Successful Scales · Episode 1 · February 9, 2021

Ep 1: Building Your Dream Team + What Roll-Ups Look For in Brands They Acquire with Ruben Amar - Co-Founder & Co-CEO of Forum Brands

A conversation hosted by Yoni Kozminski. Listen above or read the full transcript below.

In this episode

In this episode, we hear from Ruben Amar the Co-CEO & Co-Founder of Forum Brands.

The co-founder dynamic - The three people driving the business

The importance of the right partners and a team

What it takes to have your brand/business acquired by Forum Brands

What they get into

  • The co-founder dynamic - The three people driving the business
  • The importance of the right partners and a team
  • What it takes to have your brand/business acquired by Forum Brands
  • The difference between managing a 1m vs 5m business
  • Building a brand worth buying

Questions Yoni asks

  1. Would you would you ever consider um and this might be totally wrong but do you ever work with people in an ongoing perspective?

  2. Like what's the what are you guys looking for?

  3. Like, how is it how what's what's the impact being for forum uh in in light of the pandemic?

  4. Have you heard what's going on in China right now?

From the conversation

“Yeah so it's it's a great question and I would say it's very much opportunistic. You know we are a startup we are founders uh that are going to be generally speaking very flexible in in things we do we want to make sure that we address the the key projects of every single founder. Every founder has a different mindset right we we work with some people that are 60 years old and they want to retire. They don't want to do anything else. So for these people it's going to be very easy…”

— Ruben Amar

“Um, and number three is very much to be able to look at the operating opportunity and the big picture. Is this product that we are looking at right now is a product that we can sell everywhere in the world. Will a customer in UK or in Israel where you are Yoni or uh in the United States or Mexico will be as tempted and as appreciated and as satisfied to buy this product. Uh and that's the big question we're trying to address, because we are not in a business of flipping business…”

— Ruben Amar

“Yeah, we see we see these dynamics. And I think it is a good point on like how to be very mindful in ventry management. Because if people have the right tools and the right people thinking about how to best um project and forecast the demand, uh you can you can better manage your orders and your lead times and don't get into situation where you need to pay 12,000 instead of five. So, you know, it has required more foresight and intentional planning, particularly as e-commerce demand spiked in parallel. So not only…”

— Ruben Amar

“Exactly. Exactly. That's unbelievable. Wow, I love that. And you know, back in the days I was not very sales. My English was very limited, but I didn't I wanted to have this like experience of facing the true reality of trying to sell your product in an environment in hostile environment where people don't want to buy your product. Um, and back in the days I didn't realize how much impact it would have on every step of my life. But you know, standing there for 12 hours a day, trying to stop people…”

— Ruben Amar

“I think I think you you touched on the right points. It it comes down to two things ambition and self-awareness. If you have if you master these two, you'll be successful. If you master only one, you might be successful. If you don't master any, it will be a very, very difficult challenge to be successful. And self-awareness, self-awareness is something that you know got me to this space because I knew that I was missing clear skills, and I knew that if I wanted to achieve my big ambitions to be successful as…”

— Ruben Amar
Read the full conversation
Full transcript9,420 words · speaker-labelled source
Transcript note: This transcript comes from the Successful Scales production archive. It may contain transcription errors. Exact quotations should be checked against the audio before reuse.
Yoni Kozminski

On today's episode, I sit down with Ruben Amar. Ruben is the co-founder and co-CEO of Forum Brands, one of the latest players in the Amazon aggregator and roll-up space. We have a really interesting conversation on their journey, on the team dynamic that's driving their business forward, all the way through to what they're looking for in terms of brand partners and how they approach the acquisition process for anyone looking to sell their business. I feel like this is a great episode to get some insights into the guys buying businesses and how they approach partnerships and acquisition. I hope you enjoy. Hi, and welcome to Successful Scales, the show where I interview now successful professionals about their journey and try and garner insights onto any tips that can be applied to your business at home, whether it's financial freedom or the exit of your company, wherever your journey might take you. The idea here is to simply learn from those who have done it before. I hope you enjoy and you get some value out of this.

Yoni Kozminski

Buckle up and enjoy the episode. Ruben, thank you so much for jumping on the Successful Scales podcast. Thank you so much for being here and taking the time. I really appreciate it. Thank you, Yoni. Great, great to be here. Thank you for the invite. Very excited to be sharing my story and forum story with the audience. Awesome. Well, I mean, that's the perfect segue. Um, just you know, we've gotten to know each other a little bit and it's been awesome kind of getting into the minds of what you guys are up to and what you're building. You know, uh, we were just having a talk before, and I was saying um I'd back you guys in on what you're looking to achieve. You've got an amazing team. But for those listening who don't know you or what you're up to, um, just to give a little bit of um insight. Can you tell us a little bit about yourself? Sure. Uh thanks, Yoni.

