon business and understood the impact you know we were able to scale extremely quickly and scale is we weren't over indexing on our investment and simply throwing money at it we were leveraging talent that cost a fraction of the price of locally sourced or in the us or uk or australia for that matter we found high quality talent we built a system that enabled us to continue to recruit you know high level talent into the business so i realized was that there was a huge lap gap in the market and so the first position was what is the value proposition what how can we impact people's lives so that they can live like we did uh an opportunity where we got to work on the business and i would say what was working on the business mean for the typical amazon seller that's the things like effectively new product creation how do i find new products things that i'm excited about you know how do i do that next trip to canton fair how do i effectively not worry about the financials because i've placed a financial controller or cfo in the business so when you're going through this starting point understanding what it is as value what's the value that you're creating that's the first and foremost important thing and then when you start to to pair it back well then you have to understand well what resources do i actually need to then bring this to market and what are the activities that i need to achieve with those resources that will enable me to bring that value proposition to market so that's that that would be the starting point and then you know as you start to move and i can't remember off the top of my head exactly i know the way in which they build quadrants inside of the business model canvas some are related to the financials versus some break-in but i'm not running off the top of my head here but from there once you understand what it is it's a product or a service that you're delivering and you understand who's involved and what resources you need that's when you can start to look into well what does my audience look like relationships do i have to have with my customers and what are the potential segments that i could fit into am i going to reach them so what are the key channel partners so if i want to break this down into an amazon business you know i have to understand specific niche that i'm going after how big are the potential keywords um you know how far uh how far are we actually looking to push this product what's the level of competition that exists and then that's when you also start to go into the less sexy stuff and that's the what are the cost structures and and where are these revenue streams actually coming from so at a high level that's what it looks like okay cool so um let's just deal with uh a couple of those things um so this sounds like reasonably straightforward stuff um from the high level they're not difficult questions to ask i guess they're hard to answer right but what would you say is it that stops people actually doing this because i'm sure that quite a few people listening will have vaguely heard of the business model canvas but why don't people actually get down to this stuff or what are the mistakes they do when they do yeah i would say that you know the the typical entrepreneur is trying to dive in and just say well we'll figure it out we'll just keep you know we'll keep pushing we'll just keep pushing and we'll see what sticks and you know i could keep throwing a million cliches out too you know fail to plan plan to fail you have to have something in place in order to understand what you're measuring again so i would say that while it's very tempting to simply just get going and run forward um i would say that the quote that exists on every one of the decks that were typically sent out now consulting practice is that it's an abraham lincoln quote and it says if i had four hours to chop down a tree i'd spend the first i'd spend the first night if i had six hours to chop down a tree i'd spend the first four sharpening my axe and so the whole you know the whole notion of having a game plan so when you have a business model canvas and so they're not they're not doing it because it's much more tempting to say right well i found the product where sources from in china or vietnam or thailand or wherever i'm sourcing from i've got it to amazon i'm understanding where it sits you know this is all good it's with fba we're starting to sell but what it doesn't allow you to do if you don't have this level of plan and this is very baseline planning but but if you don't have that level of planning in place then you might have rapid swings to say right well this product didn't work i'm going to start a whole new product and new shipment new freight container whereas if you really track and measure and understand well this is the degrees in which i'm prepared to operate within i'm making micro adjustments i'm not sort of throwing the baby out with the bath water so to speak every time things don't go to plan you know if you have a series of parameters from a business perspective that you operate inside of you can make adjustments without a plan you're simply flying blind so yeah to get back to it i'm a i'm a big believer as much as i love to be the entrepreneur and start you know i'm running two businesses here we've got a hundred and whatever team members on staff and we're already thinking about what's the next business that we're working on and we're building technology and all these things every time that we're going through this process we're still building a plan and we're saying well what does success actually look like 12 months from now three years from now you know what are we trying to achieve is that realistic is that attainable is that a smart goal specific measurable i forget attainable uh time whatever i'm just trying to remember so specific measurable appropriate realistic timed i think but people come up with a different version of every year but you're right it's going to be the same sort of basics yeah i guess uh yeah failure to plan planning to fail is is a classic one but also there's there's a british version that that involves swearing which i'll try and stay away from from american cousins who seem to not likes wearing