Successful Scales · Episode 40 · June 18, 2021

Ep 40: Impact and Value of IP to Business, When to Consider & Apply For Patent with Rich Goldstein - Principal Patent Attorney at Goldstein Patent Law

A conversation hosted by Yoni Kozminski. Listen above or read the full transcript below.

In this episode

We've reached our 40th episode! Host Yoni Kozminski spoke with Rich Goldstein - Principal Patent Attorney at Goldstein Patent Law, host of the "Innovations and Breakthroughs" Podcast, and author of the best selling book: The ABA Consumer Guide to Obtaining a Patent.

Rich helps small businesses, start-ups, ecommerce and digital marketers, and inventors in their quest to obtain patent protection.

Yoni on LinkedIn - https://linkedin.com/in/yonkoz/

MultiplyMii Staffing - https://multiplymii.com

What they get into

  • Impact of IP to business
  • Patent infringement
  • IP strategy
  • When to consider/apply for patent

Questions Yoni asks

  1. I mean, already so many interesting um decisions that you made in such an early point in your career. I mean, it is very atypical to go straight from you should usually it takes people sort of four or five years to realize that they weren't built for practicing law. So to make that jump effectively and and and really sort of honing in. I mean, what what was that?

  2. I mean, I know we're going back a few years now, but how is that received?

  3. Like help help me understand a little bit about what, you know, we had some great conversations that I want to dive into uh, you know, in the last couple of hours we've been chatting, but yeah, what does it look like today?

  4. Yeah, I mean, that's that's that is the way to approach scale, absolutely. And there's those aspects that you have to have a strong enough handle of for you as the the operator as well, you you know, you're not gonna simply delegate out tasks that you have absolutely zero idea about, especially as a business owner. So yeah, I can totally relate to that. But you know what?

  5. And how's that actually impacting a, I would say their business on the day to day, you know, what as me as a as a potential e-commerce seller, what does that look like?

  6. And you know, for those who are looking to exit, I mean, how much can this really impact their business when when you're talking multiples and exit value?

  7. And and so, you know, as someone like I said, who's selfishly going to take this opportunity to ask a series of questions aboutficially on behalf of your audience?

  8. What are my what are my perceivable realities when it comes to my appetite for how much risk there is?

From the conversation

“They are um, you know, their their patents are going out into the weeds quite a bit often, where the improvement, it might not be that big of a deal. So it's like, okay, then someone comes along and they add um, you know, kind of um, you know, curved armrests that kind of like um go straight across and curve down in the front, and then the question becomes that now that they're getting a patent on um on the chair with these armrests of a certain configuration, does that matter to the market?…”

— Rich Goldstein

“It is a whole new area. I mean, I actually I put together a presentation on that for Kevin King. You know, you know, Kevin. I do, I do. Yeah. So for his Billion Dollar Seller Summit um uh about a year ago, I did a presentation on how exactly you can hunt through the files of the US patents to look for um and um an existing product and um and then how to make it your own. Um so yeah, there's definitely um that is definitely good possibility there. The one thing I…”

— Rich Goldstein

“Yeah, the and and I'm glad you said that what was the right time to consider because that's how I would look at it too, is to really divide the line between considering and actually uh applying, right? So I would consider it and I would I would invest in looking into it before you launch. So, like before you launch, you want to figure out like is this something that I can get strong protection for not because uh first of all, in in many cases, there'll be nothing to that it's not possible…”

— Rich Goldstein

“Yeah, well, I mean, there's different databases um that are available for um for for looking up patents. I mean, there's even something called Google patents, you know, it's it's patents PATENTS.google.com. It's a search engine for patents. Um, and so you can you can um look up patents in that way. Um, but there's some limitations to it in terms of effectiveness. It's like finding the closest things to it requires some skill, uh, and it requires going beyond just doing a word search. Uh, you know, an example I like to give is…”

— Rich Goldstein

“allocate a certain budget to IP, knowing that over time we're going to expand that and seek to get more and more of what we can, build an IP portfolio. But yeah, generally those people who've had those experiences, they become true believers. And some of those people are people that had a negative experience, people who had a few hundred thousand dollars in inventory and suddenly they had to eat it, you know, they had to change the name of their company because they they didn't do their due diligence with regards to the…”

— Rich Goldstein
Read the full conversation
Full transcript9,252 words · speaker-labelled source
Transcript note: This transcript comes from the Successful Scales production archive. It may contain transcription errors. Exact quotations should be checked against the audio before reuse.
Yoni Kozminski

On today's episode, I sat down with Rich Goldstein. Rich is a career patent lawyer, having studied both engineering and law, making a very unique combination in understanding what it takes to bring a patent and therefore a product to market. I really dove in asking questions around the value of what does that bring to a business upon exit and during the lifetime of the business while owning products. How does that really help you protect against potential competitors coming in? And for me, it was really fascinating. It's a topic that is, in my opinion, not talked about enough, but something that can really set you up for success when it comes to building and potentially selling businesses. So I hope you take what I took from this episode. Enjoy. Hi, and welcome to Successful Scales, the show where I interview now successful professionals about their journey and try and garner insights onto any tips that can be applied to your business at home, whether it's financial freedom or the exit of your company, wherever your journey may take you. The idea here is to simply learn from those who have done it before. I hope you enjoy and you get some value out of this. Buckle up and enjoy the episode.

