In this episode
In this week's episode, host Yoni Kozminski sat down with Rael Cline - Co-Founder and CEO of Nozzle AI. Rael started his career in private equity finance but quickly realised he'd rather have more fun building companies. After starting, building, and exiting companies in telecommunications and ad tech, he’s now focused on the Amazon ecosystem with London-based Nozzle.
Nozzle provides Amazon sellers with critical data to understand their customers and how to use the data to build category-defining brands. Rael is at his best when surrounded by data and people with a natural curiosity and willingness to challenge assumptions and work from first principles.
Yoni on LinkedIn - https://linkedin.com/in/yonkoz/
MultiplyMii Staffing - https://multiplymii.com
What they get into
- Customer lifetime value
- VC-backed businesses
- Building a business with no expertise
- Key lessons when starting a business
Questions Yoni asks
So I spent the first gosh, how many years?
So UCL has a really well-known computer science department, really good research, sort of world experts, like you know, Google's Deep Mind came out of that department and really, really good. But what was really interesting for me is at the time, uh my wife was running a website and look wanted to understand how to monetize it, right?
Via ads. And so I discovered the world of programmatic advertising. So that's to pretty much everyone else in in the world that is kind of display ads, right?
So this is an environment where I land on a website and behind the scenes, literally in milliseconds, there's a real-time auction happening to show you an ad, right?
You submit a bid price, and you know, Google does its thing or whoever it is, and they show you an ad. And what's interesting is when I looked into this, what goes on behind the scenes, for me at least, it drew a lot of parallels with what was going on in um finance, right?
Um and realized, I guess quite quickly that it's going to be really difficult. I Um I mean, I was just if I it's funny because if I look back at like my first pitches um to I don't know, angel investors or whatever it is, I mean, the language is just completely off, right?
You've got like three seconds to capture their attention and you're showing. And I'm like riveting. Yeah, the intersection is what we're about. So not only was the idea just really, really hard to pull off, just the actual you know, pitching communication, the whole the whole thing, right?
It's just way off. Um but um so long story short, we landed up co-founding a company that was focused on building custom algorithms for this industry. So different parts of the ecosystem, you could write custom bidding or selling algorithms, right?
From the conversation
“But I am I I love it because I can already see, I can already hear uh the all the battle scarves of like what you've gone through over this journey. And um and I think uh it really resonates with me because you know you're already prepared to share all these resources that you know would have served you two and a half, four and a half plus years ago. And that was the whole sort of idea behind successful scales is how do how do we help other entrepreneurs not um not make…”
“Yes, it's it's impossible. And that so this is just I mean, what you you're absolutely right on that. That's comparing um let's say the seller central data sets. But when you go on like the API side, which is if you're a developer, you kind of get the data, you know, programmatically and not via user interface, of course. Then there's differences between the API and what people see as a central, right? So and then our rule, our rule always is like we have to match up with Seller Central, because if people…”
“For sure, for sure. Well, listen, I want to dye I want to dive into some questions here, man. I feel like this has been immensely valuable today, but like I was just writing down so many so many questions that I had for you because you've had a really interesting career, despite you really calling it you know, sort of boring in the numbers side. I think that like in that experience and in that decision, when you think back to sort of your entrepreneurial journey, like you know was it always a burning…”
“I I've got a I I mean, I I say that we're running out of time here, which kills me because uh I feel like we could we'll have to have it around two, because I just have so many uh things that I feel like you'll just add a ton of value in here, but um you know, you've gone through this process a few times, right? And and I I sense that you've alluded to a few sort of key lessons, but you know, let's say let's say Nozzle has a hundred exit…”
“if people are interested in understanding how they can truly understand the LTV of their like we haven't even stopped to talk about just how incredible that is and how all of a sudden the you know anyone who I came from the world of you know now it's like D2C. It's like well, there was e-commerce before marketplaces were a thing. And like all this like external traffic was just like Facebook media and Google AdWords. Like they they existed before external traffic became a thing. And so you're effectively sort of thinking forward.…”
Full transcript11,777 words · speaker-labelled source
Today I sat down with Rael Cline, who is the co-founder and CEO over at Nozzle, a powerful AI that helps you understand your lifetime total customer value on Amazon and e-commerce purchases, which is something really unique and a data set that more people should be paying closer attention to. So he's a super smart guy, and we talk about what it's like to build businesses and building businesses from the people component from proof of concept and you know building an MVP to raising funds. I mean, we really go all over the place. But one of the really interesting things that Rails shares is about what it's like to build a business where you actually have no expertise in that space. And for a lot of us trying to build businesses, they have ideas that can't really materialize because you think you don't have the expertise. Well, there's ways in which you can approach it and we talk about it in this episode. I hope you get as much value out of this session as I did because this one was an absolute barn burner, at least for me. So I hope you enjoy as always.
Thanks. Welcome to Successful Scales, the show where I talk to world class professionals on what it takes to scale successful businesses. I dive deep asking questions to people who are running unicorn businesses to raising funds to buying businesses, mergers and acquisitions, IP and patent law, what is to manage performance management. I mean, the list goes on. The idea really is how do I create knowledge and learning for you guys listening in and of course myself getting the floor with people who I in many cases would never dream to share a room with. Before we jump into the episode, I've got to give a special thank you to our sponsors. Firstly, over at Global Wide Advisors, a leading digital consumer products investment bank focused on optimizing the sales process. Incredible team, always happy to pick up the phone and educate you or anyone about the sales process and what you should really consider and can obviously help take you to market or even acquire businesses. I ring them for just about everything these days. Us over at MultiplyMii, we are the end-to-end executive search and HR function into the Philippines, helping find better talent and onboarding them effectively.