blessing i'm always amazed at how polite americans are compared to brits i'm sure they have a an idea that we're polite over here but we're not really but um yeah the other thing i like is that abraham lincoln quote i mean basically i suppose what you're saying is that planning is basically sharpening your you know your weapons and that's actually the best use of the time even though it doesn't feel like it feels like you should be hacking a tree with a blunt piece of wood um i like that a lot so um let's transition i've just got one more question that i wanted to ask about this i mean you talk about what a success looked like 12 months from now two years etc at some point as you said let's reverse let's let's deal with that three to five year horizon where for a lot of the people that i deal with uh as clients or colleagues of mine the idea is to sell a business but obviously a lot of us don't really think much beyond that because it's such a big objective and the money is so attractive i mean you know a seven figure exit which is extremely achievable for a lot of people with a healthy multiple because their business is defensible and has got a decent ebitda or sde i.e pre-tax profit right whatever we're going to call it but most people don't have a game plan for what happens after that that sale as you pointed out to me before the show so tell me more about that i mean what what's how do you even plan for that suddenly you're off the merry-go-round you've gone for your 80 hour work weeks and then tumbleweed yeah so i'll tell you another great person to speak to about this topic and even greater detail and that would be a guy by the name of ryan tansem who has a podcast called intentional growth if i'm not mistaken and we we sat down we had a great chat about this and you know there's a lot of the clients that that i'm working with too they're looking to exit in the next you know 12 18 24 months and i think one of the things that you need to consider as well when while it is super attractive to exit that business and i would also say as well if you know the business valuations are not always going to be the same things shift there's also more risk as your business grows and with more risk becomes more liability and more liability means that you know things might not you know come to fruition so i would say that one of the important things when you're considering exit is well what does my life look like today you know are you drawing money from the business i would say typically amazon businesses you know we're talking about it before they're not drawing all that much money because it's very expensive to continue to reinvest and and do larger and larger inventory runs so that becomes an issue you know one of the inhibitors for people to grow is that growth capital how do i keep financing this and you know i've mortgaged the house i'm taking on you know all the different channels and vehicles and enable money but i'll say that the considerations are well what does my lifestyle look like today could i perceivably keep running this business for the next 10 20 30 years grow even maintain and stay relevant and i'm taking money every year and living a good life because as soon as you sell that business be a huge payout or a decent payout or an enormous payout whatever it looks like that is that's the end of the honeywell right there so you really have to think about well what am i going to do with that investment you can't just simply say right i'm going to buy three ferraris and a boat and two houses you're really going to be you're really going to need to focus on what your life looks like so how you invest that money so i would say really like if you take anything away from this uh this episode it's it's think about what your options look like and plan out what the next stage is that makes sense uh i like that the reality check by the way you're not going to buy two ferraris a boat in two houses there is something about the uh that's a good phrase um there's something about the word million that is culturally uh particularly i guess in america but it's kind of like you know when america sneezes britain catches cold and probably the same in australia from what i can gather is that the word millionaire has got such a ring to it but that's from the 1920s there's this thing called inflation so a million isn't what it used to be i mean like a million but probably buy a third of a house in my street here i mean and then you know you're still gonna mortgage for the rest of it and then you've got to eat and then you don't actually have a car so um yes it it's actually it's a significant enough enough amount of money to be a really big goal but weirdly not big enough to solve a lot of life's problems right since it's just about enough for a retirement fund for one or two people i guess isn't it so i guess what you're saying is uh it's it's not quite enough to live on i mean so what how do people actually deal with this and there's clients that you've worked with if you work with clients who've gone through an exit and what do they actually typically do when they've actually sold an amazon based business for example yeah so so the easiest answer to that is that typically speaking most people will go again virtually straight away so they'll take the learnings that they've had in building that first business and they'll go straight into selling on amazon into that second business because the opportunity is still absolutely there you know if you can get that exit on the books and you have some level of financial security you don't reinvest every last sentence in the newest business and you don't you know buy by these ferraris and you know i mean that million dollars wouldn't even buy half of this apartment this tiny little apartment that i'm sitting in in the past so yeah i mean you really have to be talking about eight you know eight-figure exits these days for to to last a an absolute lifetime which is pretty pretty crazy to think so that's typically the next move is is getting back into it learning and running things more efficiently than they had taking on that learning if you have a non-compete with that specific product then you know you should probably also when you're