Yoni Kozminski

Rich, welcome to an episode of Successful Scales, my friend. Hey, thanks so much. Yeah. I mean, we have literally, I feel like I've known you for a lifetime, and we've only probably sat down for a couple of hours now. But uh it's been amazing getting to know you.

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, likewise, absolutely. And and uh so glad to be on your show here today.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, fun. Yeah, well, uh, like I said, really just grateful to have you here. And I think that you know, your position and what you do today is super interesting, relevant and very current, and something that I think more and more, you know, when you talk about the rise of the aggregators and the value that businesses have, so much of it is inside of that intellectual property and that effectively that that massive differentiator. But before we dive into the current state, I'd love for those listening at home, and honestly, for me as well, I'd love to find out a little bit more about your history and sort of what's led you to the point and where you sit today. All right, cool.

Rich Goldstein

So um about my history, anything particular.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, just about my history professional, let's keep I know I know we were saying we could probably have a conversation for six hours and do 45 episodes together, but uh let me narrow the field. So professionally speaking.

Rich Goldstein

Sounds good. Well, I mean, I started out by studying electrical engineering, uh, realized that that um becoming an engineer wouldn't be as interesting as I thought it was going in. Uh, that you're really working on a minute portion of a product for years at a time. And uh I I found out about patent law. Um, and and which involves being a lawyer, you know, you need to be an attorney, of course. Um, but you also need to be an engineer to understand the technology. And um, so I finished my electrical engineering um studies and went on to law school. And then I did something unusual. Uh, I opened up my own practice right out of law school. So I I never had a job at another law firm, you know, uh as a lawyer, right? Um, I mean, I worked for a summer during law school at a law firm. That was it. That was enough to tell me that I never wanted to work out another law firm again. So created my own law firm right out of law school. And um, 27 years later, I'm still here. Wow.

Yoni Kozminski

I mean, already so many interesting um decisions that you made in such an early point in your career. I mean, it is very atypical to go straight from you should usually it takes people sort of four or five years to realize that they weren't built for practicing law. So to make that jump effectively and and and really sort of honing in. I mean, what what was that?

Rich Goldstein

They weren't built for for working on a law firm and to develop the contacts and and to have some clients so that when they do go hang up a shingle, they have some money coming in and not just starting from nothing. So, yeah, that's more typically how it's done.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, yeah, I mean, uh absolutely. And I think I find that super interesting, having the engineering meets law background. I mean, you know, in inside of our consulting practice, I would say the bulk of talent that we have are industrial engineers because of how sort of uh how would I put it like very systems

Rich Goldstein

focused a certain way of thinking, right? About things.

Yoni Kozminski

Absolutely. So to have that coupled with law, I think also there's there's similarities that exist between the two, but um but super interesting. Wow. Um, I didn't really I didn't realize that that was your background. So I'm glad to I'm glad to hear it. But it sounds like you know, you would define yourself, or I'll defined you, I'll put it out there. Pretty much that that's that's super entrepreneurial to go down what is extremely too, you know, not clinical necessarily, but very typical, you know, go to law school, go to become an engineer, and now you're effectively starting your own business. I mean, how did you even approach that?

Rich Goldstein

Which are very much usually about like just being part of the system, like working in the framework, like being part of an engineering firm or being part of a a law firm. Uh yeah, I mean uh and yet there's been this entrepreneurial part of it. So it is kind of uh it definitely has been quite interesting.

Yoni Kozminski

How is that received? I mean, I know we're going back a few years now, but how is that received? You know, if you you know, surely your parents are super happy, you've studied law, you studied engineering, you've got all the markings, and then you decide to start your own business. Not well, was not received well, you know.

Rich Goldstein

Like I remember actually uh starting my a friend of mine, like my best friend bumped into my parents around that time. Uh and they were telling him, like, don't you think he should get a job? Don't you think you'd be better off? Like, don't you, you know, like they were they expressed a lot of concern to my friend. Uh, you know, I'll never forget that. And and basically, yeah, it was not, and my parents are relatively low risk type people. Also, my father worked as an engineer for the city of New York, his entire career. Um, he he worked for the city of New York, and my mom uh, you know, worked at the post office. Um, you know, um, kind of like uh for about 15 years up into retirement. So they're you know, relatively low risk type people. And for me to give up what they perceived as like, well, that's the dream job, you know, making six figures, working at a law firm, you know, and um, you know, like why would you give that up? Like I, you know, I didn't want to work 80 hours a week. Um, and I didn't want to kind of be beholden to others that um had just a very different way of looking at things than I did. So uh yeah, I was uh it was it was definitely not a um um a well supported choice, but it was um, you know, it it definitely was one that I was determined to make.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, and and I think that that's probably something that you know, when you go down that path of entrepreneurship that it's seldom spoken about, but one of the more challenging things is that perception of the risk versus reward. And you know, most people are gonna take on that traditional nine to five and climb the ladder. And I was there as well. I I spent, you know, unlike you, I spent 10 years doing it. I worked for people. I would say that I got a lot of my extremely valuable learning through that through that process. But I think that even when you you make that jump, whatever point of the career it is, you know, it's always met with some degree of uh, you know, I mean, there's obviously uncertainty attached to it, but there's always that degree of are you making the right decision? Uh how hard was that for you to, you know, and I, you know, I'm imagining as well, you know, you're going

