Successful Scales · Episode 28 · May 7, 2021

Ep 28: Data-Driven Decision Making, Billion-Dollar Ideas, and Scaling Efficiently with James Thomson - Chief Strategy Officer at Buy Box Experts

A conversation hosted by Yoni Kozminski. Listen above or read the full transcript below.

In this episode

In today's episode, Yoni sat down with James Thomson - Chief Strategy Officer at Buy Box Experts. Buy Box Experts is a 200+ person agency, supporting brand executives who seek to control and grow their Amazon channel businesses.

James served as the business head of Amazon Services during the early days of his career - the division of Amazon responsible for recruiting tens of thousands of sellers annually to the Amazon Marketplace. He also served as the first account manager for the Amazon FBA program.

With his background and expertise in the Amazon industry, he shares with us how it's like working at Amazon and all the amazing things he's learned about scaling efficiently, problem-solving, data-driven decision making, and even recruitment.

What they get into

  • Working on solving big problems
  • Scaling efficiently using data
  • Working on the right problems
  • Billion-dollar ideas

Questions Yoni asks

  1. Like, you know, if you look at yourself and you say over the course of your career tonight, and there's still a lot, a lot left to give in it, but you know, today looking back, what are the things that drive you?

  2. I mean, incredible, incredible, just to sort of hear uh a little bit about you know, 2007, walking to Amazon, giving that level of effectively autonomy without any clear direction. How much of that would you say is part of the culture at Amazon at the time?

  3. Let's, you know, we can't talk about today necessarily, but at the time, how much of it was hiring the smartest person in the room or hyperintelligent people who are going to be extremely autonomous and giving them sort of that room to look at the data warehouse and understand what's happening versus was that you in a management position coming in, like is this something across the board?

  4. And you know, what's your what is your um value that you would put toward the people that you bring in?

  5. What was the I guess impact put up placed on paper?

  6. So I mean, it makes a whole lot of sense to me. And you know, I'm sitting here, like I said, uh thinking, how do I apply this to the business?

  7. Was that also part of the recruitment process?

  8. And that for me personally is probably the the biggest driving factor. It's you know, I I mean, I I'm not gonna make assumptions here about you, but I'll make a little bit of an assumption. I I know for me, I'm not sitting here thinking about like, okay, what's the revenue I'm gonna do tomorrow?

From the conversation

“So uh, but but but again, you have to congratulate people for saying we've identified a really big idea. The market conditions may not be quite right for us to pursue it, but that results in Amazon having a laundry list of half billion dollar ideas ready to go. It's just that right now they're working on the billion dollar ideas, and so that this is all about not only scaling your teams with the best people, but your best people had which which should be you know, at least the minimum caliber across the…”

— James Thompson

“The issue at hand is what do we need to know in order to be able to solve this problem? So we we we hired people where you know there'd be five or six interviews of a candidate, and by the time the second interview is done, I mean, the folks who have interviewed the candidate, I mean, they're smiling because they're like, he or she, they get it. We want this person on the team. And what's really cool is often those people have never really been recognized as being really smart at solving…”

— James Thompson

“When we started Prosper Show, when Joe and I started Prosper Show, we we knew we were trying to solve a problem that was worth solving. And then the problem at the time was how do you create an educational conference for large sellers who are tired of being sold to? I'd been to lots of conferences where, quite frankly, it was just a big sales pitch, the whole conference, or there really wasn't very much educational content. There were speakers, but it really wasn't educational content. And prosper turned out to be very successful…”

— James Thompson

“Having a centralized CRM system for your your clients, whether that's the HubSpot or Salesforce or whatever tool, investing in something like that was one of the most important things we ever did. Not just because there was a centralized tool where all the information sat, but we could train people to all put information into this the same way. Well, it turns out once you have a centralized source of data, then it's easier for managers to go in and pull data and say, Oh, we've got some weird variances here that we need…”

— James Thompson

“And yet, as an agency, as a consultant, we often don't make enough choices because we're just trying to pay the bills. But once we get good enough that we can say no, what we're doing is we're being true to our strategy. And all too often it takes too long before you are actually true to your strategy. You put down something on paper that says this is our strategy of who we're going after, what we're gonna do, and then somebody comes along and says, I'll give you money to do something different.…”

— James Thompson
Read the full conversation
Full transcript11,324 words · speaker-labelled source
Transcript note: This transcript comes from the Successful Scales production archive. It may contain transcription errors. Exact quotations should be checked against the audio before reuse.
Yoni Kozminski

On today's episode, I sit down with James Thompson. James is the founder of Buy Box Experts, the Prosper Show. He's an advisor and investor to Skubana and is also an advisor to Heyday, among many others. A key point of the conversation we had today was all about his time at Amazon, where he spent seven years building out multiple departments, working in the recruitment function and many, many others. Really fascinating, energizing conversation about hypergrowth, the approach to scale and data backed decision making on how to effectively compete for that billion dollar idea. Things that are 100 million dollars simply aren't interesting for Amazon. I took a lot from the conversation and really feel like anyone listening will probably draw some great insights as I did. I hope you enjoy. Hi, and welcome to Successful Scales, the show where I interview now successful professionals about their journey and try and garner insights onto any tips that can be applied to your business at home, whether it's financial freedom or the exit of your company, wherever your journey might take you. The idea here is to simply learn from those who have done it before. I hope you enjoy and you get some value out of this. Buckle up and enjoy the episode.

Yoni Kozminski

James, welcome to an episode of Successful Scales. Thanks for making the time. Uh, and thanks for having such an incredible background that I get to enjoy this beautiful visual. Obviously, your face, but obviously what's going on behind you.

James Thompson

Yoni, absolute pleasure to be joining you today. Thank you.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, absolutely. Well, um, I would think of not very many people who are more worthy than you to talk about scale and about what it is to grow companies and be part of exponential growth and you know, sort of bestow upon that wisdom. So before we sort of dive into, you know, some of your insights and your journey. Well, let's dive into your journey first. I'd love to hear for those who don't know, sort of your experience.