Ruben Amar

I know we've we've been chatting for quite a while, but it's always good to give some backbone here. So I'm from Europe. Uh, as much as we are based in the US, I'm the European part of the team there. Uh, so bring some uh nice, charming European culture to the team. But I started my career in London uh at a company called Credit Suisse. Um, I was an investment banker in the technology team, very much spent all my time in uh helping large technology companies thinking about their financing opportunities, uh, whether it is an MA, whether it is uh debt financing, and you know, eventually started, you know, working on uh the IPO of Zolando, uh, which is as everyone knows, one of the largest e-commerce platforms in the world today, especially in Europe. Uh, so learn learn early on how attractive the e-commerce space can be and how fragmented is this space. Um, after after a couple of couple of years at Credit Suisse, I decided to move to the investment side. I went to work for an American growth equity firm called TA Associates.

Ruben Amar

It's a Boston-based uh, you know, multi-billion dollars growth equity investor investment firm that basically helps companies scale uh using capital and knowledge and get into other markets and new products that otherwise they wouldn't have been able to do on a standalone basis. So I was based in London, um, working on uh consumer and technology. What it means is that I was uh looking in the market in the European market for companies in the consumer and technology space, or both uh that needed some you know additional capital and help to boost their revenue growth. Um and I worked in very different market sectors. I worked on education, food, um, um, you know, cosmetics, pet, all of the very, you know, highly highly valued and interesting, you know, segments in the consumer space. Um, and during my time there, I uh helped the CEOs and co-founders of these large businesses grow from one or two countries' operations into you know other European countries, the United States, Latin America, Southeast Asia, and all of that was done through a buy and build strategy, where we go into new markets, we identify the most interesting acquisition targets, we acquire these companies, we integrate them using technology into the initial platform based in Europe and create a lot of synergies out of it. And I realized that there's so much value that was created through my time at TA into doing this buy and build strategies. The only thing I was missing is obviously being on my own and being able to be an entrepreneur, uh, but also finding the right large market that is fragmented enough and where you have a lot of technology that can be used to be more and more efficient.

Ruben Amar

Um, and you know, that's how I decided to move to the United States, California, where as everyone in the world think, and our actually write is the place for new technology that is being developed all the time. Uh, and that's where I met, you know, Brenton and Alex, and we we came together and decided to build Forum Brands. Um and I'm happy to give more details about the forum.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, I I would love to, I'd love if you can explain maybe a little bit about what form is. Obviously, I'm I'm pretty familiar um with what you guys are up to. But for those of you know, for those who aren't as familiar with the space, maybe uh a bit of insight would be great.

Ruben Amar

Sure. Um, so maybe I think the the most interesting part is that I I will probably give more details about what is the opportunity we really saw early on in the e-commerce space and more specifically on Amazon. Um, you know, Alex was the was the co-founder, um, and I think it's a good transition to explain a little bit who are the three co-founders. I gave a little bit about my background, but I think that you know, Alex and Brenton who are the two other co-founders, bring together very complementary skills that explain what we are trying to do in the space. So, you know, Alex, Alex was the COO of Forum Brands, uh, you know, his experience in retail buying, supply chain management, cost inventory planning, negotiation pricing, promotion planning, retail PL management, all of that has been done at target.com and Amazon. So he spent you know, five to six years at Amazon, two years at Dalga.com, and you know, he really has this experience into in the go-to-market strategy and execution uh on these e-commerce platforms.

Ruben Amar

So he held every single, every single you know, mid to senior level positions within Amazon. Uh, and he he was the one, for example, that has helped building Amazon Mexico. He has the one that helped consolidating all the fulfillment centers in North America. He has built the Amazon social network on which we have 400,000 people. He has built some of the tools, technology tools that the FBA sellers today around the world are using. And he has received, as an anecdote, he has received two awards from Jeff Bezos uh himself, who I actually just stepped out of Amazon for those who don't know. Uh, but basically Alex has been the one that you know has brought to the team the online retail and Amazon DNA. Uh before, before Alex, I Brenton and I, you know, did not know a lot about Amazon. Now we feel that we became experts thanks to Amazon and the team, thanks to Alex and the team that we brought together. Um Brenton has uh as uh I would say more hybrid profile. Uh he started his career at McKinsey, um, where he worked for a couple of years in Chicago. Uh while he was there, he worked with the largest CPG brands around the world, helping helping them thinking about how to digitalize their supply chain work streams. So he worked with the largest CPG companies like Best Buy, McDonald's, Jru, PNG, Walmart, uh, and got a lot of knowledge about using technology to improve efficiencies on the back end of any CPG company in the world.

Ruben Amar

And then from there, after McKinsey, he decided he was recruited by X or former Bain Capital Partners to launch a new P firm based in Boston called Cove Hill Partners. Uh, they've raised back in the days in 2017 what was the largest first fund ever, uh, which was uh almost uh 1.2 billion dollars. And he helped them scale the company from two employees to 25 in two years. Uh, he was uh an investor uh investing mainly in software companies, uh, but also some in the consumer tech. So there's a lot of knowledge about deploying capital uh in in the United States uh in these in these verticals. And all together, you know, we we clearly have um a lot of passion about investing and consumer. And together we we realized that there was one thing that was missing in the e-commerce space. Um Amazon has created a unique environment for sellers or entrepreneurs all around the world, uh, especially the United States, it represents still the majority of the of the marketplace that Amazon has built to build multi-million dollars companies. Um these entrepreneurs have built incredible businesses uh that you know have have reached a certain level, uh, especially with the I would say COVID hit, uh, whereby they they needed additional help or they didn't they needed additional, I would say, sophistication and technology to grow the business from you know X amount of of revenues to another level of revenues.