Rich Goldstein

back for me, it was just natural. It's like, yep, this is what I'm doing. Um, and at the same time, I also um was involved in launching a magazine for inventors. So I had a a lead gen pathway. I was putting out a magazine for inventors, um, and advertising my my law firm in that magazine. So it's like I was doing content marketing in the 90s in print form. So I kind of had a whole scheme set up. So I was I was um, you know, I was all in. Um there was no hesitation on my part that I was making the right choice. Um, you know, I had decided the previous summer working at that law firm that you're like, no, this is it. I am not ever going to do this again. Wow.

Yoni Kozminski

I mean, it's it's just incredible to to meet people who who actually make that very calculated decision so early in their careers, you know. I gotta say, it's uh got more balls than I have, uh, in terms of uh, you know, jumping in uh, you know, head first, you know, you know, something something like that. Yeah, yeah. So I mean, 27 years on now, what what is life look like in terms of your operation? Like help help me understand a little bit about what, you know, we had some great conversations that I want to dive into uh, you know, in the last couple of hours we've been chatting, but yeah, what does it look like today?

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, I have like 10 people on my team. Um, and uh what does it look like? It looks like I mean, it looks like a good amount of of this, what we're doing right here. I spend a good deal of my time um, you know, on you know, on podcasts or other people on my podcast, or on on webinars, speaking at events. Um, you know, I'm kind of the um brand the the brand for my law firm. So um so I spend a good amount of time doing that, building relationships in general, um, building relationships with people, uh, a good amount of of time and attention, then focused on lead generation. Um, and um also then directing the team, you know, like directing the team, running the team. I do work with my clients uh directly. Uh I'm not necessarily doing the work, probably not doing the work, but I am figuring out what what needs to be and then making sure it gets handled, making sure it gets done in that way. So I'm I'm kind of spending time with clients on strategy. Um, and uh um that's mainly what what my day is like.

Rich Goldstein

I'm not in the trenches writing patent applications anymore, like I spent a lot of my career doing. Um, and um so yeah, it's it's basically like anyone else running a business. It's like um you run the business that um you know you you delegate what you can um to people that are on your team, you handle the things that are not delegable, or at least at this moment or with this level of scale, right? And then um, and then you you look for opportunities for bringing more people onto your team to handle those things that that um then could allow you to move up to the next level.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, that's that's that is the way to approach scale, absolutely. And there's those aspects that you have to have a strong enough handle of for you as the the operator as well, you you know, you're not gonna simply delegate out tasks that you have absolutely zero idea about, especially as a business owner. So yeah, I can totally relate to that. But you know what? I'm gonna take this opportunity to be well, I don't know if it's selfish, uh, but you know, it's not every day that I get to sit down with someone who is at the forefront of what is an ever changing uh and a super exciting time in the e-commerce and Amazon space in particular, um, to ask questions about intellectual property. And so, you know, I'm I'm very fortunate that I get to spend spend a lot of time speaking with people just like you do, and I devote a lot of my time to the same things around having podcasts and having super stimulating conversations with people in all walks of life. But I'd say one of the things that's come up a ton lately is just how frequently Amazon businesses are being sold to aggregators and venture capital and strategics and you know, the likes of anyone that's acquiring it's a real it's a real seller's market, I really feel at the moment, in that you know, you're seeing multiples continuing to go up. And you know, I've always wondered not ever having a patent related to to a business to date. Um, I dug in last time and I had so many questions for you, you know, the challenges around a service-based business and how do you actually effectively protect that IP. But uh what are you seeing when it comes to you know companies that do have intellectual property and patents taken out? And how's that actually impacting a, I would say their business on the day to day, you know, what as me as a as a potential e-commerce seller, what does that look like? And you know, for those who are looking to exit, I mean, how much can this really impact their business when when you're talking multiples and exit value?

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, absolutely. And I think that's that's a good way to divide it up too. It's like, how does IP affect the day to day? And then how does IP affect the exit? Um, and like to me, those are the two major buckets of of where you would look to measure the impact. And I'll just simplify it by saying that the IP may or may not affect um your day-to-day. Um, it in other words, it may give you some ability to stop competitors to um, you know, to gain an ROI from the from the IP based upon your ability to stop competitors. Um, but it almost certainly will be valuable at exit. So it's like those are the two dividing points. And it's like when you're running a business, it's hard not to look at um how any particular expense affects your day to day, because really during the running of your business, during the operation of your business, IP is just is plainly an expense, right? It's an expense. Um and like you always measure the expense with what the benefit is that it's it's providing to you. You know, if you're spending money on PP PPC, how much is it helping sales? If you're spending money on a certain consultant, how much is that affecting kind of your ability to get products out there to sell products, et cetera? Um, so you're spending money on IP, you're looking at like so, okay. So if I'm gonna spend money on this patent, is it going to tangibly affect my day-to-day? And so the way it could tangibly affect your day to day, obviously, is like if you're selling 200,000 worth of product, and then um suddenly um a bunch of competitors come in and they take a quarter of your market share, um, then that's $50,000 a month. So if you're able to shut them down because you have a certain um uh patent or series of patents or with some IP, then that's IP is worth $50,000 a month, plainly. Um I can it's not always that we get to see that though. It's not very often that we get to see that type of measurable result, where at exit it's a different story.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, I can say being on the receiving end, the Amazon business I was working uh with that that was uh effectively sold. Uh, one of the owners, uh one of the original co-founders of the business was not the most um adept to doing serious research. And so there was a product we were selling that you know, we were selling this uh kids' lap tray. There was a patent on I don't know, the stitching, the I don't even know what it was, to be honest with you, and off you go. We had this whole dispute with Amazon, you know, in the end, we just decided it's not even worth fighting it because for the time that it's going to be down, you know, let's give up. And we did a removal order and we got on with it. And so, you know, I can say unequivocally, yeah, had a hugely positive impact on that person's business and totally destroyed any revenue or any way that we would have recouped anything that related to that uh particular skew. So, you know, yeah, definitely and