And last but not least, Escala, our management consultancy, focused on process improvement, where we help build better systems for your business. That's all the ads you're gonna get from me, ladies and gentlemen. The rest is all about learning. I hope you really enjoy and get as much out of these sessions as I do sitting face to face with some of the world renowned leaders in their respective fields, asking them the tough questions that they're not often asked. All right, Raleigh mate. It is an absolute pleasure to have you here. We've been laughing, we've been laughing away before we hit record. But uh mate, thanks for coming on an episode of Successful Scales. Amazing. Thanks so much for having me. Looking forward to it. Yeah, no, I'm uh I'm I'm excited, and I feel like if nothing else, we're gonna have a fair few laughs here. Um It's all you can do sometimes as well, right? It's uh mate, it's the best. It's uh it's the best it's a it's the best thing I could ask for. So uh already, uh thank you. But um, mate, like I was saying before, I'm not gonna try and butcher your illustrious career and all the you know impressive things that we started to touch on, but I said let's save it for the show and let everyone learn a little bit about you. So, mate, let me pass it over to you.
Well, firstly, for every up there's at least one done, I can tell you that. But um anyway, so uh yeah, so I I um if you can't tell by my accent, uh, I'm South African.
So I spent the first gosh, how many years? Sort of 23 years of my life in in South Africa. Um my background is actually kind of nothing than what uh what I've been doing in the last 10 years. Um studied, actually, funnily enough, studied started off studying liberal arts, so kind of I don't know, philosophy stuff. After one year, uh changed, came over to the dark side is finance and economics. Um then started off in finance and economics jobs, right? So um sort of a management consultancy but focused on finance, so very heavy, uh quite quantitative type stuff. Um but came to the UK in 2010 to study a master's in finance. Um after that course, got out of the industry, as you do. So um, I mean, really kind of the thinking for me is um finance is great. I think it's very sort of intellectually stimulating. But companies and the world kind of exists in in in spreadsheets and slides. And from my point of view, what I wanted to I want to be on the other side, right? So I want to be on sort of the company building side and all the other challenges of um of of building businesses rather than sort of the advisory side. Um so yeah, I had an opportunity um, sorry in 2013, I um started a company called Media Gamma, and this is super niche. Um we were spin-out of the computer science departments at uh at UCL University College London here in the UK.
So UCL has a really well-known computer science department, really good research, sort of world experts, like you know, Google's Deep Mind came out of that department and really, really good. But what was really interesting for me is at the time, uh my wife was running a website and look wanted to understand how to monetize it, right? Via ads. And so I discovered the world of programmatic advertising. So that's to pretty much everyone else in in the world that is kind of display ads, right? So this is an environment where I land on a website and behind the scenes, literally in milliseconds, there's a real-time auction happening to show you an ad, right? You submit a bid price, and you know, Google does its thing or whoever it is, and they show you an ad. And what's interesting is when I looked into this, what goes on behind the scenes, for me at least, it drew a lot of parallels with what was going on in um finance, right? And finance have been doing this for kind of 20, 30 years, where you have real-time systems buying and selling things, right, via auctions. Um, and so and this is uh gonna get a little bit in the weeds, but the the original idea was to create effectively derivatives. So that is options, uh the ability to pre-book uh advertising space or have the option. Uh so for instance, if you coming up to Black Friday six months before, you can either pre-book a particular spot, or you have the option to use it if you want on the day.
And so finance has got a whole sort of history of these sort of things and how to price it. Um And basically UCL was kind of the only the research out of there was the only other place I could find looking looking into this, uh, which I thought was super super interesting. So I contacted the chair of computer science there, uh Dr. Jun Wan, um, and out of the blue, um, and we just met up and decided to try commercialize this, right? Um and realized, I guess quite quickly that it's going to be really difficult. I Um I mean, I was just if I it's funny because if I look back at like my first pitches um to I don't know, angel investors or whatever it is, I mean, the language is just completely off, right? Um I'm using all finance language, right? I'm talking about derivatives, I'm talking about puts and calls, I'm
talking scrap that I like, you know, intersecting, saying like this is the you know, the local maximum, like just horrible. That's it. I mean, that's it. That's exactly what investors are looking for, right?
You've got like three seconds to capture their attention and you're showing. And I'm like riveting. Yeah, the intersection is what we're about. So not only was the idea just really, really hard to pull off, just the actual you know, pitching communication, the whole the whole thing, right? It's just way off. Um but um so long story short, we landed up co-founding a company that was focused on building custom algorithms for this industry. So different parts of the ecosystem, you could write custom bidding or selling algorithms, right? If I'm a um an advertiser, I obviously have to make a decision of what bid to put in. Or if I'm on the other side, if I'm a publisher hosting the ad, I can set a reserve price for the auction, right? I want to maximize my revenue. Or if I'm the exchange, the intermediary in the middle, um, I want to be, you know, maximizing for liquidity, like just making sure the market's kind of you know, buying and selling stuff and all that sort of thing. So um it was really interesting that because yes, it's it's niche, but the market itself is massive. Um, I don't come from a computer science background, right? Like, yes, it's kind of a quantitative background, but you know, A building software, B sort of algorithm stuff is not not really my thing. Um, and I think there's some really you know interesting lessons around how to build teams and to what extent, to what extent do I actually need to know how to build an algorithm? If you're co-founding a business, um you would think you really, really need to know uh how to do these things, like really in the weeds. But actually, um I kind of come around to thinking this is more hindsight to be honest. Um kind of around to like the limits of that, right? Obviously, you need to hire well or find a co-founder who can pick up those pieces, and you clearly need to know the right questions to ask, um, which requires some knowledge.