looking to exit really understand what the terms look like and what does that look like there's lots of different and interesting ways in which particularly the aggregators are looking to acquire businesses you know you can sell off a large portion of it and remain as product development in in some instances and continue to do what it is you've done and reap sort of the back end benefits of the growth of business and additional product categories so yeah long long long answer for what should have just been something very simple as they're typically jumping straight back into it or like we discussed before becoming a consultant and saying this is what i've achieved this is how i can achieve it for youtube and take you through that process which i think both very viable solutions that's great and i know i like you the reality checks in there no need to apologize for the detail as you said i've not had anyone articulate that but frankly you need an eight-figure exit to last a lifetime which sounds ridiculous but when you run the numbers if you live in anywhere with any kind of cost i had no idea tel aviv was so expensive but north london's like that and you know a particular london for stop new york san francisco i know sydney is just crazy crazy expensive because the prices didn't really get down doesn't really have a financial crisis in 2008 but i just say it's uh yeah a lot of locations in the world where you do need really serious money just to buy a flat and to sit in it without living in fourth the fourth most expensive city on planet earth right now in tel aviv very interesting i had no idea but i mean yeah that goes to show that there's many many locations in the planet where life is that expensive and so yeah even if you live somewhere cheap i guess you know like it comes down to personal planning doesn't it so i guess we ought to give you a chance to to remind us what it is you do because you've got the two sort of offers so just uh remind me so you've got a scala and multiply me so just lay out for me what the difference is and what you do for people yeah so i'll keep them separate so escala is their ent is is effectively it's a management consultancy focused on process improvement what we do is we systemize your business specifically in the e-commerce space so we will come in and we will um analyze assessed we won't use the word audit again what is happening inside of the business uh based on your current state processes will then make a series of recommendations that might be seven might be 27 on how do we make your company an enable of scale or also sale and what that looks like is typically a two to four month project depending on the size of the business sometimes it can go up to 12 months where two of these consultants will actually build in your optimal workflow right that you need to piece the videos documentation we effectively commit the business to an operating system and it helps effectively you know like we said before remove you from any of the nuanced details inside of it and enables you to continue to do the things you love while while having a system in place it also obviously really helps businesses set up for exit so you know based on knowledge transfer and sops if a potential acquirer can understand very clearly what it is that your business does it becomes more attractive to additional buyers so that's that's the escala offering multiply me is our end-to-end executive search and hr function in the philippines where we'll actually help guide you through the types of roles that you need so rather than having and we won't we won't place a va a virtual assistant i don't like that term by any stretch of the imagination actually if anyone you speak to my operation talks to you they'll tell you how much i hate it because it ruined someone's career so we're looking for ppc specialists inventory or logistics specialists creative directors designers web developers specialized skills that we help define the roles and responsibilities inside of the business we'll then go and source that time we'll vet we'll go through sometimes hundreds of candidates to get to a top three and then once assuming one of them is is the right fit then they'll move to the onboarding stage where we feel the kpis and expectations we handle the performance management ongoing we do the internal or sorry the external hr function for you so the whole objective is how do we better integrate personnel who are even ones that aren't familiar with working with teams how do we make sure that it sticks and it's something that is viable because even even if staff is significantly cheaper in the philippines if they're not the right fit culturally and there's an output and a service delivery it doesn't work so don't don't also look at it as well this is a solution to all of my problems and it's way cheaper you also have to have that level of investment and understanding well i need to understand how to be a better manager in order to achieve it too yeah it makes sense and by the way yeah i'm not a big fan of virtual assistants for the simple reason they're not virtual they're real people it's just that the contact form happens to be online but then you and i aren't virtual we're just talking online everything's online now i think that the pandemic if nothing else has forced everyone to stop this uh artificial differentiation between online and offline working as if there's somehow it's a different mode of communication and it has its limitations but the work is just as real so yeah absolutely with you and by the way also um i've got a va i suppose i would call normally just because lazy language and everyone gets what i mean but an assistant in the philippines who works with me and and she i would hire on the spot in london in fact i would struggle to find somebody with her work ethic uh in london not to say that in london because it's so multinational a lot of people can't really speak good english here english is superb so there are some amazing people in philippines also happen to be more affordable but i would say amazing people is the key to your point and obviously that's what you guys are amazing at so if people want to use let's just separate this out then so if people