Rich Goldstein

and that that happens, but uh it's not it's not the the most typical thing, like this is what this is though what people are looking for when they're going to invest money in the IP, they're really thinking in terms of that type of scenario. Like, is it going to tangibly affect my bottom line as I'm operating? And they're not looking to this whole other area, which is like, well, how's it going to affect the purchase price when I sell my business? Or how is it even going to affect whether the purchase can whether well whether the sale can be made, whether I can sell my business, and yet um that is often where it has the biggest impact, is right there at the moment of um that you are that you are um exiting your business that you're selling, um is like that having the IP and not having the IP can be the difference significant uh amount of valuation, and it could be the reason why they someone else passes on buying a company. They say, Well, you don't have the you don't have the um trademark protection for the brand, so they're not going to buy it.

Yoni Kozminski

And and so, you know, as someone like I said, who's selfishly going to take this opportunity to ask a series of questions aboutficially on behalf of your audience?

Rich Goldstein

So that's not really exactly.

Yoni Kozminski

You know, yeah, you're right. I'm sure if I've got these questions, and you know, typically a lot of people will as well.

Rich Goldstein

You don't want to talk more about my background.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, back to engineering.

Rich Goldstein

So a lot of great stories, but we'll we'll talk about those another time.

Yoni Kozminski

I can't wait to wait to hear those. Uh listen, I mean, you you're uh you're a slick guy to be creating that uh form of marketing back in the 90s. I can only imagine some of the some of the stories that I'm sure we'll share uh over hopefully a few beers at Prosper uh next month. Absolutely. Yep. But while I'm being selfish uh myself and the audience, I will ask the question that I think uh a lot of people sort of getting into, you know, a lot of people look at getting into Amazon, it's the easiest, it's easy. I'm just gonna dive right in, I'm gonna find a product, I'm gonna go to AliExpress or wherever else I'm searching, and off I go. And I think that you know the the risk when you're starting to run a business and you haven't done your due diligence on what exists in market, what are the potential complications? What are my what are my perceivable realities when it comes to my appetite for how much risk there is? I mean, how do you even start the process? Let's say I've gone down the path, I've identified a product. How do I know that I'm not gonna come up and hit that brick wall that we hit selling a product someone else has a patent against?

Rich Goldstein

Well, I would say you don't know, like the the it's you really when you're starting out small, you don't know if you're gonna hit that brick wall. I and I would say the biggest um um the the biggest thing you can do is to use common sense is like you know, if you if you know you're copying a product, then um you know imagine that there might be some IP to it. Um that you're you're better off um for something that has been around is more established. It's a product that maybe has been on the market for 20 or 30 years, and you kind of can pretty much rest assured that you're not going to be um infringing a patent, like that's again using common sense, also using common sense. It's like you you want to sell a product and you want to make it look just like a competitor's and have a brand name that sounds just like their name, because you're thinking like, okay, well, they'll buy mine by mistake. Well, you're probably walking right into a trademark problem there. And it's again, it's common sense. If you think that you're doing something wrong, you probably are. Um it's not always actionable, it's not always something that they can take action from. Not every type of copying is going to land you into trouble. But that's one of the ways to minimize your risk is to use some common sense uh about it. And I'd say too many people don't.

Yoni Kozminski

So you said something before, and and I I think I'm picking up what you're putting down, but you said that you pick products that have been around for 20, 30 years. Is that because the patent expires over a period of time? Exactly.

Rich Goldstein

Exactly. So if you're going to sell uh like a product that has been out there, let's say for for 30 years, you can know pretty safely that there's no patent on that product. Whatever was out there 30 years ago, it's not possible for it to still be patented. Um, you know, for the for the the same thing as was out then. It is possible that the improved version, um, why is that because uh uh a patent um a patent lasts for 20 years after you a utility patent lasts for 20 years after you apply for it? You need to apply for the patent. Um, at least going back then, the the laws changed just a tiny bit, but you need to apply for a patent within one year of the time it's publicly disclosed. So you can safely say that um unless they applied for the patent, like um, you know uh 21, 22 years ago, then um in which case the patent would have expired already, then they would have lost the right to have a patent it. So um the the um you know the the rule has always been it's changed slightly lately, but the rule had always been that if if you publicly disclose an invention within one year you need to apply for the patent, or it's just in the public domain, it's open to anyone. So if you see a stapler out there from 30 years ago, you can safely say that if I want to make that exact stapler, I'm free to do so.