James Thompson

So I'm James Thompson. Uh I am a by accident e-commerce entrepreneur. I never thought I was going to be an entrepreneur. I went the uh academic route uh many years ago and thought I was going to be a professor and did all the training and did my MBA, did my PhD and said, all right, let's let's go become an academic. And uh about 15 minutes into that experience, realized that maybe I was better suited as a consultant. Uh, maybe I was better suited solving real world problems. Um, and I mean that as no disrespect to academics. I come from a family of academics. I have a father and a brother who are academics and very successful. I just realized that I couldn't live in a world where there were six or seven people who would be my editors, my reviewers, and they would control the world for me. Um, I needed to be a little bit more free and be in a position where I could try a lot of new ideas out. So I did the normal things that people who have been classically trained in business do. I went off, I became a banker, I became a management consultant, and I became miserable because quite frankly, the corporate world wasn't really the right kind of place for me. Um, I did have an opportunity to go work at Amazon, which, although one might say that's a corporate world, uh, I got to work there in 2007 to 2013, which was a time of insane growth. Significant new programs uh were being developed.

James Thompson

I got to be part of some of those programs. And from the perspective of being in the safety of a corporate setting where you know you're getting your paycheck, you know you're getting your benefits, you know, there's an office still there tomorrow. You know, that part's all very rewarding. But at Amazon, I got to do something I never got to do anywhere else, which was work on problems that quite frankly, every day seemed impossible to solve. And yet I knew that we would solve at least enough of the problem that we would figure out that maybe we were trying to solve for not quite the right problem, but we would we would accomplish major, major, major uh goals. And it's very exciting to be in a position where not only are you being challenged to find ways to create ridiculous levels of growth, but you're being asked to do it often with next to no resources. So you have to say, how do I beg borrow and steal resources? How do I get really creative about frugally finding ways to encourage my oh so kind colleagues to come and work a few hours on this project and lend their slender services and such. So I had the opportunity to uh work with the original FBA team at Amazon, figuring out how do we sell FBA into Amazon sellers. Um, and that was a you know, I can tell more, tell a little bit more about that later, but that that was a really crazy situation because Amazon didn't really know what FBA would would encompass in terms of how they would position it to sellers.

James Thompson

Obviously, here we are today, and sellers who want to be successful in third party with a few rare exceptions, they basically have to be using the FBA program. I used to take sellers on these tours of the fulfillment centers. People would walk in and say, okay, your warehouse is bigger than my warehouse. I guess we'll use your warehouse. And in retrospect, I think back and I'm like, it's it's not about I have a bigger warehouse. It's that I have the ability to do things with this warehouse and this network of warehouses and the software that runs these warehouses, uh, things that you'll never be able to do with your 50,000 square foot warehouse. So no, that that was kind of cool. Fast forward, I left Amazon in 2013. Uh met my business partner Joe Hanson. He and I have started a few businesses together. Uh, some folks may be familiar with the Prosper Show, which is a large scale educational event that's held once a year for mid-size and large brands, uh, primarily third party seller brands. Um, and then Joe and I also uh started an agency called Buy Box Experts.

James Thompson

Buy Box Experts is now a 200 person agency working with brands, first party, third party, uh advertising listings, all the stuff you would expect an Amazon agency to do. And uh talk about scaling. You know, we've we've had to learn how to go from basically a hodgepodge of a collection of a few people who sort of knew bits and pieces of Amazon, plus Joe and myself, to now we have a team that has literally 15 or 16 different specialized sub teams, each of which are really, really strong at what they do, uh, and we're able to now bring that expertise to brands. Um, we didn't have a roadmap for how to scale. We kind of learned along the way. We we certainly made more than our fair share of rather expensive mistakes in looking at how might we be able to get to be big and and competent at the same time and being big and competent at the same time while you're scaling. I mean, Yoni, I know, and I'm sure you know firsthand from your own businesses how how do you add more people, backfill the training and standardizing what it is they need to know and how they need to know it. Oh my gosh, those things are hard.

Yoni Kozminski

It breaks, it breaks every other month.

James Thompson

There comes a point where you realize if we're gonna do this, we need to be an adult type of company. We we need to think about this beyond, hey, we're just some cool new startup in the internet space to we need to create an environment and an infrastructure for our employees where they say this is a real job. And when they explain to their parents they work for us, their parents say, ah, you work for a real company. And so putting those, putting those two parts together, uh, it took us many years to get to the point where we could afford to have certain types of benefit programs. We could afford to have a recruiting, a full-time recruiting person, a full-time uh administration person, uh full-time technology person. I mean, these are expensive investments having these types of folks on the team. And yet, the moment we added these types of people to our organizations, it became clear, oh, wait a minute. Yes, we we now are in a much better position that we can add the next 30, 50, 80 employees because we've got people in place to handle these uh these responsibilities full time. So it's very exciting to have that, but it's also scary because you're writing big checks to add new types of competencies to your organization. So being in a position where you realize we can't go, we can't grow any further without making these investments, whether we want to or not. And now that we've made these investments, oh yes, I see that we can actually grow even faster than we anticipated because we've got competencies in these in these areas.

Yoni Kozminski

I have so many questions. I'm sure you've seen me just writing down note after note after note here. I have so many questions. Um, and like I said at the start, I feel like it's an absolute privilege to have you here because I know in this I'm gonna learn a lot, and those listening, I'm sure will too. But before I sort of dive into some of the more current experiences about growing buy box experts and you know, uh the prosperous show and a lot of the stuff, you know, I did my due diligence too and looked at a lot of the businesses that you're an advisor to and investor to. Um I'm curious, you know, from a personal perspective, you know, you've been at Deloitte, you've been at BCJ, Boston Consulting Group, you've been a consultant. You said that you plan to go down the academic route, and now you're finding yourself in you know, scaling startups to maturing companies. What's your key driver? Like, you know, if you look at yourself and you say over the course of your career tonight, and there's still a lot, a lot left to give in it, but you know, today looking back, what are the things that drive you? Is it the well, you know what? I'm not gonna put words in your mouth.