And this is even if you're building a tech company and software in general, but to actually you're never gonna be relied on to even build a you know, maybe a prototype, but nothing further, um, to really do anything that's gonna be in production or anything like that, right? And so um it's more around understanding um the right questions to ask. And um, and I think I've become quite good at that over time. And many times you learn most of the time you learn the hard way, right? Like had I just asked that question two years ago, I could have avoided all these things. Yeah. But you know, this again, it comes via the hard way or it comes around uh via just knowing people and picking their brains around um how would you go about doing this, how does this work? There are a couple of good resources or blogs, I guess, that are um that could help you out around um you know, for non-technical people, um, here's how this stuff works. Um, but yeah, I mean, I'm quite comfortable now that um I don't need to go that much deeper either into the algorithm or into the software space, even if you're um you know, founding a company, I guess, in in that particular area. So we so I guess to pick it up, um how long we sort of three, four years of it. Um and we had customers uh both on the as I say on the on the sort of sell side, which is the publisher side and on the um on the on the advertiser side. Um but we kind of saw the winds of change around um the data in particular, right? And so right now everyone's kind of familiar with you know cookies and sort of the demise of cookies and all that. But the winds have changed kind of, yeah, I'd say three years ago, uh, somewhere around there, where it was definitely going in this direction, and some of the crucial data sets uh weren't gonna be available in in in the open ecosystem way.
So sure, you know, Facebook would have them, sure, Amazon would have them, Google would have them to some degree, but they're never gonna kind of give it to you to kind of customize things. Um and so long story short, we took a uh a decision to um to sell the company to one of our long-time uh customers based in New York. And um what was yeah, I mean, it's interesting for me is um, and I've I've in some ways done it again with what I'm doing now uh in the Amazon space, but when you're setting up a business, really considering what your sort of core existential dependencies are, right? Um people who built there's like Facebook, they're famous examples, I guess, of Facebook that you know you wake up one day and they change the rules and Amazon, of course, as well, right? So wake up one day, flick a switch, and you know, what does that mean for your business? And there's always that sort of inherent risk there. Um and if you're looking to build a company that is venture capital backed or um anything like that, then that's obviously a key, you know, a key thing you need you you need to um you need to address there. Um yeah, so that was kind of the um the first exit. But what we realized towards the end of that business is where did this where did this approach work really well?
And um it was very clear that um the our best customers were effectively gaming companies. So they want to show people ads, mostly on mobile, let's say, um, and someone downloads the app. But what was really interesting with them is that they were really focused on what happens after after the ad after the download, right? So they have this um approach where they're talking about, okay, after three days, how much money have they spent? After 10 days, how much money have they spent? After you know, 60 days, how much money are they spent? And using that data um really created really good outcomes if they gave us that data, which they did. And so when thinking about the next thing um to do, because kind of if you start a company, you know, and um you know it's uh it's hard not to do it again, I should say, at least for me. Um this was really interesting to me because um, you know, having the data sets of what happens after the ads is really a massive game changer. And so again, looking around the sort of ecosystem where you could apply this principle and one quickly lands on Amazon, right?
Where they've got both the advertising data sets um and they've got the transaction data sets, the orders. Um and so yeah, that's kind of the genesis of um how we started Nozzle um about two, two and a bit years ago. I realize I've just been talking and talking for a very long time. So um to stop that.
But I am I I love it because I can already see, I can already hear uh the all the battle scarves of like what you've gone through over this journey. And um and I think uh it really resonates with me because you know you're already prepared to share all these resources that you know would have served you two and a half, four and a half plus years ago. And that was the whole sort of idea behind successful scales is how do how do we help other entrepreneurs not um not make the same mistakes?
Exactly. What's in what's interesting to me though is like for some of the things, like pretty much all resources or good resources you'll read about, you know, entrepreneurship is um on hiring specifically is is if if it's not working out, you kind of need a part ways as soon as possible, right? Yeah because it's just it's so no matter how many times I read that, I still I still kind of make that mistake. And if I look back, and even though I had read this many times, um throughout you know, the hiring decisions I've made um almost always I would I knew earlier than than you know that then when I ultimately took action, right? Um I still find it very, very hard to do um to have those conversations, even though you know you should, right? So it's one thing, it's one thing giving the advice and sort of reading it and knowing you should be doing it, but often there's still inertia to actually do it.
It's um it's you know, it's not an exact science, and there's like you know, a lot of the things that you read about don't always consider the emotional impact than you is that sort of how you're wired. And if you are someone that is very much about your people, which to me it sounds like you are like I am, um, those some of those decisions are easier said than done for sure. Agreed. Agreed. So wait back to nozzle. Where are we at?
So we're at Nozzle. Um so yeah, so um credit nozzle on sort of the yeah, the looking at the I guess the data sets and um really realizing Amazon's uniquely positioned, not just because the market is like Amazon itself is kind of up into the right growing really quickly, but they've got this ecosystem of um the data sets are available both on the advertising and the retail side. And so there's kind of a unique opportunity to to make you know to make something out of that. Um also Amazon's data um is a bit of a shit show, right? Like anyone who's trying to work with it knows that it's extremely tough to work with. Um it's a very siloed organization, they're multiple on the data side, it's API kind of side.
Yeah. Um, you know, you would have um, you know, two data sets trying to do the same thing with different names, and like you know, trying to just sort through that mess is is really, really tough. Um, but if you can do it,
then obviously, you know, there's a big opportunity to to do that.
And there's and and that's like the rise of the entire industry around it is like how do we effectively both visualize and make sense of those yeah, like I'm thinking back now, you're you're really transporting me back to being an Amazon seller, and you know, you download, you download the sales report and the PPC report, and it's literally like the numbers aren't the same, the names of the different categories are different of what they're trying to measure, but you know they're the same. They're supposed to be the same number. It's insane.
It's crazy, right? Like, what is the source of truth in this stuff, right?