Rich Goldstein

But what you can't do is um you can't um copy any of the improvements that have happy to law happened along the way. So you notice that maybe for the last five years, there's been um like staple of staplers have had this kind of new release lever or something like that. It maybe that there's a patent on that. You can't say that that that's free for you to do, but whatever it is that had been done way back then, you can do exactly that. And by the way, the same thing goes for if you feel like hunting through the records of um of United States patents and you find one that's interesting and expired, you're free to do that. You're free to make exactly that product in that patent. So that's just one way to reduce the risk. Um, and um, but yeah, in general, like when you start, you know what when you know you're copying someone, you're running a risk. And I think that's that's the common sense that should um enter into it. And it's rather difficult to determine when you're infringing and when you're not infringing. It's the most expensive and most difficult thing that anyone could ask me is to say, well, I've got this product here. How do I know if I'm infringing anyone else's patent? Or can you find out for me, am I infringing anyone's uh and anyone else's patent? That's called freedom to operate research, where you're really looking for the freedom to know that you can go out and make this product and not step on anyone's toes. Um, but it's possible that any product, especially any somewhat involved product, could have patents on many different aspects of it.

Rich Goldstein

There could be a patent on the um, you know, the connector system, kind of like the lightning connector in an iPhone, or there could be a patent on the um the way the battery compartment is configured, or there could be a patent on some aspect of the circuitry, or the look of it, a design patent for the look of the product. There's so many different directions that that can go in. Um that it's an extremely involved project to do a freedom to operate review. The one footnote I'll add to that is the extent to which you could limit the area of search, the way you could limit the type of info that uh patent attorney would need to review to figure that out, that will help you tremendously. So it's like if you know the product and you know the patent number, then that's going to make it a much narrower project. Then it's like, well, here's the product. I don't know what patents there are, but what am I infringing? That's that's a much more difficult project. That's like a that's easily 10 to 20 times more involved than if you just had an identified patent, and you're saying, can you help me determine if I'm infringing? And and uh is there a way around this patent?

Yoni Kozminski

So it's so funny. I'm sitting here and I'm literally, I I think uh, I don't know if it's the way my mind works. And I'm thinking, well, how can I find my way around this? So what statute, uh, maybe not statute of limitation, but what expectation is there on you, the patent lawyer versus the governing body of US patents who are actually reviewing it? Like, why couldn't I safely just say, right? I'm gonna put this patent, I don't really give a shit if it exists or it doesn't, I'm gonna submit it. They'll come back and they'll say, Well, sorry, you're actually infringing. Why couldn't I have them do the work?

Rich Goldstein

Oh, great question. And uh and it's uh because you getting a patent um is not a guarantee that you're not infringing anyone else. Uh and and so, like them deter when they're determining whether you can get a patent for your product, um, they're not looking at infringement. And I know this makes absolutely no sense. I'm gonna make it clear in a moment. Because the reason it makes no sense is because people would say, Well, okay, so wait a second. So if I'm close enough um that uh that I'm not gonna get a patent, that must mean I'm close enough that I'm infringing, or they or the opposite, though, is what they're usually thinking. It's like, well, if I'm different enough that I can get my own patent, that must mean that I'm different enough that I'm not infringing, right? Yeah. Doesn't work that way. Uh, I'll explain how and it'll make total sense. It's like imagine you invented um uh you invented a chair, right? You invented a chair with four legs and a seat. So like I guess it's more like a stool, but that's the chair that you invented. Uh, you're able to patent that. I come along a few years later, and I invent a chair with four legs, a seat, and I add this like the seat back to it to make it more comfortable on your back, right?

Rich Goldstein

So I add the seat back to your your chair. Um, the patent office will say, Well, you've made an improvement. Um, and that improvement is worthy of a patent. So they'll grant me my patent for my chair with four legs, a seat and a seat back, but I can't manufacture a chair with four legs, a seat and a seat back without making a chair with four legs and a seat, right? So your patent is a subcombination of my invention. And therefore, I can't make my chair without infringing your patent. So um, and that's often how it goes. When something is groundbreaking, then the patent on it is for the core combination of what makes it work. Um, as time goes on and people improve upon it, they're able to get patents on their improvements. Um, and you know, they still though could be infringing the original one, but there's something also that's important to understand about that. So the people that come later on that they didn't have the original concept, they're getting a patent on the improvements.