want to get in touch with you at a scala i'm guessing that like most management consultants you off some kind of free consulting call is that right and if so how do people get hold of yeah so so you can check out we are escala.com and on it there's actually a booking link that's to my calendly i'll walk you through exactly what it means i'll actually take you through visually what the experience looks like and from there we'll we'll give you a free consult where you'd sit with our director of consulting and my co-founder and he would actually ask you a whole series of questions about what's happening in your business what are the challenges what's the problem that you really need to solve and so i would say if nothing else it's going to help you think about your business a little differently yeah i'm always a big fan and without wasting other people's time of saying to my clients to give in doubt go and talk to experts in this stuff particularly when it comes to people who buy and sell businesses because they look at the business as a whole but you guys also have a same kind of approach right so you helping to diagnose the weak points and and the you know the the sellable points if you like of your business is a fantastic conversation for anyone to have i'm a big fan of pushing people to do that whether or not they sign up with the person in the end and then the multiply me thing um if people want to uh approach you for that then um yeah where do they go for that yeah so multiplyme.com at mii.com and on that you get booked into cat who is our director of client engagements over at multiple i mean she's amazing firstly um but she will walk you through the process she'll also be more than happy to share any job descriptions around the roles that make sense for you as a business so you can sort of have an insight into what's a realistic accountability responsibility and expectation to ask of of talent you know like people come and they say we need we need ahead of marketing and you know one once you sort of peel back a few questions you realize that all they really wanted to do was drive more traffic externally to their product and so really what you needed is a google ad specialist for example because they didn't want to invest in building a team that's required for seo so it should be happy to have that conversation with you um and you know we're gonna have in the coming weeks and months we're gonna have a lot more material on on all that what the dna of an amazon business looks like from a personnel an operational perspective and a whole lot of things so as soon as i've got their michael i'd be happy to share them with you yeah that'd be useful to have that conversation what i would say to anyone listening is that look i mean um and total transparency um a lot of i guess we have a referral agreements in place we bring the guests on because part of what we're trying to do is get work but in the end if somebody who knows a lot of stuff is prepared to speak to you for free i would always just take that offer for the simple reason you're going to educate yourself i think this apart from things as you said uh towards the beginning your need one of the things that happens is we just plunge in and we're doing stuff but we have no idea what the industry is that we're in and the drivers of it we have some ideas about the industry i guess but we don't really understand business structure and how that works because we've never been educated about it and so i think um that the chance to educate ourselves about it with people like yourself who's worked for consultancies and hired serious consultants who who understand corporate structure is just a great opportunity so um i would encourage everybody listening to do it period if you have a serious amazing business and presumably you guys will only work with businesses above a certain kind of size we'll be able to help people above a certain size and what sort of what is your sort of ideal person you can help the best yeah so i mean across both businesses the the businesses were working mostly with at the one percenters so they'd be sort of doing over a million dollars in amazon but i mean we're working with client on the oscar side we're working with clients you know some now north of 75 million annual revenue and we're working with probably six or seven aggregators right now helping build out their operational infrastructure too and on the multiply me side i would say that we're working with smaller clients as well um than the million dollar threshold that is more so am i ready to actually bring someone on in a full-time capacity that's going to serve a function that i really don't want to be doing anymore and i can afford to pay someone you know anywhere from twelve hundred dollars a month to i don't know twenty five hundred dollars a month including all of the services would be sort of a baseline insight yeah and by the way that's incredibly affordable for somebody of the sorts of skills that we've been discussing um so one other thing just to sort of draws us to a close we started and finished with the business model canvas i fear i've taken this down a few rabbit holes here but i think it was all part of the the kind of the pieces of the puzzle that we need to put together to create a sellable business or at least a business that somebody would want to own without going crazy as you say like 80 hour work weeks are probably not the title of a winning book for a good reason unless you're like workaholics anonymous you know 80 hour work weeks how to work your ass off and make no profit that wouldn't sell very well and yet that's the life a lot of us have created for ourselves and i've been guilty of that as well and my wife looks at me and goes what the heck are you doing and to which my response is yeah um i can't justify this we have to change this so you've got a version of the business model canvas template if you go to amazingfba.com forward slash multiply m-u-l-t-i-p-l-y ply and just remind us what what that's going to help us do or what what that consists of in simple terms yeah business model canvas simply put helps you put your conceptual business that even if it's the product that you're looking for into a