Ruben Amar

And it just became overwhelming for them because it's always been a side project. We realize that like with our knowledge and expertise and all the a sort of like centralization of cost and knowledge, we'll be able to get in, um, acquire this Amazon FBA businesses and basically grow them into multi-channel international brands that we want and our goal is to reach every single consumer around the world with our products. And our our strategy is very much in line with some of the other players that you've probably heard about, uh Yoni, uh, is to really much buy our way in by the by being efficient in the way we get into this market, which is buying these brands that are operating on Amazon. But then from there, our ultimate goal and what we are doing, and the people we have recruited so far is very much to you know build these brands into sustainable, long-term valuable brands that can become uh you know, uh accessible to everyone in the world, no matter what e-commerce channel you work on. Wow.

Yoni Kozminski

There is a lot to unpack there, uh, Buddy. I've got to say um really cool to hear the stories of the other co-founders. Um, just how complementary each of your skill sets are makes a whole lot of sense to me sitting and kind of listening to the journey and the story and just how well um put together you are as a unit. And I think that that really touches on the first really important thing that comes into going into business and successfully scaling companies is that you you can never do these things alone. If you've got super ambitious goals, you need to have the right team or the right partners in place and having complementary skill sets where you don't see necessarily 100% eye to eye is is something that just keeps coming up. And I feel like in your story, you really validated that point.

Ruben Amar

Yes, Yoni, this is this is this is exactly right. You know, I'm I'm coming from the you know, mathematical finance world where you know we're always trying to get one plus one equal three. Um the reality is that you cannot do, I mean, it's very difficult to build a business on your own uh without being fully aware of where you lack skills. Um, and the reality is that in this opportunity, we actually started the business only Brenton and myself. It was uh for one or two months, it was literally Brenton and I working on a on a on a on a piece of paper, you know, writing 40 pages about the opportunity, and very quickly we realize that we are lacking some fundamental skills to complement the company. So then you get into this dilemma of do we want to split the pie into three, or do we want to keep only two parts? The question the answer for us was very simple. I'd rather have one third of a pie that is much larger than one half of a pie that is smaller. And you need to be very self-aware on what you need to do to win in this space and what skills you need to have within the founding team, which is basically dictates the DNA of a company to be successful. So this is a uh this is something that Brenton and I very quickly decided uh after only one and a half months of work that we would need to bring these retail Amazon e-commerce experts to complement the team. And from there, Yoni, to your point, not only about the founding team, we decided to take a little bit more time uh in purpose, of course, uh to before acquiring our first businesses, just because we knew that the way we wanted to be perceived in this market is to recruit the best people. We are very, very people-oriented. Results in a company are key, but people that drive these results are even more important. So we emphasize so much all the efforts and the money invested and the time spent to look around the world for the most complementary skilled people to join our team, not only on the Amazon operating team, but also on the investment team, also on the corporate development team. Um, and that's how we we started building a strategy of what we believe will be a game changer or or a reading strategy, is to very much have the best quality team of people that are passionate about consumer, that are self-aware, that think about sustainability in this space. It is a key issue today for Amazon, for example. We are already doing a lot of efforts on like trying to be more sustainable in the way we operate these brands. All of these things are so important as you think about how to build a large and international and expendable and scalable company. And that's something we did since you know the first days of foreign brands.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, that again, like you bring up such a key and important point that you know, at the end of the day, business doesn't drive business, people drive business, and having the best people and investing in your human capital is the engine room for everything else. You can have the best technology on planet earth, but if you don't have the people to actually leverage it and understand how to interpret the data, then you know you've got nothing. So I'm with you on that. And I think that it permeates. And you, as the founding team and senior leadership, you do set the tone for what is acceptable, who to bring in. And hopefully that culture grows and builds into what will be a large brand and a large company one day. Exactly.

Ruben Amar

Exactly. Top B right. And you know, in our first month of operating, before even we did any fundraising to be completely transparent, we did a lot of work on our core values and principles. And the number one that was not even a debate at all between the three of us was that we would want to have an horizontal structure where people matter more than anything else. And you know, uh, especially today, as the world becomes more and more challenging for people because of the speed at which everything goes, uh, the Zoom environment or you know, whatever, whatever software people use. But um, I would just say that like there is some sort of pressure that people have in order to become successful. Um, and some this stress level can turn into some mental health issues and therefore impact dramatically the productivity of a company. So from day one, we wanted to create an infrastructure, an environment where people feel that they are part of a dream, but more importantly, where people are just healthy, where people just go to work with a clear mindset of being happy about the job they do, about participating in a greater in a greater mission and about you know, feel that they are valued for the skills they bring and that they can learn.