James Thompson

So it's really interesting. I I went to work for one bank where it didn't take long for me to realize I was miserable and I couldn't really figure out why I was miserable. I had a big PL to manage, I had a team to manage, I had a nice office, I had a lot of work flexibility, but I was absolutely miserable. And I ended up with what is basically a life coach at the company who helped me understand what it is that makes me tick. And until you force yourself to sit down and ask those questions and realize, wait a minute, it's okay that these things make me tick. And in my situation with this particular organization, things that made me tick were not things that that organization could provide me. And the moment I realized that, oh gosh, I'm going to need to change jobs. Well, okay, that's annoying. But at least I understand what is it that I need to get out of my professional experience in order to be happy. If you think of the number of hours you're awake in a day and the proportion of those hours you spend on your work, if you're not happy doing whatever it is you're spending your time doing at work, I know it's work, it's not play, it's called work, but you still have to be motivated and be in a position where you say, This is worth doing, this is worth waking up for every day. And for me, coming to the point that I realized that I needed a job where I had certain types of intellectual flexibility, but I had the data to be able to provide insights into what it is that I ultimately uh was going to undertake to be in a position where I had managers who weren't in a box who had to do X, Y, and Z and do it only one particular way. You know, I I had been in many jobs where that was the situation.

James Thompson

And as soon as this particular coach of mine, his nickname names Rick Oslin, wonderful gentleman who still continues to be a very, very important guide for me. Um, you know, he helped me understand where the mismatch was. And as a result, the mismatch was so large that of course I was unhappy because I was trying to fit into an environment where things were being accomplished, or excuse me, success in how you accomplish things uh was not the way, not at all consistent with the way that I knew how to create success. So I ended up leaving that company and I went to work for Amazon, which was quite frankly uh a very fortunate uh chance situation that happened. I I didn't really know what I was getting myself into when I went to work for Amazon. This is back in 2007, and quite frankly, Amazon is unrecognizable as a company today versus what it was in 2007. And I went, I started at Amazon in December, early December 2007. And I remember the first day I started, uh, as you can well imagine, Q4 at Amazon is insanity beyond insanity.

James Thompson

And I walked in, and my manager, who at the time was the director of the department, he sat me down, he said, here's your desk, here's your computer, here's your password and access to the Amazon data warehouse. We'll see you in a month. Not what's your job, what is it you're supposed to do the next month, but basically we don't actually have time to talk to you for the next month. So you figure out what you're gonna do. And I and I'm I mean, I'm literally like, okay, the bathroom's over there, the door out, the building is there. What is it I'm supposed to do? I've never had this level of well, minimal oversight, and yet I knew I had PL responsibilities. So figuring out how do I make a job out of this so that not only do I appear to be competent, but I'm actually competent and actually happy doing what I'm doing. I mean, it's it's a when you in retrospect, it's basically like handing handing your eight-year-old kid a set of kitchen knives and saying, there's the chicken, there are the sharp knives, make make me an amazingly yummy a meal.

James Thompson

It's kind of like this is insane. But as it turns out, that that's the way things were were done at Amazon. It might have a little bit more structure now, but um I very quickly realized, okay, I can take the strengths of what I know how to do and I can apply them to this role and I can just start doing things. And I don't really have to ask a lot of permission, just have to go do it. And as long as it's it's backed by data that I have pulled out of the data warehouse and looked at, and I'm testing against hypotheses. Even if I step on someone's toes, if I've got the data to show what I've done, most of the time I can just keep moving forward. So there's an awful lot of asking for forgiveness, but in most organizations I'd worked in prior to that, there was no moving forward until you asked for permission 12 different ways before you could actually move forward. So it's a very strange mental shift to be in a situation where all of a sudden people are looking at you and saying, Well, what it what what problem have you solved today? Sorry, what problem did you want me to solve? Well, whatever problem needs to be solved. Well, what problem needs to be solved?

James Thompson

Well, that's up to you to figure out what problem needs to be solved. And at the end of the day, the fundamental driver at Amazon is how do we keep scaling and how do we do it efficiently? I remember my my first weekly business review at Amazon, amazing experience to be in where you realize everybody in the room has essentially been programmed in a certain way to think about what progress looks like. And I remember sitting in the meeting and people were not talking about 20, 25% growth. You know, you work in a company that grows 20, 25% year over year. That's exciting. At Amazon, we were growing three to four percent a month. And so when I think back to my, you know, my classic MBA training where working in a growth environment and how do you think about growth, blah, blah, blah. It was always around this framework of, you know, you get to eight to 10% year over year growth, you're in a growth organization. If you grew your business at Amazon eight to 10%, people would laugh at you and you'd be replaced. And so the whole focus around if you really want to scale your business, fundamentally, you need to understand what are the key drivers, the most important key drivers that are going to allow you to create fivefold growth, tenfold growth.

James Thompson

And if you don't understand what those key drivers are, then it's going to slow you down from being able to grow. You can't just, well, let's try this, let's try that, let's try that. Yes, you can experiment in a bunch of different fronts, but you better be experimenting with a very clear uh set of hypotheses and some initial data that would suggest I think going down this path is better than going down this path. Because if you get it wrong, you're gonna have to course correct very quickly and start going down the correct path because you're being asked to do you know, 40, 50 percent year over year growth at a minimum. So this whole mindset, when when I think of my time at Amazon, what I learned from that that I've been able to take post Amazon, the most important issue is if if something's worth doing, then being well, for something to be worth doing, it basically means you're gonna figure something out and then you're gonna scale the heck out of it. You're gonna say, All right, I have the secret sauce on how to go from A to B, but I can't just go A to B. I gotta keep going in that direction as fast as I can.

James Thompson

And I basically have to grab as much land as I can going in that direction, knowing that it's going to work, I got to move as fast as I can. And at some point I'll get diminishing returns. But if I just keep plotting along in this direction, saying I have the formula of what I need to do, and I just keep moving at a fairly slow pace, then somebody else will figure out the same path and we'll end up you know capturing the flag before I do. And so this concept of experiment, experiment, experiment, leverage data, make sure you make small course corrections if things aren't working. But then when you figure it out, you better move as fast as you can, you better scale as fast as you can. Granted, it'll create new problems for you, like, oh, you know, we want to get at least three new clients a month. Oh, now we want to get at least 30 new clients a month. You know, obviously being able to support the back end of what that justifies, you know, that there's a bunch of issues, but you need to ask yourself the question if we know now how to add new clients, or if we know how to create new product listings, what would it take for us to be able to do five times that much? What would it take for us to do 10 times that much? Well, let's break the problem down.