single a4 sheet or letterhead as they call it in the states which will enable you to make good decisions on what does my audience look like what's my revenue streams what's who do i need and what what is my value proposition what am i actually doing here as a business yeah these are extremely important questions and i think enables you to make good decisions is probably one of the key uh things that uh yeah people often just miss um they just do stuff and actually the more you want to work in management i guess the and and own an asset rather than working it the more you you are going to earn your money by making decisions right which is a very good point um doing stuff is is overrated i guess is the what are the the uh things from this podcast um also i know you've got a two-year financial planner now i guess that you know it's impossible to give somebody everything they need without being a cpa but if um you know if somebody's uh needing that what is that that free tool will do for you yeah so that tool is something that we actually built out to plan a product launch that we had years ago inside of amazon so that takes you through everything from your operating expenses your opex's to your landed cost calculator it has in a two-year financial plan where you can actually drop inside of it examples of what your projected sales price is your targeted a costs knowing that at the start it's typically going to be higher and a few assumptions that will actually give you a two-year cash flow projection you'll understand how much money you need to invest in the business and you make better decisions rather than later on coming into it and saying i really needed half a million dollars not a hundred thousand dollars i didn't think that my ppc plus the reorders around the inventory we're going to factor in at this point this quickly any planning tool that helps you know realistically about the cash intensity or the the working capital requirements for this business and the cash flow is has got my vote so that's if you get that folks at amazing fba.com forward slash multiply m-u-l-t-i-p-l-y i guess i could have spelt it the same as your website but i just thought people would be scratching their heads so um but just to reiterate your website is spelled m-u-l-t-i can you spell it out for me yeah multiply like you just spelt it but instead of the m-e it's m-i-i so it's multiply m-i-i good so we've dodged that bullet with amazing fba.com multiply like we know add spell multiply so that johnny we we have so much we could discuss i know that we we didn't even get around to discussing how to grow a team in e-commerce which given that you scale that you've been part of scaling a team for four to 140 people in a year is extraordinary so we have to get you back on to talk about that if if you're willing but uh let's wrap this up here and uh just last question for you then is what question should i have asked you uh well i would say what question should you have asked asked is how do you approach the recruiting hiring and performance management of talent i'd say that that's the question that i've actually been working very hard on to put some some material to support people so i can't give you all those answers in in a quick uh in a quick example here but what i will tell you is that um understanding the right hiring characteristics so what is the right person uh what do they look like understanding the right behavioral questions and you know what approaching active versus passive recruiting and then getting prepared for your interviews at a really high level in a very short succinct way those are some of the key things that i'd say that's where you should really look at when you're getting ready don't just walk into an interview and expect that you'll have all the answers or the right answers if you haven't planned for it there you go wrapping it all in together i i can certainly say from my experience of hiring i was going to say va but you know a general assistant i suppose i guess their content marketing assistant yeah general assistant executive assistant is probably a better term the traditional thing would be a pa as a personal assistant it's i guess people use va because it sounds like pa but the virtual piece kind of implies out of sight out of mind and that's dangerous thinking isn't it but i can certainly say as a rank amateur when i started with this my first interview was a total car crash and i remember going away thinking wow mike so for somebody who's interviewed a ton of people for a podcast that was shockingly bad and i sat down and i went through it with a with an hr professional and my next one was better but uh yeah the point is it is an absolutely a new skill set so we'll have to get back on to talk about that but obviously this could be the longest podcast in history if we uh do any more about that and i've got to make it absorbable for busy amazon sellers and e-commerce sellers but yeah it just remains for me to say uh big thank you for making us think about the big picture and i really love the message of the hustle culture is not the way to go and and i think anyone who's burnt themselves out for more than a year level mine several in this area can absolutely attest to that so the business model canvas thinking is is really helpful gift to give people to hopefully get back some time and get what they want without getting nuts so um many many thanks for coming on the show thanks for having me and i hope uh people listening at home got some value out of it great well that's the end of the podcast folks and just check if there's uh any other sort of questions that have come in on uh the stream so um yeah it looks like that's it from us um if you've got any other questions if you're uh watching this on youtube then um you are ahead of the the game youtube or um facebook because the podcast itself won't be coming out for about another month or so then do pop any questions in the comments below and yeah i will get in there and answer them but meanwhile thanks very much for watching and stay tuned
Episode details
- Show
- Successful eCommerce Strategies / Product Market Fit
- Host
- Michael
- Guest
- Yoni Kozminski
- Transcript
- 12,051 words (YouTube captions)