Ruben Amar

And you know, that's always easy to say, Yoni. I'm sure that a lot of founders have told you that they are very like people conscious. It actually means much more than just saying, you need to build infrastructure, you need to build the core values from day one. You need to lead a lot of like text around your your corporations to make sure that everyone signed up for these values. And and you know, it took us a lot of work to build that, but we are very happy with the team, you know. In in it's funny because you you met one, our first employee ever, John, uh, who is an incredible person. We can talk about it. But uh now we are a team of 14. And in November, we were only three. Uh, and you know, as as you scale these businesses, and I know that this topic of discussion between between you and I today is about how to scale efficiently a team. Um, it is very important before you hire your first person to make sure that you have a clear, clear structure and and and vision of what your team will be once you have a hundred people and all the efforts that you will do for the first employee, you'll need to make sure that you will do the same efforts for employee number 100. Uh, and that takes a lot of time. So, totally agree with you. People and and structure organization are key, key, key elements for what we'll build in it for.

Yoni Kozminski

I love it. I like you, you are literally you're taking all I don't have smart things to come back to you with because you are you're you're just laying down fire. Um, I couldn't agree more with you, mate. It's uh it's exactly that. It's about the infrastructure that you lay down and the vision in your ability to foresee what the scale is actually gonna look like. You're you're putting the work into plan before you even consider taking those first steps. And just to not skip over that point, yeah, John is how I met you guys, and he is a smooth operator. Like I was so impressed just from meeting John before we ever sat down, and I haven't spoken to your co-founders before. But um, you know, you've got a great team, and and you've invested in the people that are gonna make the difference to whether you succeed or fail in this space.

Ruben Amar

Yes, 100%. Um, and John, as I said, was the first hire. Um, you know, for those who don't know him, John Dirk Derkids is our VP of growth. Um, he's he's what I call a customer obsessed and data-driven operator. So he has 14 years of professional career spanning from management consulting and e-commerce industries. Um, and over the course of his career, he's really developed reputation as uh as a builder, helping D2C brands scale through technology operational excellence. Um, he, you know, he was the head of third-party marketplace for Amazon Canada on the electronics sector. So he managed a PL of $2 billion and was was was in contact or responsible for more than 24,000 sellers uh in in this space, uh, which is which is a meaningful number. Um, he helped recruiting these sellers, he helped, you know, making the life of these sellers much, much better because Amazon is known for being sometimes complex to deal with. It's very difficult to escalate any problem. If you, if you look at what he has built on Amazon.ca Canada on his vertical, it's really, really impressive. And as we think about the DNA, it all comes back to the DNA of people we bring in as like first hires. He is he has done so much in transforming the way we operate these brands, the people that we want to recruit to operate these brands. And more importantly, the vision of what we can do with these brands alongside the selling founders side by side. And I think he brings this like unique, unique perspective and knowledge of how Amazon operates, but more importantly, the sort of like human perspective of building relationship with these sellers, not only from a quick transaction, which might people might think that everything stops there, right?

Ruben Amar

We do an acquisition, we give them some compensation in cash, and then they leave to do another project. What people miss and don't appreciate is that a lot of these sellers are passionate about these brands. They're very proud of the brand they have built. They are very proud of all the works they've done, even as a side project. And they want to make sure more importantly is that the next the next home of their brands is a great home, is a better home, is a home that can become much bigger and can help the brand achieve these goals that they've always dreamed about, but with more knowledge, with more expertise, with more capital. So we see our form brands as a natural next step for a lot of these sellers, but as a partnership. For example, a lot of our deal that we do involve, you know, a certain period of transition where... these sellers can actually benefit from some of the upside of working with Sporum. And they participate to a certain degree. So they will be involved in product development, go to market strategy on new products, All the things they really, really like on a daily basis, but they have already, they had already crystallized a little bit on their efforts.

Ruben Amar

They received some capital out, but they have some skin in the game to keep working with us. And that's what we are passionate about. We are we are beyond, you know, we are brand builders, but the the um the place where Brenton and I come from, we always loved working with entrepreneurs. We are excited about their journey and we love being able to work with them in achieving great goals. And I think that John brings this unique perspective on how we can best work with FBA sellers because he's been working with them for so many years when he was at Amazon. Great, great, great insights there.

Yoni Kozminski

Uh I've got a question for you. I wrote it down before, and I want to come back to it. Um, so we're talking, obviously, you guys are building brands on Amazon, and you know, you'd fall into the category of aggregation, of acquiring, you know, a number of FBA businesses and taking them to the next level, giving them a real home that you know, obviously the the parents, the true parent of the inception of the child that they created that was born into some sort of Amazon uh life. Uh, you know, they want to see them grow up and mature and kind of hit you know, hit adolescent. So you talked a little bit about um kind of the complexities and like the decisions around why someone would sell. And I just love to pick your brain as someone who's also seen it like I have uh running an Amazon business that's that's a million dollars versus running one that's five million, like maybe you can help people understand kind of the journey that a potential seller who might deal with guys like you, like why they might want to work with you and also like what what does it look like from one to five million and five million to 10 million? Like take us on a bit of a journey if he can. Sorry if I'm putting you on the spot. Yeah. Sure.