James Thompson

Let's figure out fundamentally what is holding us back and what would need to be true for that constraint to be removed. These are these are the types of questions I wish I had been asked to help think through when I was a business school student. When when the professor said, Congratulations, you're going to work for a growth-oriented organization. What does it take for you to grow your business 50% year over year? And again, another 50% next year and the next year. And by the way, it gets harder and harder. That 50% is a bigger number. So thinking about how do you break down this problem and how do you uh put yourself in a position where you know you're headed basically in the right direction and you can move as fast as you can, and then take that and go work at Amazon where somebody says you need to figure out in what direction to go running. And by the way, we're not going to give you any resources to go figure it out until such time as you've proven you have a model that's highly scalable, you're not going to get any new resources. Once you prove it, I'll give you the resources. But until you prove that you're heading the right direction, figure it all out on your own back.

Yoni Kozminski

I mean, incredible, incredible, just to sort of hear uh a little bit about you know, 2007, walking to Amazon, giving that level of effectively autonomy without any clear direction. How much of that would you say is part of the culture at Amazon at the time? Let's, you know, we can't talk about today necessarily, but at the time, how much of it was hiring the smartest person in the room or hyperintelligent people who are going to be extremely autonomous and giving them sort of that room to look at the data warehouse and understand what's happening versus was that you in a management position coming in, like is this something across the board? That's the talent we look for versus you in that position.

James Thompson

It took me a while to realize what was going on in terms of the types of people who are in the organization. And I ended up, you know, one of the years I was at Amazon, I I actually managed recruiting for the US Amazon marketplace team. And I did so many interviews, it was absurd. But you very quickly realize there's an awful lot of people out there who have impressive looking resumes. They've worked for a lot of the big brand names, they've done they've been there when important things happened. But it turns out they weren't the people that made these things happen. They got lucky. And there's a lot of lucky people, and luck is great. But when all you've done is you've been at big brand names long enough to put your the brand name on your resume, it doesn't mean that you're the guy or you're the gal that's actually going to move things from A to B. It just means you were there when somebody else moved things from A to B. And so as we, you know, as I dug into the whole recruiting process, both participating initially recruiting folks, but then us actually running the recruiting for this large team, you very quickly realize how do you filter through resumes that at the surface look really impressive. And yet, most of these resumes that we would look at, most of these people, their resumes would focus on what it is I've done.

James Thompson

I was here when this happened. Look at the brand names, look how impressive it is. You know, why wouldn't you hire me? I worked at tier one company, tier one company, tier one company. I went to tier one business school, tier one undergrad. Why wouldn't you hire me? And yet, the moment you start asking questions around, okay, what did you do? Yoni, what did you do to move the business from here to here? You very quickly realize that even if they were part of a team, they weren't establishing the strategy. They weren't actually uh acquiring the resources. They were basically the cleanup team that were told the the cookbook recipe has been developed. Now your job is to actually just go and execute this. Well, that's not really interesting for Amazon. We Amazon doesn't want blockers and tacklers. They want people who are going to figure out, you know, to use the hockey expression, where the puck is going. You know, what do we need to do in order to keep scaling our business? Because scaling from A to B and then scaling from B to C isn't necessarily quite the same path. But they also want people who are saying, what do we need to do to scale from A to M? Holy smokes. If we want to be, you know, 500 times bigger than we are today, that requires a whole different level of thinking. And I cannot tell you how many times I was in meetings where somebody will put some audacious goal up on the whiteboard. And the question was not, are you crazy?

James Thompson

Like, are you nuts? We're never going to hit that goal. The question was always, whether we're going to hit that goal or not, what would need to be true for us to be in a position to actually hit that goal? I think back to like the 1960s. What will it take for us to put a man on the moon? Well, that's ridiculous. We're never going to do that. No, let's let's break down the problem. What will it actually take? Well, we'd need this and we'd need this. And then we'd need, you know, this and this to work together and then this and then this. Okay, well, let's start tackling those parts of the problem that we know we can solve today. We have the technology or we have the wherewithal to be able to figure out these problems. And then with the parts that we don't fully understand, what information do we need to go and find out so that we can peel back the onion and start to figure out more of what's going on? That type of intellectual adventure solving seemingly impossible problems. For me, this is one of the most gratifying things I've ever done professionally. Because you realize it's it's not about being successful or failing at the problem. By definition, the fact that you're working on the right problems and you're working with a bunch of other people who are also focused on of course this is possible. It seems impossible, but of course it's possible that collectively we're going to figure out how to solve even 80% of the problem. And maybe by the time we solve 80% of the problem, the other 20% will either be irrelevant or some business need will have slightly changed. But we will have learned so much to get to 80% of the solution that we will be a much better organization than we were if we had just said, hey, let's create a small marginal growth goal that really won't get us anywhere and will allow us to be trumped by some other company that comes along and says, we're thinking way bigger than you. So these are some of the really interesting things that I did at Amazon around thinking about solving big problems. If you spend your time focused on how do I work on small problems that are safe, that aren't going to get my career in, you know, harm my career in most organizations.

James Thompson

That's all very nice and well. But at Amazon, there's very few glorious failures. What there are are lots of little failures where you learned really important things that will help guide the course correction you're gonna, you're gonna have to make in order to continue to figure out how to solve this big audacious goal. Really interesting stuff. Quite frankly, I think back to all the types of management consultants and bankers that I worked with who, you know, they they were all part of the top of their classes in business school. And yet I wish all of them had had a chance to work at Amazon for even 12 months because you very quickly realize that just because we're smart in terms of I know how to get good grades, I know how to you know appear to be smart, that's not really the stuff that's important if you want to build something amazing. And Amazon has built all sorts of amazing things, and it's because they asked the right questions around what would it take for us to do this insane thing? Why bother going to Mars?

James Thompson

You know, let's let's go to planets on another solar system. Well, okay, what's it going to take to do that? You know, A, B, C D, break down the problem. How do we solve each of those different subproblems? Really interesting experience. And uh and I know I'm babbling here a little bit, but you know, for for me, the part of working at Amazon and being thrown in an environment where it wasn't so much you're being thrown in the deep end, but rather you're being thrown into a situation where the question is always why not? Not why, but why not? Why can't we go to a 500 times growth point? Why not? What's holding us back? Well, let's figure it out. Because turns out you put smart people in a room, of course they all want to go and create insane growth. And they all want to, you know, put a man on Mars, of course. But everyone wants to play it a little bit safe. Say, well, I don't really want to be part of a spectacular failure. The people Amazon hired, there's no such thing as a spectacular failure, as I say.