Rich Goldstein

They are um, you know, their their patents are going out into the weeds quite a bit often, where the improvement, it might not be that big of a deal. So it's like, okay, then someone comes along and they add um, you know, kind of um, you know, curved armrests that kind of like um go straight across and curve down in the front, and then the question becomes that now that they're getting a patent on um on the chair with these armrests of a certain configuration, does that matter to the market? Does the market care about your curved armrests? Or do the competitors look at it and say, well, we don't need the curve armrest? Um, then that patent's not very valuable. And this is the most important thing, I think, for people to take away is that every patent has a scope. And some patents cover a whole concept, and some are very specific. Uh, before you invest money in a patent, you want to figure out what you're getting. Uh, are you getting something that's going to cover, you know, four legs and a seat? And then like you'll be able to shut down all the other listings because um, because they can't make the chair without four legs and a seat, or are you getting one that has just a lot of detail and in order to get the patent, you need to limit it to a lot of the detail of what makes yours work, but that's not necessarily things that other people are going to want to copy. Then you might want to think twice about getting the patent.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, I my mind just goes to the most obscure places right now. And I'm hearing you sort of explain the the limitations. I'm sitting here thinking, all right. So this guy's got a great idea. He's had five years in market with this patent, 10 years in it. I'm not gonna be able to uh, you know, I'm not gonna be able to claim it, but I'll make all these incredible upgrades. I'll, you know, and then five years from now, 10 years from now, when it, you know, when it actually expires, then I'm gonna absolutely crush it, and they're not going to be able to come to market with it anymore because now I've created all these upgrades, you know. Yeah, you could and then and then the other thing I

Rich Goldstein

was and you might even be able to do better than that too, is like, so imagine like um there's this core product that one company has the patent to, and then you come up with like uh a bunch of really cool enhancements to it. Um, and then you go you go to that company and you say, Look, I've I've improved upon your product in this really cool way. If you'd like, if you'd like to give me a license so I can make the chair of your patent, then um I'll give you a license, and you could include these improvements in your product. It's called cross licensing.

Yoni Kozminski

Can you can you also and then what's some of the other deal like? Could I also effectively just broker a deal with someone who has the patent, say, Hey, I want to sell this with the add-ons, and you give them some sort of a uh commission or or whatever that sort of

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, it's just a that's like a licensing agreement where you're just um um you're making a contract with the patent holder, um, giving you the right to make the product, or basically um the right to not get sued by them while you're making the product, and uh in return you pay a royalty, and that's that's one uh outcome that that can come out of uh these like um scenarios on Amazon when you're found to be infringing someone else, is like you can work out an agreement with them like that. And I think Amazon, even in the um in when they contact you, they say like contact the rights holder to to um to make arrangements because they are that's what they are hoping is that you make arrangements and you continue to sell and and they continue to sell and everybody's happy and uh um everybody wins. So, yeah, that's that's a that's a possible way to do it.

Yoni Kozminski

That's I'll tell you uh I'll take it. It's it's great to know. And I would say I'll tell you where else my mind went is that you know, at some point in time, someone who is really investing in their idea to the level where they've created a patent, you know. Why wouldn't I simply look 20 years back into areas that are interesting to me and then start to say, right, this is expired. This is a great idea. Someone's invested that much. That could be a whole new idea. I'm just thinking that's a whole new area where I can start to get product ideas.

Rich Goldstein

It is a whole new area. I mean, I actually I put together a presentation on that for Kevin King. You know, you know, Kevin. I do, I do. Yeah. So for his Billion Dollar Seller Summit um uh about a year ago, I did a presentation on how exactly you can hunt through the files of the US patents to look for um and um an existing product and um and then how to make it your own. Um so yeah, there's definitely um that is definitely good possibility there. The one thing I would say about it though is you have to hunt through a lot of like um so-so ideas to find some good ones. Um, but one of the benefits is that so when someone applies for a patent, you must or they must provide enough detail so that someone in the field can essentially produce the invention from the description without too much experimentation. Like you don't there's no dimensions typically in patents, and you don't have to say whether it's a you know it's a machine screw or like a tapping screw or whatever, like you don't need those fine details, but you need to give enough detail so that people in the field just know what it is and how it works. So any patent that you find will have that level of detail because that's what they had to do, you know, whatever.

Rich Goldstein

50 years ago, they decided that this um hair dryer concoction was something worth patenting, and they went to the time and trouble of fully explaining how it works, and it's all laid out for you right there in the patent.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, fascinating. Fascinating. I'll tell you what I find also really interesting is that you know, when I think about the typical entrepreneur, right? They're head down, driving forward, trying to get whatever it is, you know, that we're talking products, particularly getting it up off the ground, right? And now there's a lot of moving parts when you're building a business, when you're building uh, you know, when you're building an Amazon business, an e-commerce business, you know, you go to the manufacturers, you're having to deal with supply chain and logistics, you're building the listings, you're looking to market the product if it's outside of Amazon, you need to build email campaigns and landing page funnels and whatever it looks like. I mean, it's really endless, media buying, etc. You've only got 12 months to actually get a patent out on that product once it's been launched from you know, once it's visible as I understand it to the public market. How many people are going in with that level of education, knowing that they need to do this? And you know, like I just think there must be an insane amount of people who've missed out on enormous opportunities because they just haven't got on this fast enough.

Rich Goldstein

Insane amount of people, insane amount of people. And that's why anytime I do a presentation, that's one of the things I want to hit on, because uh I know uh I mean, just throughout my career. Um, well, look, let's put it this way as an entrepreneur, one of the primary things you need to do when you're launching a business is to preserve your resources and to make good choices about how you allocate your resources. And people very often when they're launching a product, they'll say that you know, patent sounds like a good idea, but it's very expensive. So I'll wait, I'll come back around to it. Um, and often what would have would happen, what I've seen happen is then they um they put the product on the market, a couple of years go by, things are going great, and they come to me and they say, Well, I've got this product, it's doing phenomenally, I need to protect it. And I have to ask them the question that I don't want the answer to, which is well, how long has it been out there? And they'll tell me 10 two years, and I'll say, Well, it's too late. You know, I'd love to take this project from you.