Yes, it's it's impossible. And that so this is just I mean, what you you're absolutely right on that. That's comparing um let's say the seller central data sets. But when you go on like the API side, which is if you're a developer, you kind of get the data, you know, programmatically and not via user interface, of course. Then there's differences between the API and what people see as a central, right? So and then our rule, our rule always is like we have to match up with Seller Central, because if people don't trust um, you know, the data they're getting from Nozzle, then you know everything else doesn't matter, right? And so what they trust is what they see central. Uh yeah, and so and so we spent a long time not you know just wrestling with these data sets, but also you know, you kind of have to um
and it's difficult to do, but you kind of have to build relationships between various teams within Amazon, right? Like trying to get hold of, let's say someone in the on the API side in the retail team. Now that is like a rare, rare, rare person, right? Like it's it's really funny. I I I don't even put it, they don't even put that title in their LinkedIn profiles because they just know what will happen. Yeah, yeah. So it's really funny when you really when you speak to them and you like look them up in LinkedIn, it's kind of like, ah, I know what you're doing, right? That's amazing. Yeah, it's um yeah, loads loads of rabbit holes.
But once you're I I feel like once you're in, like once you're in specific teams and functions inside of Amazon, like everyone's so helpful. Like, oh yeah, I know the launch manager for Japan, like let me introduce you right now, or like you know, super helpful, totally agree.
Um, although the white, as I said, like it's it's such a siloed organization, so it's sometimes very difficult for them to because what we're trying to do is effectively across silos. I mean, most people are looking to do stuff across silos, but
um, but it's specific, it's not like you know, I know a ton of tech companies that you know, uh SaaS companies that are just focused on, you know, uh repricing or just focused on you know the the media buying aspect of it. And so you know they they deal with one API, one specific token, it's all very clear cut and it's one team. So Yeah, this is definitely harder.
But but ultimately, ultimately more defendable if you can do it, right? Like it kind of builds emotes in a way to do that. For sure. Um I mean, I should say though, you know, Amazon um itself is changing a lot. They've actually invested a hell of a lot in the APIs, right? If you compare where their sort of API ecosystem was, I don't know, even when we started, right? Two, two and a half years ago versus what it is today, there's they've um invested a lot in it. There's a lot more things that you can do, so a lot more different data, let's say, but also just for developers, um, becomes I'm not gonna say much easier, I'm gonna say slightly easier. Um and you know, they're looking at at you know putting in sort of dev um you know, dev teams or or or dev kind of customer service teams and stuff like that, which which is encouraging. It's it's it's actually really interesting to me because uh and I'll say this quite a lot.
It's in in it's incredible that the same company that um started and grew AWS, Amazon Web Services, into an absolute industry leader, you know, tens of billions, like responsible for most of Amazon's profit, incredible stuff. And that's all dev first, right? I mean, that's like if you want to get started, really good documentation, really good, you know, dev relations and all that sort of stuff. And then the actual stuff, like what brings, you know, brings in the most cash, at least, maybe not profit, uh, which is you know, Amazon marketplace and all that sort of stuff is just very very, very different, right? Like the APIs, like um, all that. So it's just, you know, it's the nature of the silo of the company. On the one hand, you've got this incredible dev relations, dev first sort of approach and um something else on the other side. But anyway, it is it is improving. Um So, yeah, so so with Nozzle, um, the kind of key thing with us is um this speaks to kind of the product strategy of what we want to do. Like, you know, the seller ecosystem, insofar as like tools go, really well served around um bid management stuff, right? You want to run your adaptable and run your AI campaigns, loads of really good tools out there, um, really good operational dashboards, I should say, like things around I don't know, PLs or inventory and you know, things like that, a lot of good tools out there, and also market research and competitive stuff. So if you want organic um, you know, rankings and you want um, you know, market share and all that, again, good tools for that. But the one area where where at least we think um is lacking is actually visibility into your customers, like who's buying from you and what are their behaviors, right? And if you come, let's say from a D2C world, um, Shopify, for instance, um, this is kind of table stakes, right?
Like you need to know about your customers, customer first, um, you know, all of that sort of stuff. And this doesn't exist in the Amazon world. And so the product strategy for us, at least to begin with, is okay, let's create something super, super valuable for a subset of Amazon sellers. So it's not applicable to everyone, right? And we can go into what that is. Um, and create a wedge, right? So this is your entry in there, super valuable, um, really, really sticky, like good evangelists. Um, and then you can think about you know, branching off into other places after that. But really, to be properly differentiated, you need to create something that's valuable to a subset of um of users. So our focus is this idea of a focusing on your customers, but more specifically um metrics around customer lifetime value, uh, or kind of a plain English way of saying that it's profit per customer. Um, and well, we're a SaaS company. This is we level, you know, live and die by these metrics ourselves as a business. But um in e-com, again, this is such a key principle where if you're selling B2C, it's getting harder and harder to break even on the first purchase.
And so you kind of have to think about other strategies to do that. Amazon really doesn't have the data or tools to be able to enable you to do these sort of things. And so we measure um, let's say, you know, Yoni goes and buys product A on day one, and 60 days later, he goes and buys product B and then product A again. You know, you're effectively adding up throughout his entire journey the total profit, let's say over 12 months or two years, whatever the time frame may be. And let's say that number comes to $30 profit over 12 months. And why that is is so useful is you can use that number to kind of the other side of the coin, you can use that number to say, okay, I can afford to spend up to $30 to acquire a new customer, right? If I want to break even in those 12 months, and given the backdrop of what's happening in Amazon now, so there's multiple things that are making it really, really tough uh for sellers on Amazon. You've got um, well, they've they've increased their fees for number number one, right? The FBA fees. Uh, you've got a whole bunch of the you know aggregators coming in that's making it a lot more competitive. Um, a lot of you know, our our sellers, their competitors have been bought by aggregators, and you're thinking, gosh, how do I you know respond to that? Um CPCs are increasing a hell of a lot. And so, you know, breaking even on their first purchase is becoming increasingly difficult.