James Thompson

It's about we're we're here to solve extraordinary problems and we're here to figure out uh how to do things that nobody else has done. I think I think about so many of the companies that I either advised or I worked for where the frame of reference was always your competitors. What am I doing relative to my competitors? How do I gain share from my competitors? At Amazon, I don't think I've I was ever in a conversation where people talked about the other companies. It was about what do we need to do in order to make customers so incredibly happy that naturally they'll flock to our platform. And if there are things that we need to do that nobody else has ever done, then let's do it. If we're trying to do things that other people have started to do, well, that's all very nice and well. At the end of the day, Amazon's going to find a way to scale or solve that big problem in ways that nobody else had, because there's the safety blanket of the culture that says go solve big audacious goals, go learn, go use data, go find ways that you're going to do things that no one else has done, but will be insanely rewarding once you get to those points.

Yoni Kozminski

So, firstly, I wouldn't say that you uh babbling and if you were it was uh inspirational babble because I'm sitting here just listening, thinking, wow, if you set your trajectory to Pluto, you know, then your fallback plan is landing on Mars. So if you're if you're trying if you're trying to solve the biggest problems that exist, then you know the the low uh hanging outcome is still gonna be something exceptional. So yeah, it it makes a whole lot of sense to me. And you you got you caught my attention when you talked about the fact that you were inside of uh, you know, I guess the recruitment drive for one of the teams that you're working with inside of Amazon. And you know, I read every book under the sun around professional development and entrepreneurship and all those things. And I'm really curious from working inside of Amazon from the perspective of sort of that people first. What was that experience like working inside of the recruitment drive? And you know, what's your what is your um value that you would put toward the people that you bring in?

James Thompson

I worked with some pretty darn amazing colleagues at Amazon. Um everybody was almost everybody was a type A personality. So at times it's you know, at the end of the day, you're exhausted because it's my idea versus your idea, your data versus my data. And at the end of the day, you know, I to become better at what I do, I need to be surrounded by people who are constantly pushing me. It's not a personal thing, it's a professional thing, and they're pushing me to think more clearly. At Amazon, you know, I I think back to my father is incredibly bright man who's published dozens of books, thousands of articles, really, really smart guy. And he's he's an idea guy. He's always throwing ideas at me. And it was about a year and a half into my time at Amazon that I remember I was having a conversation with my father. And I said to him, Dad, it's not about whether your idea is a good idea or not. It's about whether your idea is one of the top 10 ideas and whether you've got the data to show that the opportunity available by solving that top 10 problem versus the other 10,000 ideas that are on paper that's

Yoni Kozminski

curious just to jump back for a second. So, you know, we're talking about the fact that um or the thing I I guess that really interests me when you were going through, like I said, not babble, but it was inspiring and had me thinking a million miles an hour as to your time in the recruitment arm of the businesses that you support inside of Amazon. What was the focus? What was the value? What was the I guess impact put up placed on paper? Like how central was that to the success of everything that you were looking to uh drive. And then after this, I want to talk a little bit about data.

James Thompson

So I'm really glad I worked in recruiting. And quite frankly, when I was asked to do this, I'm like, really? I don't want to work in recruiting. But I recognize that if you don't have the right people at the table, we're not going to solve big audacious goals. We're just going to be uh, you know, a handful of people with big ideas and a bunch of followers who are saying, that's too hard. I don't want to work on that. But the other thing I learned about recruiting is if you bring the right type of people in, and by the way, you know, Amazon is lots of lots of articles have been written about Amazon's recruiting process, and and it really does work. I'm really impressed by the likelihood of a uh culturally unfit person finding their way into Amazon is pretty darn slight. But but here's here's the thing that I think about with recruiting. If you put the right kind of people at the table, and everybody's saying, let's find a way to go to Pluto versus let's find a way to go from here to New York City.

James Thompson

You know, the the reality is you're gonna have a lot more interesting ideas show up on paper as people realize, well, we can go to Pluto, but also there's this other thing that we can also do that's big and audacious, and why can't we work on both of those? I'm gonna tell you a little story. So my my father is a very smart academic, published all sorts of stuff. And I talked to him regularly when I was at Amazon around some of these big ideas, you know, how do we how do we go find a way to do this and this and this? And my dad would throw ideas at me all the time and say, Well, what about this? You know, have you thought about doing this or thought about doing this? And I it was about a year into my time at Amazon that I explained to my dad, I said, you know, it's not about whether your idea is a good idea or not. It's about is it one of the top 10 ideas that's on the list for everybody in your department? And to be a top 10 idea, we're talking back in 2010, 2011, to be a top 10 idea, it was a billion-dollar idea within two years.

James Thompson

It was not some puny little 100 million dollar idea, it was a billion-dollar idea. And so I think I frustrated my father many times where he would give me an idea. I'm like, that's a great idea, Dad. That's a hundred million dollar idea. The problem is we need billion-dollar ideas. So I'm gonna take your 100 million dollar idea, I'm gonna write it down because things may change in the next few years, and that 100 million dollar idea might become a billion-dollar idea if some external factor changes. But right now, it's a hundred million dollar idea, which means it's not gonna make the cut. In most organizations, people will go gaga over a hundred million dollar idea at Amazon. Nobody's excited. And so we we do this recruiting process, we bring in people who are all fighting to come up with the next billion dollar idea. And we would go through this annual review process where everybody would write up what they thought was their biggest and best idea for the year, and and then there was this big review process over a three, four-day period. And to me, that was that was exhilarating, reading all these different ideas, realizing wow, that's a really good idea, but it's only a 500 million dollar idea. So you know what? That's gonna get shelved. We may revisit it in two or three years, but sorry, guys, only a 500 million dollar idea.

Yoni Kozminski

Just half a billion dollars. No, no biggie.