Rich Goldstein

Obviously, you can pay to have this done, but I can't help you because it's just too late. And they'll often say, 'Well, how would I have even known that?' It's like, you wouldn't. It's not like they teach about patents in high school, it's not like the required curriculum. So that's the one thing I always want to get across is is this. And I'll just say it this way is if you put a product on the market before you uh apply for a patent, um, you immediately lose the rights in most of the world. Uh, and in the US, where there's still a one-year grace period, if a year goes by uh and you haven't applied for the patent, then it's game over. So there and there are other ways to lose out too. That's kind of like you know, assuming no one copies it and assuming no no one else applies for the patent. Um, because the US is now a first to file system. So the first person to file a patent application is the one entitled to the patent. So there's other ways to lose out, but but assuming that no one else was even involved, no one else was even trying their own version of it. Simply your own action of making it public is what could cause you to lose all the all of your rights, the right to ever patent it.

Yoni Kozminski

It's uh intimidating here. So okay, so I'm uh I'm uh I'm gonna launch uh an Amazon business. I'm gonna launch an e-commerce business. I'm relatively confident while I'm going through this process that what I've come up with is is pretty good. And you know, I have every intent to sell in market. What stage in your mind is the right time to really start considering bringing on a patent? Is it before I've hit day one? And I'm like, well, I'm pretty confident without any backline insights, or is it six months in? Like what what are you typically saying is the the right time?

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, the and and I'm glad you said that what was the right time to consider because that's how I would look at it too, is to really divide the line between considering and actually uh applying, right? So I would consider it and I would I would invest in looking into it before you launch. So, like before you launch, you want to figure out like is this something that I can get strong protection for not because uh first of all, in in many cases, there'll be nothing to that it's not possible to protect it, and then you don't need to bother at all. Then you can like kind of go forward like full force to get the product out there, knowing like it's not um, you know, it's not protected. It's like so often, like when people aren't protected, but they're still thinking about protection, they'll put one foot forward and one foot back, where it's like, okay, I'm launching this product. Oh, Oprah wants to have it on her show. And he's like, Well, I don't know if we're ready for that. People might steal it, you know. So it's like you're you're kind of hesitant about it. But if you figure out at an early stage, there's no possible way to protect this, then you could just full force go out there in the world knowing that, like, hey, look, I'm just gonna I'm gonna get it out there, I'm gonna do the best I can. And like, I don't have to like um do it with hesitance as if like you know, I'm not ready to put it out there full force because I haven't protected it yet. So that's a good positive outcome is to figure out no way to protect this. That's

Rich Goldstein

that's a good uh outcome. And then now you allocate your money towards towards marketing promotion, getting it out there. Um, another possibility is that you might be able to get a patent, but um, by taking the right look at it, you get to see, like, you know what, I'm actually not gonna wouldn't be a very good patent. It would be a patent limited to kind of having these features, and that's probably probably not very valuable to me. So I'm not gonna bother with applying for a patent. And then another outcome possible, it's rare, but it's um possible, is that once you look into it, you say, you know what, this actually be a very good patent. This would be a very strong patent that would preempt a whole new area here. So maybe I should put my resources into getting this patent now, or get some other resources from someone else, knowing that it's important enough to kind of call in that favor or or borrow some money from someone, or whatever you need to do to get it protected now. That's

Rich Goldstein

definitely the minority, but the way that you um you get to determine, well, which direction is right here. Do I never protect it? Is it like that I'm headed for something that's so so in terms of protection? So maybe maybe I do it later, maybe not, or is it something that's like critical? Do it now because the patent may be the most valuable thing that you get for this particular product. Um, and so you I say you consider it before you launch, you know what category you fit in. Um, you know, and the way that you do that is by digging into what other people have done before, uh, called prior art research. Once you know what the prior art is, prior art are things that have come before that are like your patent. Once you know what the prior art is, that's when you can figure out can I get a patent on this whole concept, or has most of this been done before, and then I'm just getting something specific. So that's what you want to do, and that's when you want to consider it.

Yoni Kozminski

How um great great insights, great information? How hard is it to find historic, you know, prior art or patents that have existed? Because I'm just thinking it's done, sounds like by the US government or or somebody inside, like how much how much work are they putting into making that very easy and accessible to identify.