And we're saying, actually, here's the data to say um if I'm prepared to wait for two purchases or three months, um, I can afford to break even at that point. And actually, it gives me a lot more firepower on the advertising side. I can afford those increased CPCs. In fact, I can afford a hell of a lot more, double what I thought. Um, and so it's really, you know, you've got to have a you've got to have a product that lends itself to repeat purchases or a brand that lends itself to repeat purchases, obviously. And that's what I mean by um we're not we're not a tool for every seller. We're starting off, you know, in in specific categories that lend themselves to repeat purchases. So anything, obviously, sort of supplements and pair products and health and beauty and just CPG in general. Um and kind of going from there. Um so that's that's you know, that's where we are, that's where we've launched. You've got you know, a lot of a lot of sellers um using the tool. Interestingly, our go to market was um we actually started off doing this in Tableau, right? So like a data analytics before committing engineering resources, and this is another sort of interesting angle to it.
Um, when we first started off, when you first well, I mean, this is I guess general principles when you're when you're starting a new business, like ultimately ultimately startups have to become like learning machines, right? Like that's really what it is. And you've got to try stuff and be wrong as often and as fast as possible. And you know, your culture needs to reflect that. Um and the people you hire need to obviously reflect that as well. So when you when you start a business, you might have it might be out of your own pocket, you might have you know, enjoy investors or VCs, whatever it is, but in in kind of all cases, at least if in technology businesses, um, for me, that is kind of the key, the key thing there. And if something is a bad idea, you need to be able to test it. Like if something is a bad idea, the perfect creating like a very um you uh you need to be able to test this as quickly as possible, right?
Like that's kind of the main the main thing. And it's very easy to spend way too much time building a perfect test to see whether this is good or not. Um but if something's a bad idea, the perfect two week test doesn't make it a good idea. Yeah, yeah. And and if we're on to something, people will demonstrate uh put up their hands in some sort of way to learn more, despite having a crappy user experience or um the data's kind of right, but not right, but it's interesting enough to that they'll work with you to get it right. Yeah, um, or spelling errors or bad copy or watermarks, like I don't know, all that all that kind of stuff, right? Like if it's a real if it's a good idea, that stuff doesn't matter. So, you know, really trying to design your um experiments to see whether this is a good idea in such a way that it's kind of cheap, it's quick, and and it's difficult because a lot of people who um you hire are are like are are perfectionists, right? And this is really really difficult to like actually launch something that I don't know, has a spelling error and you kind of don't care because you're prioritizing speed. Yeah, so you know it's it's um it's it's it's interesting and it's a very s specific way of doing things and looking at the world and and hiring, and you know, at some point maybe this won't be applicable for the stage we're at. If you're much bigger, then you might not be able to take um you know, might not be able to take that approach. But you know, success at the end of the day is not it's not about how good your ideas are, it's about how good you are at building quick and cheap ways to test them.
It's um it I've been thinking this whole time who said it. Um Reid Hoffman from LinkedIn said if you're not embarrassed by a first version, yeah, you've launched too late.
I So yeah, so I you know I can totally appreciate the you know the notion of building on Tableau, which it probably still looked pretty cool, knowing the platform. Tableau is quite absolutely it's quite good. And we still have some customers that in some ways prefer prefer Tableau to the web app. But um so but it but yeah, it's it's a quick way to like in fact it's interesting because right in the beginning, we like our very, very first customers, when we're doing customer lifetime value, they actually don't give a shit about a dashboard. I mean, I could literally email the number to that person. Yeah, right. Totally. Totally. Right? He's like, I just want to know the number, all right. And I'm gonna set my quarterly, you know, ad budgets off the back of this number. Yeah, I don't give a shit whether you you test it to me or you know, email it to me. Just I I need the number. I I really in fact, it probably better be email it to you, right?
I don't have to think about logging into WhatsApp to me. Yeah. I mean, and that's the thing, right? Like it's it's it's so um and so if you're not you know doing that deep customer development and like really zeroing in on like what it is when they want it,
people really just don't give a shit. Like really like spending time doing fancy dashboards when people just want a number in an email. What a colossal waste of time.
I'm just I'm specializing like this huge dashboard that literally like the the number is like a countdown and then just get the one number like it. Yeah.
So so in the beginning, we you know, we totally overdid it, right? And it's like, well, there's like seven things here, and you hover over and it doesn't matter, and the guy's like, don't give a shit, just email it to me.
Thank you. So that's what I mean, right? Like I speak about all these, you know, grand ideas about testing things cheaply and whatever.
Again, this is hindsight, right? This is like you learn the hard way. You you kind of you know, do these things for like a month and then realize I could have just emailed emailed it.
I mean, yeah, but there's like a whole, like there's different layers as well. We're going through an experience right now. So we brought on a chief product officer, and she's got a team of you know, business analysts and UX researchers, and we're going through like initially just a full customer journey mapping of what it looks like from an experiential perspective from us, and how can we improve both on the so for us supply and demand is multiplier, the talent that we identify and the demand side clients. So, you know, this is like a two-month deep dive project, like interviewing clients and you know, also internal has been a lot of work. So there's definitely I think I think to your point, like yeah, fail, you know, make lots of mistakes early on, but like as you guys continue to evolve, you're like, okay, well, we're we're identifying product market set. Like there is now a time where let's actually double down and build something that has real surveying power.
Yeah, yeah. Because once you want to, you know, commit um engineering resources to it, then you know it's a totally different thing. I mean, of course, the engineering is is flexible and all that, but it's um yeah, it's uh uh sort of cash flow-wise and whatever, obviously a really big commitment. And um, you know, we've brought in venture capital as well. So this is a really big decision of what you know, ultimately, again, what sort of business do you want to build here? Um, is it something that is uh you think has you know really big potential and you need the venture capital in the first place to do it because it's a technology company and requires a whole lot of upfront investment in in the technology. Um And you make that back over time, or is it something that um yeah, FastFeed isn't um a VC type proposition? Um and it's not it's not saying one's better than the other, it's just what sort of business do you want to build and and what does it require? What sort of funding or funding partners does it require Yeah.
and and like heaps of pros and cons from from both aspects. Like I said, so I'm sitting I'm sitting on the other end of the table here, where we're bootstrapped. And so we've built a couple of companies here and we're building technology on the background. But yeah, like does it inhibit our ability to absolutely push forward and like spend wildly on marketing efforts and you know, bulking up the team to you know a thousand people, yeah, for sure. There's definitely limitations, but also it's a service business. So again, different decisions again.