James Thompson

So uh, but but but again, you have to congratulate people for saying we've identified a really big idea. The market conditions may not be quite right for us to pursue it, but that results in Amazon having a laundry list of half billion dollar ideas ready to go. It's just that right now they're working on the billion dollar ideas, and so that this is all about not only scaling your teams with the best people, but your best people had which which should be you know, at least the minimum caliber across the board should be so good that everyone's coming up with 100 million, 500 million billion dollar ideas. And things will shake out in terms of whether your idea is actually big enough because of the market conditions, or whether it's a really clever idea, but we need to put a twist on it and combine it with something else to eventually make it a billion dollar idea. But for the time being, it's just a really smart idea with some things put together that don't quite get you to the billion dollar number. So no one ever said to me that's about scaling, but the reality is that that's a form of scaling that I'd never seen before in any other kind of organization. Come up with ideas, make sure they're big. In fact, make sure they're so big and potentially have vibrant impact on so many other parts of the existing business that the senior executives can't help but say, let's fund that.

James Thompson

Let's move forward with that. So, you know, that that that's part of the stuff I learned at Amazon that unfortunately I'd never learned in any of the other types of roles I had. And I work for some big name companies where you know smart people are supposed to go and work, but it was just never the culture of we're here to do things that might seem unsafe from the potential of we may fail versus unsafe if we don't do this, someone else will figure it out and will beat us to Pluto. And then we got a much bigger problem because now we have to not only go to Pluto, we got to go beyond Pluto. And we already know that getting to Pluto is going to be hard enough. You know, we we we better aim, move quickly, uh, and put the right people to the table to make sure that we can we can we can have a realistic chance of being successful.

Yoni Kozminski

So I mean, it makes a whole lot of sense to me. And you know, I'm sitting here, like I said, uh thinking, how do I apply this to the business? You know, I'm I'm thinking in my head right now with people that I have internally who are just literally solving problems that no one asked them to solve. They're really they're going out there, and these are the people that you want to promote. You know, we had one guy in our team, Jab, if you're listening to this, I love you. And he literally pitched us on building a team around, it's called the Kaisen team, constant improvement. He pitched us around the idea of building out a department in the business, and now we've given him four team members that he can now, you know, where we've we've effectively invested in his commitment to building better data into our business. And so two questions for you before we move on to data, because this to me sounds like something that is likely a driving factor. And for businesses that are not as large as Amazon and some of the businesses you've worked with, I think it's one of those things that I think a lot of companies sort of um move beyond and don't think too critically about actually making data-driven decisions. They they more so look at, oh, well, this is working, so I'll keep pushing forward and growing organically, and here we go. But when you were talking about these billion dollar ideas, is that internal teams they each present and then you review it once a year? Was that also part of the recruitment process?

James Thompson

We didn't ask, well, I don't I don't remember asking candidates for billion dollar ideas, but we would we would ask them questions that were so grand in terms of the audaciousness of what we were asking them to solve. I really wasn't interested in whether they solved the problem or not. I was interested in did they have the mental structure around how do you take a problem and break it down into various components and start solving each of those components, or at least start putting effort behind what are the key drivers that make this problem today unsolvable and what what would need to be possible for us to have a solution on this part and a solution on this part and a solution on this part. It's it's it's it's a wonderful feeling to be in an interview with someone and they immediately start breaking down the problem and and classifying different different types of parts of the issue. You realize I don't really care whether they get this or not. They they understand conceptually that it's not about, oh my gosh, are you kidding me? We're never going to solve this problem. Why are you wasting my time have asking me to solve this problem? Well, that's that's an easy way for people who otherwise have been in organizations at tier one companies, you know, if they've played it safe all along, it's easy for them to say, I don't actually know how to solve this problem because I've never been forced to solve the problem or forced to think about the issue as to whether it's solvable or not is irrelevant.

James Thompson

The issue at hand is what do we need to know in order to be able to solve this problem? So we we we hired people where you know there'd be five or six interviews of a candidate, and by the time the second interview is done, I mean, the folks who have interviewed the candidate, I mean, they're smiling because they're like, he or she, they get it. We want this person on the team. And what's really cool is often those people have never really been recognized as being really smart at solving seemingly vast, difficult to solve problems because they've always been in a corporate environment where they've been asked to play along, go down the hall this way, only go this fast, do these things. And now we're giving them a situation where there is no hall. It's like a grand opening, great big huge space. Your job is to figure out how do we, you know, if if if we're gonna grab parts of the field, what parts of the field do we want to grab? How much of the field do we want to grab? How quickly do we want to grab it? Uh, it's very freeing for the candidates when they realize, oh my gosh, you know, Amazon has this kind of environment.

James Thompson

We I can do this. I can be a mid-level manager and I can go solve or at least come up with a solution to a problem that no one spent time thinking about, but I see the opportunity to solve. When you when you let someone uh become intellectually free around solving big complicated problems, it's exhilarating. And there are days that I came home from Amazon where I was exhausted because in a very satisfying way, I've been in meetings with other people. We were solving problems where you have to sit back and say, are we looking at this with false, false assumptions or pretense around what is actually reality versus what is possible? When you start to say, I think we're gonna build a 10 mile wide bridge across shark infested waters, and we're gonna do it with paper mache and it's doable. You're just like, wow, I've solved I figured something out that I don't think more than a handful of other people in the room have ever solved in the world. That that's really exciting and makes you want to get up the next morning and go back to work. So um that that only comes because the room is full of other people who also have the guts to say, I want to work on problems that other people might see as frivolously ridiculous, but I recognize as we need to start to think about how to solve this problem, at least parts of it to get to a point where we actually understand the mechanism, the underlying mechanism that much better.

Yoni Kozminski

And and I think that hearing you saying the passion and hearing the passion in your voice around what that is to be one of those people in the room solving some of the biggest problems, you know, that no one else is even attempting to tackle, let alone solve itself. Um, it sounds like, you know, in the traditional corporate construct where you're sort of, well, I don't cage is probably an over uh statement here, but you know, you're you're sort of you're swimming in your lane and you're focused. It is almost the antithesis of what it is to, you know, be an entrepreneur to effectively live out that problem solving mechanism of how do I, how do I how do I get to that big audacious goal and how do I do it faster than anyone else? And that for me personally is probably the the biggest driving factor. It's you know, I I mean, I I'm not gonna make assumptions here about you, but I'll make a little bit of an assumption. I I know for me, I'm not sitting here thinking about like, okay, what's the revenue I'm gonna do tomorrow?