Ruben Amar

And I think you know, we we've spent um the good thing is Alex knows so much about the Amazon channel. Uh he has spent his career working on that, building it. Uh so he knows both sides of marketplace. I think that you know, we we've talked with many, many, many, many sellers before even launching you know, foreign brands. Uh, many have grown to a size that the burden of ownership has become challenging. And this is definitely this is roughly the I would say the one to two million dollars range where you know, we we've talked with hundreds of these sellers who share the stories about starting the brand to supplement, you know, teacher income or pay for college or buy a house. And they were all meant to be side hustles that suddenly were consuming more time than they ever thought possible. So many sellers fail, failed and actually feel stuck, not knowing really what to do with their business. And what we provide them is is an equitable way to cash out on all of their hard work. And when you think about the the managing a business of one 1 million and 1 half million dollars on a part time basis versus a five million dollars many additional things needs to go right. You need to spend more more time on thinking about other channels on Amazon because having a five million dollars on Amazon becomes more risky than having only one you need to diversify your revenue your revenue streams. You need to be more mindful about how you manage inventory you know having five million dollars business with like hundreds of SKUs becoming more and more challenging if you don't have a team that spends all that time on inventory management on demand planning using the right technology you can very quickly get into a situation of out of stock and if there's one thing Amazon hates more more than anything else is being out of stock. So you want to make sure that you don't lose any momentum that you've built until you reach one million dollars of sales because of an out of stock situation.

Ruben Amar

Marketing becomes more challenging you need to you need to bid and manage you know more search terms more um being more efficient use better uh better terms to target your your customers this this this this means you need to spend more time so if you add up if you add up all of these you know challenges and in a way we see them as more of new opportunities because this is basically the results of these sellers being successful on something that they never thought would be as successful you know we see that as an opportunity for us to get in at the stage where we tell them that look you've been in a you've you've been able to build an amazing business now that you need to reach to this to to the next level of the business we get we get here we compensate you for all the hard work you've done so far and we help you build this business and grow it to the five 10 million dollars because we have not only the infrastructure from a human capital perspective so people that are expert on marketing people that are expert in inventory management people that are expert not just on Amazon infrastructure but also people out of Amazon we have we have recruited people that like will spend all their time thinking about new channels Walmart.com, Shopify, Firgo in the UK, Mercado Libre in Latin America, all these new opportunities we have people you know spending all their time on that um so this is a basically a uh a way a win-win situation where the seller can benefit from you know some some valuation and and and some cash out in compensation for everything they've done but can also have some skin in the game working with us to just reach to the next level uh the next level business perspective and you know reaching this five 10 million dollars that is so difficult to reach on your own.

Yoni Kozminski

Would you would you ever consider um and this might be totally wrong but do you ever work with people in an ongoing perspective? Like would you ever give them a concurrent um equity clip or salary or something while they you know let's say they love the brand they just don't want to deal with everything else but they want to keep pushing it forward and developing would you ever have a longstanding relationship or just do people always cash out.

Ruben Amar

Yeah so it's it's a great question and I would say it's very much opportunistic. You know we are a startup we are founders uh that are going to be generally speaking very flexible in in things we do we want to make sure that we address the the key projects of every single founder. Every founder has a different mindset right we we work with some people that are 60 years old and they want to retire. They don't want to do anything else. So for these people it's going to be very easy it's going to be full cash compensation after closing and they might be involved for two months to make sure a transition goes well but it basically ends there. For people who are younger who are more hungry who keep you know who still have some willingness to keep growing and be involved in the in the space we'll be able to find ways to work with them whether it is a longer earn out structure way they can they can get more money out of the transaction uh you know after the fact and they are still involved in some way whether it is on product development strategy development for the brand um inventory inventory management with our team um supply chain relationship some people had amazing relationship with manufacturers in China why would we don't want to have them involved and help us in not only this brand but on on maybe other brands so we will look at every single case and make sure that the most important thing we'll do on every single case is that we address what the founders or the selling the selling owners of these brands want to do with their life after the fact and we'll be very flexible, we'll be creative. And so far we've done a handful of acquisitions and we we've seen very different scenarios. And it's been going very well because as founders, we respect and listen and understand all the founders. So we'll be amendable and be as as value creative oriented as possible.

Yoni Kozminski

mate You are saying all the right things. um that's that's really that's really interesting and i can totally appreciate that position it's not a one-size-fits-all solution And you have to adapt to the market and what the demand is in your case for founders of businesses, because you know, everyone had their clear vision set out or some form of it. And they, you know, that you have a love for it to whatever degree, whether you're even building a business just to sell it, it's still your baby. You still created something from nothing, and you've brought people together and you've impacted lives, and you know, so I love the the flexibility. Um, I have so many questions for you. So many questions. Uh let me ask you this. So your it's just a very interesting time in the space right now. There's a lot of VC money coming in every other day, you know, there I wouldn't call different aggregators competitors necessarily because everyone has their own strategy, it's a huge market, there's different approaches. It's not it's kind of indirect competition in my mind, um, at least the way I see it. But uh where I'm really going with this is for anyone um who would ever be interested in selling a business. Um, so let's say some of your potential partners, like what are some of the things they can do to get on your radar or for it to be an attractive offering for them? Like what's the what are you guys looking for?