Yeah, and different different economics at the back of it, right? Like if um, you know, venture capital typically doesn't back service-based businesses, it just doesn't, you know, sort of make sense. Um I mean, ultimately they want something where in terms of scaling, you know, the the cost to serve uh an additional customer kind of approaches zero or very, very high. And if service-based businesses obviously don't follow that. So you just carry on hiring people to serve us. So yeah, um, really, one is not better than the other, it's just um depending on what kind of you know, it's a good fit for sure, for sure.
And and and let's be real specific. Venture capital doesn't back service businesses because the multiples aren't 15, 25, 50, 100 X, right? And that's 100%.
And so that's uh that's the thing. That's that's also interesting, right? So like if you want to talk about that process, happy to do that as well. But you kind of when if you make a decision and say, like, okay, this is the sort of company I want to build, VC money um would be a good fit for that, then you kind of need to work backwards and say, how does the what is the economics of the venture capital fund actually look like, right? Like they raise you know, a certain amount of money, whatever it is, 100 million, or these days it's a few billions, but anyway, they stick with 100 million. Yeah. Um And they need to show a return to you know their their limited partners, the people to give them the money. So um, you know, they have to get whatever it is, a 10x return, but they also know that let's say I invest in 30 companies, you know, it's really sort of three or four of those companies that are gonna make those returns, the entire fund, right? It's kind of a log distribution like that.
And so I think it's one in one in five is like the the average of going rate.
Yeah, I think that's well, I think one in five is actually pretty pretty high. I mean, you you're doing well if it's one in five. But um, but yeah, so there's the expectation that you know a certain number of a large proportion of them are gonna uh shut down. Some of them might um, you know, just sort of you get your money back kind of thing, and then obviously they're gonna be ones that need shoot the lights out and they need to make up all the other ones as well and give the returns. Um and so that's you know a very different approach as an investor. Um, you know, if you're you know, you raise money and let's say you've got I don't know, 12 months or 18 months or two years to kind of prove something out. Um when you come back for that next round, you you know, these are the questions they're gonna be asking themselves. Is this gonna be the company that's gonna make the whole fund sort of thing? Right. And they uh generally they reserve, I don't know, a third or half of their money raised for follow-ins, right?
To carry on investing in in in the winners, so to speak. Yeah. And so yeah, it's really, really rough, right? Like that's the world you're playing in, and there's no that's a game. And if you're going to take venture capital money, that is what you're signing up to do. And it's pretty brutal. And um, but that's that that's what it is. But on the other hand, of course, you get you do get the money. I mean, in many ways as well, um you know, have having a lot of money is is is a bad thing as well, right? It means it can multiply all the bad things you're doing in the company. Yeah, right. Yeah, you haven't proven stuff out, and now let's just spend a ton of money on marketing. And you know, that's that's not the best way to acquire customers sort of thing, at least not in the beginning. And so, you know, you it uh yeah, it's it's it's a complicated decision, but um, you know, those are those are definitely some some of the pros and cons.
For sure, for sure. Well, listen, I want to dye I want to dive into some questions here, man. I feel like this has been immensely valuable today, but like I was just writing down so many so many questions that I had for you because you've had a really interesting career, despite you really calling it you know, sort of boring in the numbers side. I think that like in that experience and in that decision, when you think back to sort of your entrepreneurial journey, like you know was it always a burning desire to be an entrepreneur and to be starting your own things. Did you like what was the if you if you should sort of take me back to there? What was the decision to go and study something if you always had an entrepreneurial journey? I'm making an assumption here, so I may be wrong. Yeah, maybe you caught that bug, but just curious as the sort of the considerations and a thought process for someone who might be trying to navigate their way through.
Yeah, absolutely. So I mean, for me, my father um sort of struck out on his own when when I was very young, frankly, right? Like, and so that's a super brave thing to do. He's a financial advisor, uh setting life insurance at the time, worked for like a big corporate, kind of struck out that and and is done really well. And so, you know, his entreprene uh entrepreneurial journey was always shared with me from a very, very young age, where sitting on the dinner table and he'll tell me about some of the stuff and challenges that he's you know that's going on and um some of the nuances of all these sort of things. Um and so that that was always really, really um interesting to me. Like, I mean, he's not you know, the young kid is not gonna share like some of the really bad stories or stuff that might impact the family on the ups and downs of the uh of the entrepreneurial journey, right? Um but but still just some of the challenges around uh dealing with people or clients or um even some moral dilemmas, frankly, like when I got a little bit older, you know, all that kind of stuff. Um and so yeah, that that was um sort of encoded within me um, you know, at quite a young age. Um in my teens, I was you know, this is kind of 90s, I guess, in South Africa. So um e e-com was kind of doing a thing, but not not not too much. Um, but I was you know, doing I don't know, uh sort of things on the side and um doing sports betting in school and all that type of stuff.
Yep, yeah. Uh well we aren't learned, yeah, let learnt the principles of of liquidity quite early on. Um uh competing with a tuck shop for you know, touch up people's food for would you well would you rather have you know those Crips and Crisps in a hamburger or uh or place a bet on Man United this weekend for my It's more valuable to do.
Uh so um, but yeah, I mean, I think also what was really interesting is is the idea of like um I mean I I don't I don't mean this really earnestly, but something like rules or guidelines sort of approach, um, you know, and and like bad rules in particular, it's uh, you know, and it's just you know so so my father used to come across this quite a lot within um the financial services industry and you know it's obviously heavy regulated and all that, but um you know, just some of the way corporates would behave around certain rules that just don't make sense and that this is uh you'd be viewed things as a guideline more than a more than a rule. Um and so that again that kind of DNA uh really really stuck with me as well. And I think that's again well suited to being entrepreneurs. Um whether um, yeah, it's the whole sort of permission versus forgiveness kind of thing in some cases, right? Um so there's that. But I think um the core attributes really for me um around curiosity and determination, right?