Yoni Kozminski

What am I gonna, how much money are we gonna? It's it's what's the big problem that I'm gonna solve that's gonna enable everyone who I'm working with to solve that one thing that they couldn't do before that we've now enabled it. And I think that um a big part of that is probably uh back to that point around data. That's the driving mechanic of letting you understand, well, what's historically happened and where can we actually take it? So I guess I'm I'm now rambling a little bit, but my question to you, and something that I've been meaning to ask about is is data. When you look at all the problems that you're looking to solve today. So let's talk buy box experts, for example. You know, you've you've come from a very data-heavy decision making, effectively competing with other colleagues on, well, you know, we both have the same access to this data set. It's the problem that I'm gonna solve, and you're competing. How much has that DNA been woven into you know all of the businesses that you've now either advised, invested, and built yourself? Yeah.

James Thompson

When we started Prosper Show, when Joe and I started Prosper Show, we we knew we were trying to solve a problem that was worth solving. And then the problem at the time was how do you create an educational conference for large sellers who are tired of being sold to? I'd been to lots of conferences where, quite frankly, it was just a big sales pitch, the whole conference, or there really wasn't very much educational content. There were speakers, but it really wasn't educational content. And prosper turned out to be very successful, and we had thousands of people come to the events, and quite frankly, we didn't know what we were doing, but we figured it out. Everybody got their chicken sandwich and lots of great education and it went well. But what we realized quickly was we had no, we didn't have the contacts to go find 1,500 people a year to come to our show. So we had to start to break down the problem. Where are these leads going to come from? How are we going to get these leads? Well, we can do it this way and this way and this way and this way. We started to test a couple of different approaches. And some of them we realized, oh, this is totally going to work.

James Thompson

So we need to double down on this. And these other areas, even though they may not necessarily be the best approach, what else can we learn from trying this out in other ways and see if we can get more more people to attend? And it was what's important to understand here is there was no database that we went to and said, slice and dice the data differently, we'll find our answer. It was around saying we have a big problem to solve that we recognize we can't solve just by calling some people we already know. We're gonna have to figure this out. And by recognizing there's you know, channel, there's approach A, B, C D E, what do we need to do for each of those approaches and breaking it down? That that's a form of compiling data and saying we're gonna test things here, test things here, test things here. What are we testing so we can collect data, collect input around whether this is going to work or not? That's all about the this need to collect data drives the need to innovate and try things that are a little bit outside of the realm of what you have to do every day. And so to the extent that you know, here I am now running an agency, and we we used to struggle with hiring two or three people. Now now we're hiring more than a dozen a month.

James Thompson

And so the question around how do we build a scalable process? How do we find these people? How do you find good people to work in your company? How do you do that in a COVID world where everybody wants the same types of people? Well, again, it's a problem of we we have to look at lots of different opportunities. We have to say, what do we need to learn about each of these different channels to figure out whether or not this thing is actually going to work? And that's that's about collecting data, being willing to do lots of little experiments and say, I've learned enough to say this looks like we should keep moving forward, or we actually have learned enough that we don't want to go down this path and let's reinvest our assets somewhere else. So I don't build big databases anymore. I don't go and have access to huge databases anymore. But the way problems are solved has to be around looking at ways to collect data. How do I collect data about different ideas so that I can figure out whether these things make sense or not?

James Thompson

I worked for one company at one point where it really was the antithesis of data collection. It was all about who you knew. Well, go talk to Bob, because Bob knows how to do it, i.e., Bob supposedly has the answer to the question. And if Bob says, do it my way, and then it'll work, then you'll have success. Well, it turns out the world is ever changing. And to everybody out there who's the Bob, you know, it doesn't mean that you're gonna continue to be the most relevant way to solve the problem. And so, how do you continue to find questions that need to be asked where data needs to be collected? So you can further test does the mechanism still work the way we think it works. How do I collect the data to get the feedback so that I can course correct and figure out how can I move forward faster or more efficiently? That that's really what we do today on so many different fronts. It's not running regression models, it's not building big data databases. It's about asking the right questions and being prepared that 50% of what we do is not gonna be successful in the sense that this is not the answer we had been hoping for, but we learned enough along the way that we're now in a better position to say we know why this didn't work, and that's actually useful to know, so that we don't repeat it over here, uh you know, basically put a new coat of paint on it and call it something new when it's in fact the same underlying mechanism. So um, yeah, it's it's a frame of mind that says we have to innovate around doing experiments. We have to do experiments and try things out specifically to collect data to learn about our environment more effectively and be in a better position to be able to say we actually think we know what the environment looks around us because we continue to test the outer bounds uh of what we think our underlying assumptions are.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, this is this is ringing true to everything I'm doing. But if we were to take it down uh, you know, a few levels to a um something a little bit more tangible. And what I mean by that is for example, for example, like with us, uh you know, I I think like you, we run a lot of what we do inside of multiply main escala, everything's backed by data. We pull from our HubSpot, um, you know, we pull from HubSpot, we pull from CrayLite, which is our recruitment CRM. We type in zero, we build analytics dashboards based on performance, where things sit, where are the bottlenecks, where are the challenges? We iterate, we continue to sort of break down the information better to make better, more micro focused decisions on okay. Well, if we make this little course correction deviation, then we can fix that problem. And the next bit of the funnel is you know, that creates an issue here. And so you're constantly iterating. But we also run, you know, weekly we run on EOS, the entrepreneurial operating system. Yeah, I'm saying you nod your head. So no surprise to me that you're all over that. So, you know, we have L L 10, our level 10 meeting every week. We have the 90 minute meeting, we go through and we look at what what are the core challenges in the business this week?

Yoni Kozminski

How do we solve them? How do we bring the senior management team together? So for you, in everything that you're doing data, I mean you're a 200 person strong agency. What mechanics exist in your business to sort of help, you know, for businesses maybe smaller than yours or you know, the people listening today, like what are some of the insights that they might be able to draw upon to start to build the data sets they need to make better decisions?