Ruben Amar

Yeah, it's it's uh it's a great question. And I think you know, at the end of the day, we are trying to find these uh these sellers and not them finding us. Uh, we're doing some work on making sure that we are visible in the space. Uh we are publishing great, great blog posts on our website that are being published that you know it's a great great amount of content uh for uh for for you know the FBA owners around the world. Uh but at the end of the day, we are trying, we have a team and we have a technology to be able to find the most attractive brands. So now the question is how do you how do you prepare for a sell? And you know, how do you position yourself to be you know eligible or or in our radar? Yeah, you know, we are we are we are looking for brands that have built great products because we have this DNA of ex-Amazonians in our team, we are very much customer obsessed. So we want to make sure that the products that these you know brands are selling are being very well appreciated by customers. Um, and the best way to look at it is the quality of reviews. So one of the first things we will look at as as a buyer of these businesses is you know the quality of uh the rating of the of each each each single product, but also the number of reviews, uh, the re what we call the reviews mode. Uh so you want to make sure and for for sellers that are listening to us to make sure that like you're always always customer focused and obsessed, because this is the one thing that Amazon wants most importantly, more than the pricing, more than how much you spend on the Amazon PPC.

Ruben Amar

They want to make sure that the customer that is buying your product is extremely satisfied. Uh, so I'd spend a lot of time making sure that I that that uh I build the right number of reviews and the and the right rating. Um the second thing is that we are we are also looking at business models and verticals that for us have um you know are less sensitive to any economic downturn, so that have limited FAD risk. So the things we are focusing on today is very much you know, fitness and health, kitchen, um, pet products, uh personal care, um, you know, sports and outdoor, because these businesses, these verticals, uh, if you think about the consumer world, not only on Amazon, these these are verticals that are very large today, but they will be large in 10 years from now, no matter what the economic cycle will be. The gross margins profile is very, very interesting, it's very high. So there's like room to be able to uh invest in growing the company on more marketing, on more product development. But if you have limited gross margins, you'll have less less freedom into you know growing these businesses. So we want to make sure that like the gross margin profile is interesting. We want to make sure that uh the even the top line growth profile is not too seasonal and not too influenced by you know out of our control factors like you know, uh natural catastrophes or economic crisis or a pandemic. Uh and and you know, we we're gonna be very, very careful and mindful about it.

Ruben Amar

Um, and number three is very much to be able to look at the operating opportunity and the big picture. Is this product that we are looking at right now is a product that we can sell everywhere in the world. Will a customer in UK or in Israel where you are Yoni or uh in the United States or Mexico will be as tempted and as appreciated and as satisfied to buy this product. Uh and that's the big question we're trying to address, because we are not in a business of flipping business around. We're not in the business of like buying a business that is not operating well and flipping it around for one or two years and then selling it. That's not what we do. What we do is that we acquire a high quality business and accelerate the growth. We are accelerators of brands. Uh, and we get from point A and we build it into point B, C D E in a fairly short uh short term using our technology. So generally speaking, I would say if you operate within any of these verticals that I mentioned, if you have a great quality product with great review mode and and you know, a minimum of a four star rating uh in terms of reviews, if you're doing a minimum of 150 or 200,000 SDE in the last 12 months, will be a great partner for us. Uh and would love to discuss, we have a very, very quick and lean process whereby we can give you uh a very quick indication on how we value your business, but more importantly, how we can structure something interesting for you in less than 48 hours.

Ruben Amar

Um, and you know, once we get to uh an LOI stage, which is a letter of intent, where we agreed on a structure and we just need to do some diligence to make sure the numbers are the numbers. We have built incredibly efficient technology tools, thanks to Alex and John's team, whereby it's very limited work from the sellers in the diligence. We we know that they have other things to do, oftentimes they have like other jobs. So we want to make sure that we respect their time and limit the amount they spend on the diligence. So we have built incredibly efficient tools that allow us to be able to get to a closed deal and funding in less than 30 days, uh, with very limited uh with very limited involvement from the sellers. And you know, from there, as as I as you asked me earlier, it will really depend on the types of partnership you want to build with uh with this with these sellers.

Yoni Kozminski

Love it, love it. Um, just adding more proof into just the way in which you guys are looking at the situation and how you can create efficiencies at every stage and like you said, accelerate the process. So I'm really enjoying just hearing for myself kind of how you guys are approaching it. I find it really fascinating. Um, so I'm sure those listening in uh probably probably enjoying uh listening to you as much as I am. Uh you you touched on something, you touched on something just before. Um, and you said, you know, effectively you're looking for businesses that you feel like you can truly accelerate and businesses that also have limited seasonality and effectively limited risk. And you you um actually laughed. I don't know, I don't know if the audio picked it up or you saw it, but you said, you know, or the pandemic. And so that got me thinking, you know, the pandemic has affected every person on planet earth in some way, shape, or form, some disproportionately, you know, very ice, you know, very asymmetrical times we live in right now, um, from whether you're a you know, a parent of a young child and all of a sudden your life is upside down because you can't work effectively to people like me who have no even social commitments anymore. So I'm allowed to work until midnight if I want to, and there's no one who's gonna invite me anywhere to go. And I think it's the same for um for businesses, right? Like, how is it how what's what's the impact being for forum uh in in light of the pandemic?

Ruben Amar

Well, I can tell you it's certainly lit a fire. Um, and the impact that it basically has done to our business is that it has increased the importance of thoughtful data-driven inventory management. Um, lead times have extended dramatically as COVID has placed you know a certain strain on the manufacturing and shipping industry. Have you heard what's going on?