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, well, I mean, there's different databases um that are available for um for for looking up patents. I mean, there's even something called Google patents, you know, it's it's patents PATENTS.google.com. It's a search engine for patents. Um, and so you can you can um look up patents in that way. Um, but there's some limitations to it in terms of effectiveness. It's like finding the closest things to it requires some skill, uh, and it requires going beyond just doing a word search. Uh, you know, an example I like to give is like you have a you invent a new type of can opener, and so you're you're um going to Google patents and you're typing in like can opener with um handle release, right? Because that's what it has, it's a hand release level or whatever. Um, so you're looking, you're searching for can openers, Google Patents is gonna pull up a whole bunch of can openers. But if someone had the same invention as you and they didn't call it a can opener, but they call it a container lid remover, it's not gonna show up in that search. So professional patent searchers use other methodology for finding things of the right technology that isn't necessarily using the same words. So, just as an example, it's like the the point is like you can do searching online and you could find some things out there that are like it, probably enough to tell you like, you know what, this this thing's way closer to it than I even thought existed. Like, let me not bother with this, let me move on to something else. Um

Rich Goldstein

But if you um if you do such searching, and then you determine that there is um uh that that it doesn't seem to be anything that close to it, you still should do a professional search before you go into um you dive ahead into filing a patent application, uh, because if you um you would spend far more money on applying for the patent than on having the professional search done. So it's a good place to start, but you don't want to skip that. And then I probably more importantly than that is the strategy. Just, you know, even getting a bunch of patents in hand and seeing what some of the closer things to it are is helpful. But I think the most important thing in the beginning is strategies to figure out like, well, what's possible here? Like, can you do a patent? What patent should you be applying for? And I think a lot of people just really skip that strategic inquiry at the beginning that I think uh is so important.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I feel like I've learned so much. And it's really uh funny, you know, we were talking about like what's the length of the podcast. I'm looking up and there's literally minutes left uh for us who've just gone on and on about this, and I'm loving every minute of it because you know, it's like every time you meet someone that has a very unique niche skill, there it just is this entire world in and of itself. And so I'm particularly curious when it comes to the types of clients that you're working with. I if I had to guess, I'd assume that you'd almost have these like serial patenteers, the people who are coming and effectively, you know, jumping in from the get-go because they're understanding the impact of business. I mean, is that is that like uh it's like a gate, not a gateway drug, but you know, you you come in, you create one, you see the impact it had on the exit value, or that you could fight everyone off with a stick every time they try to challenge you with their new products bring, you know. Is that is that typically what you see happen, or you know?

Rich Goldstein

I mean, I I I um I see all kinds of um things. I see all kinds of different clients from individuals uh with just one idea that we work on together, um, and they're excited about that one particular idea, but but that's all that we ever work on together. And and I mean a lot of inventors don't get very far with it. Uh, and then you have people, uh I also have bigger companies, not many, but I have some bigger company clients who obviously worked on project after project together. Um and um, you know, but those people like you're discussing, you're the those people that you're describing, the people that have actually played the game of IP and won, then they become true believers. People that have actually seen the value at the time of exit, then yeah, of course, the next business they come around, they start from the very beginning. Let's like, let's come up with an IP strategy. You know, let's start with something now, being that we're, you know, we're this size now, we're small now. Let's

Rich Goldstein

allocate a certain budget to IP, knowing that over time we're going to expand that and seek to get more and more of what we can, build an IP portfolio. But yeah, generally those people who've had those experiences, they become true believers. And some of those people are people that had a negative experience, people who had a few hundred thousand dollars in inventory and suddenly they had to eat it, you know, they had to change the name of their company because they they didn't do their due diligence with regards to the the name of the company. And and so now those people, time and time again are doing the due diligence in the beginning. Either way, however, you get there is uh I I think the the the bottom line message is to find an appropriate relationship to IP. It's not a relationship where IP is extremely valuable in the answer to everything, and it's not the relationship where IP is just a waste of time, it's something in the middle. And that's what I think is important to find as an entrepreneur, an appropriate relationship to IP so that you do the right thing at the right time when it matters.

Yoni Kozminski

I think that's uh extremely valuable words of wisdom as we're about to cut into the the end notes here. So before I do let you go, Rich, I'd love uh you to tell me what's the best way for anyone who's going through this journey, whether they're at the start of it, have a product in market that's sub 12 months, remembering that you you know that's the end of it, um, which is really sad reality when I think about the hard work that's probably gone into people's businesses and and what's happened there. But what's the best way for them to get in touch if they need your your services?

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, best way is to go through my my website, Goldstein Patentlaw.com. Um, and uh you there are great resources there for learning about the patent process. Um, and uh you also can um set up a time to talk with my team to see if it's a match to work together. Um, and you know, I I recommend too, like just really learning about the patent process. I've got a book that I wrote um for the American Bar Association explaining in plain English how this works. You can find that on Amazon. It's the ABA consumer guide to obtaining a patent. Uh and also I've got a podcast where I have awesome people on that have been down this road and they tell the stories of what's worked for them. That's called innovations and breakthroughs. So those are just all resources to help you on your path. But I highly encourage that you learn what you can, or that every entrepreneur learns what they can about IP so that you can make good decisions when uh when IT um issues come around.

Yoni Kozminski

Well, I feel like I've started that journey now with you, mate, and uh I've learned a ton, but you've definitely got me hungry for more. And I think that it's definitely somewhere I'm very curious to see what ideas can be created from new business ideas, particularly around product based businesses. So Rich, thanks so much for sitting down and taking the time out of your busy schedule to sit and help educate me and the listeners. So yeah, uh, it's been an absolute pleasure. Thank you.

Rich Goldstein

Yeah, my pleasure. Thank you for having me.

Episode details

Series
Successful Scales
Host
Yoni Kozminski
Episode
40
Published
June 18, 2021
Transcript
9,252 words