James Thompson

Having a centralized CRM system for your your clients, whether that's the HubSpot or Salesforce or whatever tool, investing in something like that was one of the most important things we ever did. Not just because there was a centralized tool where all the information sat, but we could train people to all put information into this the same way. Well, it turns out once you have a centralized source of data, then it's easier for managers to go in and pull data and say, Oh, we've got some weird variances here that we need to address. Um and it becomes easier to say, can we do cost modeling and figure out are we in fact in a situation we've got a bunch of customers who cost us more money than we thought. Uh we started doing you know, time management costing tools, and that that was really, really useful. And we discovered we thought certain types of customers were inefficient, but now we have data to say, oh yeah, yep, we're we're not doing this. When a client says, I need you to do a bunch of extra free stuff for me, say, sorry, not interested. And the ability for us to start saying no to clients around we're actually not interested in renewing your contract. I'm sorry, but when was last time a growing agency said we're actually going to shun a bunch of revenue? Well, it turns out until you have the data, the cost data where you're you're tracking who's doing what for clients, until you have that kind of information, you could find yourself with a book of business that you think is glorious, but in fact, you're underwater having all these types of clients.

James Thompson

So centralizing the data on who we're talking to as prospects, who we've signed, who people are within those client organizations, and then the cost information about each of those clients. You know, those are two of the most important steps we made so that we could focus on running properly towards certain prospects and running away from certain prospects or running away from certain types of work. That that was that was extremely important for us. And quite frankly, uh, too many years went by before we got our act together and wrote those checks to get those software tools in place.

Yoni Kozminski

And I think that's really uh common for most people. Like we're we're in a position now where we're, you know, and this is the this is the game we play, you know, we're bootstrapped, we're almost over indexing on building out teams around the data before we have the number of clients to back those decisions because we know the importance of making those good decisions. So it's that that balance. But I think that too many companies uh, and you know what, I'll say, particularly inside of the Amazon space as an FBA seller. Um, Amazon is one of the great companies in our lifetime, and it's so good that it enables growth at a scale for FBA sellers that you know isn't really possible in in almost any other ecosystem in the environment. So getting ahead of those decisions early and almost overindexing on the data-driven decisions as you get to two and three and five and 15 million dollars is going to absolutely set you up for you know an accurate growth trajectory versus oh shit, I've got no growth capital anymore to invest into inventory.

Yoni Kozminski

I've got like, you know, six people, one person when it's 25, he's worth 130,000 out of Amazon just because he worked at Amazon before you know it. You grow, you know, you're growing, but you're not scaling, you're not getting to a point where uh where you're actually the profit in the business is growing. You're just simply growing the revenue, and you know, it's uh sort of uh diminishing returns as a business. So I think that, you know, to your point, those data backed decisions, investing in the tools that are going to enable you to give you that level of visibility to make better decisions and saying no. I mean, you know, there is uh, you know what, there is not much uh there's not a better feeling in the world where you're at a position where you can say no to a client because you know that it's going to be a headache for your team, and it's not really what it's just not a right fit for you and for them. And so, you know, making those decisions and having the data to back it is a pretty special moment, I think, in any business's you know, uh any business's lifetime. All right, right.

James Thompson

Well, it's also a point where you realize for better or for worse, we're now at a point that we can be picky. And when you're a startup company, it's easy to believe that you can't be picky. You got to take all the business that comes your way. The moment you can start to be picky, you have a much better sense of who you are, what you're good at doing, what you're not good at doing, and who the types of companies are that you ultimately want to be working with. Uh, you know, many years ago, I was a general consultant. As a general consultant, your job is to say yes to anybody who shows up with money in hand. And the moment you realize that I can afford to not say yes to everyone, but also it's irresponsible of me to say yes to everyone. That becomes a glorious thing. One of the best things that I have learned as a professional is the more we learn how to say no, and the more we are able to actually say we have a clearer sense of what our strategy is. Strategy is about making choices.

James Thompson

And yet, as an agency, as a consultant, we often don't make enough choices because we're just trying to pay the bills. But once we get good enough that we can say no, what we're doing is we're being true to our strategy. And all too often it takes too long before you are actually true to your strategy. You put down something on paper that says this is our strategy of who we're going after, what we're gonna do, and then somebody comes along and says, I'll give you money to do something different. And you're like, okay, because variance can't be that bad. Well, variance is terrible. And as soon as you learn that, as soon as you realize that you have to say no sometimes in order to be true to your company, true to your employees, true to the types of training you have or haven't given them. You know, that that's a very, very important part of learning how to scale is saying no. Wow.

Yoni Kozminski

Um, I've got to say, James, just sitting here, I'm leaving inspired. Uh, I had some pivotal decisions to make about exactly the topics you talk about right now. You know, there's some amazing opportunities that are sort of sitting in the wings right now, but it's a deviation from the strategy. And so even though you know the money

James Thompson

that's that's your hundred million dollar idea. Put it aside. Yeah, it's it's a good idea, but not for right now.

Yoni Kozminski

And that's spot on. Uh, that is spot on. So, do you know what? I know that we're getting to the end here. So I want to be respectful of your time. And uh firstly, I want to thank you for taking the time to sit with me. I've loved every minute. And, you know, I'm sure those listening at home will gain, you know, as much as I have from, you know, just the wisdom and the insights about what it takes at some of the biggest companies and the most hyper growth business, you know, in our lifetime. Uh, being a part of that would have been an incredible experience and being able to share that wisdom. For anyone that might want to get in touch with you, leverage buy box experts. I mean, I know that you're no longer, I mean, you're connected maybe to the prospero show, which I'm I'll hopefully be attending. So hopefully see you there in the flesh. It'll be nice to get around people. But what would be the best way to find out about any of the million solutions you're attached to and leverage them?

James Thompson

I am definitely active on LinkedIn, James Thompson on LinkedIn. You can also find me at James at BuyboxExperts.com. So thank you, Yoni, for having me. This has been a pleasure. I look forward to doing this again. Likewise.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, I would love to have you on again. So uh you just wait, you just wait, and uh, I'll be following up with you soon. Thank you. All right, thank you. Take care.

Episode details

Series
Successful Scales
Host
Yoni Kozminski
Episode
28
Published
May 7, 2021
Transcript
11,324 words