Yoni Kozminski

Have you heard what's going on in China right now?

Ruben Amar

I know, we know, we know it's it's also Chinese New Year.

Yoni Kozminski

But also also this overwhelming. Also, this new, I heard some crazy stories the other day. I spoke to someone I know, um, and he was saying that usually it costs five about five thousand dollars for the pallet they typically send, and they can't get anything on the docs. And if they do, it's costing them about 12,000.

Ruben Amar

Yeah, we see we see these dynamics. And I think it is a good point on like how to be very mindful in ventry management. Because if people have the right tools and the right people thinking about how to best um project and forecast the demand, uh you can you can better manage your orders and your lead times and don't get into situation where you need to pay 12,000 instead of five. So, you know, it has required more foresight and intentional planning, particularly as e-commerce demand spiked in parallel. So not only, you know, not only it has increased some challenges on the supply chain, but at the same time, demand has just like skyrocketed. But it is generally speaking a fun challenge to solve. COVID, you know, if you think about the COVID impact on the positive side, it has sped up adoption dramatically. So it's really important for us to keep meeting consumer needs, especially as e-commerce penetration uh has gained probably you know four to seven years in in less than six months. We want to make sure that we keep you know sticking to our DNA of always meeting consumer demands and needs everywhere in the world. And it just requires more thoughtful and data agreement uh processes that we are very well equipped and have the the people to do. Fantastic.

Yoni Kozminski

Fantastic. Um, so I mean, you talked a lot about you've talked, you've covered a lot of interesting points. You know, you were talking about how you guys are dealing with deal structures and you know, what a what a good partner um looks like. And I think for uh people listening in who are sitting in that that stage in that decision, like it sheds a lot of light into the minds of you know the people um driving these businesses and how far they can take their brands. You know, you you shed a lot of light into the strategy on expansion and how you know the the model is that you're trying to take brands further than they could without that level uh of sophistication and complexity. And I feel um just to kind of wrap this all up, we're we're really entering an age now with you know all these new folks stepping into the space of professionalization of the space. And yeah, it really feels like you guys are you know, you are right front and center in how you're approaching it. Um I have a few more questions before I let you go. So um if it's cool with you, I'd first like to ask I'd like to ask, um, you know, you've clearly had a pretty interesting uh career and experience to date, and you guys have super ambitious goals and you know, it sounds to me like from where I'm sitting, anything is possible. You know, you you really you're trying to push the envelope um to wherever it finally goes. But what's what's in your career leading up to this this point?

Yoni Kozminski

Like, what's some advice you would give someone uh or something that you've really learned and and and held dear and has kind of been uh uh maybe not a pivotal moment, but something of real value that you know that's impacted you. Yeah.

Ruben Amar

Yeah, it's it's a great question. And I think you can probably read hundreds of books about you know how to pivot from a career to another, how to become an entrepreneur. At the end of the day, I think everyone needs to have his own uh um you know experience in life to be able to get uh to certain things. At the end of the day, what I think is the most important is to really know what you're trying to do. Um, if you have a goal in life, you should make you should make it a first priority and create an environment, whether it is a personal environment, professional environment to achieve this goal. Um from my own perspective and my own experience. Funny story is that many people would probably think that I learned a lot about you know this idea of like taking the risk and becoming entrepreneur from my time at TA Associates or my time at Credit Suisse, or it actually did not happen necessarily there. It happened through a summer experience I had um in when I was 21 years old, which is you know now a long time ago. Um, I was uh I wanted to have an experience in the summer selling cosmetics products in a random mall in the United States, Florida.

Yoni Kozminski

Uh Dead Sea products.

Ruben Amar

Exactly. Exactly. That's unbelievable. Wow, I love that. And you know, back in the days I was not very sales. My English was very limited, but I didn't I wanted to have this like experience of facing the true reality of trying to sell your product in an environment in hostile environment where people don't want to buy your product. Um, and back in the days I didn't realize how much impact it would have on every step of my life. But you know, standing there for 12 hours a day, trying to stop people to get into your your booth and sell them some random products for the Dead Sea Cosmetics to people who spoke only Spanish while I was speaking only English. Um was an experience that learned me one thing. It not only learned me, you know, it teached me how to sell, but more importantly, I learned that failure is just something that gets you closer to success. Every no that you receive in life just gets you closer and closer to a bigger yes. So people, and I think Israeli are actually good at it because they have like this um you know culture of what they call chutzpa, which is audacity, where you just don't need to be afraid of of receiving a no or failure. But I think that no learning to accept failure as a motor as a driver of reaching an even bigger success is actually the thing that you know changed a lot of my perspective. And you know, I could have I could have gone to much more stable, highly paid jobs after my career, and I could have continued in this in this, you know, in this path getting in private equity.