And I think those two things, uh particularly from him, um really really demonstrated and installed in me. So, you know, like that's um so I I did start off um I mean, I I I never really considered not going to university. I was never gonna just sort of drop out and um I don't know, start a business and all that. Um But, and you know, I don't think I would have lost it in the corporate for that long. Um yeah, again, it's just it's just um yeah again, p personality thing and and and all of that. So I did I did sort of jobs as a in finance and private equity and all that kind of thing. But uh, you know, ultimately on the company building side it was always far far more interesting to be the sort of intellectual and emotional challenges and everything else going on. So yeah, that's what was kind of um when did I I I don't know if there was a moment um when I was growing up and I was like I can't be anything else but an entrepreneur kind of thing. But but uh but the the sort of values and um personality types and all that sort of stuff, absolutely from a very very young age, primarily to my father, I guess, around around doing that. And and also just encouraging me to um, you know, when you when you're younger, you have like you you try like 10 different hobbies and stuff, right? Like I was it was gonna come back to bite me, I guess. But um uh like I you know, I would be doing like magic, right?
Like pretty random. It's uh that's really setting. That's a hundred percent gonna come back to buy you.
Yeah, I know, right? So I I went for like I went for like magic lessons, right?
I mean, because I was interested. I was just you may there's no way when we when we eventually meet in the flesh, you're not pulling out a magic trick or two.
So uh so yeah, so you know, but they're always encouraging of like piquing my curiosity, right? And not and not and not shutting it down and saying, like, okay, that's ridiculous.
Like we know you've gonna last like two months. Um and so again, it's just that curiosity component, right? That I always have and that my
uh parents always kind of fostered that that you know, I think is is is great. So now that I've got a you know, three year old in a 10 week old, I mean, that's exactly the sort of you know approach I'll be taking with them, even if it's magic.
I love it. I love it, and congratulations on the 10 week old. Thank you, thank you. Uh um so so you you touched on something um that really caught my attention early on and um something that I think is really valuable or timely for me, it's something that I um I feel like I hope if anything imprints on people listening to anything that I say, it's that for a lot of Amazon sellers out there, they need to really be thinking if they're gonna compete tomorrow and the next day and they're gonna get to a point where they understand what their LTV is using nozzle and actually sort of build toward that future plan, they have to graduate from being Amazon store owners to business owners and and running real ops and having real sort of vision and drive and direction. And so, you know, while a lot of people sort of magically found their way into the Amazon space and they had, you know, a lot of the great entrepreneurs who had a great product idea built into a brand idea, or if they were really smart, built a great brand with the idea of what the product sets and the sort of trajectory look like as they look to build new products. Um you talked about the fact that this is a really longer winded way of saying like you talked about a fact that you built businesses where you had no real expertise in them and you talked a little bit about your true passion as I understood it is is building businesses.
And so for I mean, I'd love just you to talk a little bit about what you wanted to to talk about before is building a business in a space where you have no expertise, like how how do you approach that? Yeah.
Yeah. Um f first and foremost, uh it still comes down to those core attributes, curiosity and determination, right? Like that that is just the most potent kind of combination where um if you're if applied properly, um you can do you can do a lot of things. Um secondly, you need to surround yourself with the right people. That's absolutely, you know, you you've got to be a sponge, you've got to um surround yourself with domain expertise or um other people build companies, good you know, uh big companies, small companies, failed companies, all that sort of stuff, and just taking like an honest assessment of um, you know what what current skills you currently have, what do you need, what and more importantly, not more importantly, equally important, what you don't need, right? Because you can waste a lot of time becoming like okay at something, but that's just a waste of time, right? Um Amen. so yeah, exactly. So for me, um being able to read API documentation is like entry level stuff. Like you have to so if you're gonna build uh you know a software based company, particularly off the back of another company, i.e. Amazon, you need to understand what's possible.
Like what beta do I get and what format is in that kind of thing. And so I I mean I actually remember the the the moment quite clearly, which is quite rare for me. I have a shocking memory, but um I was in a coffee shop on a I was in a coffee shop on the weekend where I discovered um the Amazon API, the MWS API. I was like, this is this is crazy. And then so I I look into the you know the API documentation and I see what data is actually available, and then your mind starts to think like, oh my goodness, if I had this data, um I could do all these these these sorts of things. That's brilliant. Um and so again, that's kind of the the curiosity to do that and then the determination to like really go deep into these data sets and ask an actual engineer who knows what you know he or she's doing, um, is am I interpreting this correctly to validate that hey, this is technically possible, let's go, you know, let's go sort of try this out kind of thing. So um yeah, I I'd say um those are the attributes. And then secondly, um you as I say, you need to surround yourself with the right people and and it's not that I and I'm not talking necessarily like writing the beginning, it's not really about I have to hire this person, is this person a co-founder or whatever? Because if people when you talk to people and they're excited because they think you're onto something, they'll just meet with you for coffee anyway, right? And and like share stuff or you know, whatever it is, and you can kind of see where that goes. It's not always about trying to convince people like, hey, join join my you know, my company.
One but one hundred I mean, that really resonates. I have like standing phone calls with like in like you know, fellow industry colleagues regular just because like yeah, I want to hear what they're up to, how can I help? And they're they feel the same way. And so you just end up you don't know if you end up working together or it's just effectively like a friend in the space.