Ruben Amar

But I decided that in order to achieve my goal of being an entrepreneur, building a great organization with a people-oriented culture, achieving a mission of getting consumer brands everywhere in the world. The only way I can do it is just taking the risk. And if I fail, it doesn't matter. If I fail, I will learn and move on to the next journey where the success will get closer. Uh, and that's what I learned through this random three months experience that what I thought when I was 21 was just a nice way to pay my vacation. I actually see today the impact it had on my life. Uh, so one one key learning for people don't be scared from failure, just face it with with enthusiasm. And and if if if failure does come, the next success will be bigger and closer.

Yoni Kozminski

Love it, love it. Thank you, Ahava. Look what uh look what it's done for you. Um just for anyone for anyone who doesn't know, uh, it's like uh an Israeli birthright for um after you go to the army, you want to live overseas and get out of the country that you've just spent three years and four months, I believe, of your your life if you're a male serving. So you fly all around the world and you can be in Canada, Australia, Europe. Sounds like you were somewhere in uh must be Southern California, if I had to guess. Uh Miami, Miami, okay, okay. I was trying to pick the Spanish, but uh that makes sense too. So um and you I think like what the point I'm trying to make here and what it covers is that it's about the mindset going in and those experiences of the no, um, because it's really tough on those on the a galot on the on the trolleys, uh selling this stuff, and you know, whether it's even I mean, you're you're putting yourself up to the task of selling it in a in a foreign language to a different language, and that is you know, that that is going to teach you some grit and hard work and determination and and I think there's a fine line, right?

Yoni Kozminski

Like you also have to be aware of your limitations. So uh just to kind of bring it back to what we're talking about at the start of the show. Um you found two really strong partners, and as a as a team, you were able to achieve a lot more. So I'm all for the position of keep trying, you know. I definitely have made many, many mistakes in my life and my career. And you know, I'll I'll never be perfect and no one can be. Um, but as long as you learn from it and you push forward and your belief grows in whatever it is you're pushing forward to, um, you're gonna have success. It's really just uh a matter of time. Exactly.

Ruben Amar

I think I think you you touched on the right points. It it comes down to two things ambition and self-awareness. If you have if you master these two, you'll be successful. If you master only one, you might be successful. If you don't master any, it will be a very, very difficult challenge to be successful. And self-awareness, self-awareness is something that you know got me to this space because I knew that I was missing clear skills, and I knew that if I wanted to achieve my big ambitions to be successful as an entrepreneur, I had to go and talk to many, many potential, you know, Stanford students to be able to find the right ones. And it took me a lot of like coffee chats in Silicon Valley to figure out the right the right partners. And and you know, it's it's not it's not an easy task, but it it wouldn't have been able to be possible if I was not self-aware enough that I was missing clear gaps in my in my skills to be able to achieve the goal. So, very much important to have like both the self-awareness and the ambition working together.

Yoni Kozminski

Mate, this is just such high value, high grade stuff. I feel like I'm learning a lot into not just the psyche of of what's driving you guys forward, but um but also just really profound insights um as to kind of how you view the world. And I feel very uh linked, but uh yeah, really just hard hitting stuff, mate. Uh really before I let you go, um, because we've got to wrap this up, unfortunately, but I feel like we should get you on a second episode. Um, because it's just filled with such wisdom. I'd love to have you uh back once I get a few more under my belt because I feel like we're just getting warmed up here. Um if anyone wants to get in touch with you, uh, anyone who's looking to sell their brand, what what whatever it might be, um looking for an opportunity, you think you can make the forum team, whatever, whatever they're might want to get in touch with you for, what would be the best way? Yeah.

Ruben Amar

So the it's a great, great question. Thank you for giving the opportunity. I really enjoy the conversation as well. And I I loved every single question you asked. So it shows a lot on your wisdom as well and your understanding of founders. So I think your your podcast will be very successful. And and thank you for inviting me as you know, at first, at first one of the first speakers. I highly appreciate it. Um, so to answer your question, if any seller is interested in potentially selling his his or her brand, they can go on Forum Brands.com. It's F-O-R-U-M-R-A-N-D-S.com, one word. Um, and there's uh there is a contact us form where they can give us a couple of details about the brand and their name, and we reach out within 10 minutes and we we circle back with a call um and you know learn more about the business. But those who are interested to join us, you know, potentially, you know, joining our team, mostly as you probably heard at the beginning, we are recruiting heavily, we are excelling, we are accelerating, we are recruiting the best people uh that you know really share this this passion for consumer uh around the world. Um there is uh there is a career page on our Forum Brands.com uh with our opening uh opening uh roles. Other than that, if they if if the if people are interested in just you know learning about potential opportunities or anything else, they can you know reach out to me.

Ruben Amar

It is Ruben, R U B N at Forum Brands.com. Um, I'd be happy to to discuss potential you know additional opportunities. We have a great chief of staff who is now gonna head all our HR efforts. So uh all that all together, we're happy to have these discussions and you know, and and give give more details about uh active opportunities in our team. Awesome.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, well, Ruben, again, thank you so much for coming on. Thank you so much for investing the time. I think that you're really gonna help a lot of people who do take me up and start listening to me bang on for you know 30, 40 minutes. Uh so thank you. Thank you, Yoni.

Ruben Amar

I really appreciate everything and and and thank you for having me today.

Episode details

Series
Successful Scales
Host
Yoni Kozminski
Episode
1
Published
February 9, 2021
Transcript
9,420 words