But yeah, some of them might become advisors, some of them might become investors and advisors. I mean, you you don't know, but if you'll if you're if if you think you're you know, if they think your idea is good or they're like you as a person, they're like, Okay, it's actually quite rare that your first idea is actually what you'll end up doing, right? You change you change like four or five times. It's just that's that's how it goes, right? But they can see that, hey, I like the way this person thinks and I like this person. Um yeah, I mean, that's that's that's the way to do that. So you know, really not being shy about trying to um embed yourself in the ecosystem, whether that's meetups or I don't know, masterminds or whatever it is. Um, and then just on the company building side, yeah. I mean, people who've um you know I've said successful and unsuccessful businesses. Um, and I think you just gotta um absorb all of that sort of stuff and read as much as you can voraciously. Um that's another that's another really really good way to do that. But I think it kind of comes back to like what don't I need to know?
Like that's a much harder question, right? Because very easy to say I need to know these 20 things, and then before you know there's 40 things, and you know, all that kind of stuff.
So, how would you how would you define your your skill sets? Like if you have to look at yourself as I'm a generalist, right?
Like I'm absolutely a generalist. And uh generalists are more valuable than specialists right in the beginning. For sure. Like someone who's yeah, someone, especially in sort of the you know the the startup environment, if you've if you can do one thing like world class at one particular thing, well, it could be that in two weeks that we're not doing that thing anymore. Yeah, that's just the way it goes, right? Um so um, yeah, so I think the um kind of fig what I'm good at, yeah. Um, and it's also funny because you you'll read a whole a whole bunch of like literature ask people on like what what what is the role of this of a founder?
And you know, again CEO, CEO and founder are the two dumbest titles.
I mean, it's everything from yeah, your number one job is to not run out of money, right? If you've yeah, your number one job is to hire well. Uh your number one job is to find product market fit. It's like actually you have like 10 number one jobs that that you're meant to be doing, right? So in many ways it's actually not not that helpful because everything is just the most important thing. Um so I would say and and and also depending on your time pressure, because it's like, hey, I've got six months left, I don't know, that I can fund this thing. Um yeah, what's number one in that case? But um, I mean, if you're talking sort of medium to long term, then the team size is is generally the most important thing, right? And the hardest thing, right? It's the one that people get cons and myself included to get consistently wrong. If someone thinks they're consistently brilliant at hiring people, I would be quite skeptical because I just think it's the hard toughest thing to do, right? You can implement whatever processes you want and you know, all that kind of stuff, but um it's it's extremely extremely difficult to do. But ultimately, you're looking for people with complimentary skill sets, obviously, right? And and if particularly when people want to invest in that they're really investing in an individual. If you're a first-time entrepreneur, very difficult to as one individual uh to find you know uh venture capital funding, they're typically investing in teams.
Um and sure, if you are have a uh you know, you've built three successful businesses, you're not gonna have a problem, they'll just invest in you as a person. But if it's first time, it's a different story. For sure. Um and um and it's complimentary skills, right? Like I, you know, I as I said, I I'm not at least my background is not that technical, but if you hire a technical person, um then figuring out where you know where their trust is between, okay, I need to ask these questions, but I trust the answers from from a co-founder or from an engineer or whatever it is. Um that that's hard to do. Um and I think only time can solve that, right? It's very hard to be like, there's a few interview questions, okay, like I know this person, you know, and and also what's interesting to me is like if you don't come from that background, um, how do you know what what good looks like? Like, how do you know what if someone's a good industry? Like it's very easy for them to you know convince that someone's good or got a lot of experience. And so you kind of need to reach out to um a CTO, right?
Uh a chief technical uh technology officer, um, let's say of like a really big business. And it's hard to do, right? It's really hard to do that. But getting that person to also speak with that person to validate, um, then you know what good looks like. Because there have been a lot of times for me where you know, for instance, you work with somebody and they're like, okay, they're great, but actually someone else comes along a lot later and you're like, okay, now now I know what actually what brilliant looks like, or you know, that kind of thing. Yeah. So you know, that expectation setting um and trying to shortcut that process via super experienced people who've done it, uh, you know, and I think um, yeah, I think is really important. It's really, really hard to do, but it's such an important thing, particularly right at the beginning, beginning of the country, that's the company, right?
I I've got a I I mean, I I say that we're running out of time here, which kills me because uh I feel like we could we'll have to have it around two, because I just have so many uh things that I feel like you'll just add a ton of value in here, but um you know, you've gone through this process a few times, right? And and I I sense that you've alluded to a few sort of key lessons, but you know, let's say let's say Nozzle has a hundred exit next year, whatever, and it's all sunshine rainbows, and you realize, well, I'm already bored and I want to do something, I want to build my next business. What are some of the key lessons that you'd take or like what is starting a business? Because I think back to what it was starting a bootstrap business two or so years ago versus to the fact that I will never ever do that again in my lifetime. It's like you couldn't, I I don't know how much it would cost, but it would
have to be a shitload of money for me to even consider doing what I did again. Like we have we have infrastructure now, right? You know, and uh and I know what that feels like. And I'm not a generalist trying to do everything. And so, like, what are the what what would what advice would you give someone? And you know, you can assume that they have money or they don't have money, like I I would say, you know, use whatever advice you would give at both stages, let's say, yeah, uh, or the stage that you would go down. Um what what have you learned and what would you change? Um, yeah, I mean, I I I think um really thinking deeply around what sort of business you want to be build building in the first place, right? Like it's it's as I said, it's very rare that the first thing that you build ends up being actually what what you build and scale with, right? Um, but the general direction, um, I think you'd be very clear, and also just from a sort of company DNA point of view, right? Culture point of view, your vision point of view, what sort of people you want to hire point of view. Um that sort of clarity, I think is is always going to be um one of the most important things. It affects how you yeah, I mean, it affects who you hire, it affects all that sort of stuff. But also it affects around who you want as your funding partners if you decide to go down this sort of external funding route. Um, you know, do you is the sort of company gonna be a good fit for, you know, is the market big enough?
Is it growing quickly enough? Uh, you know, all those sort of checks as well, um, if you want if you if you want to take VC money. So really thinking in the beginning quite deeply around uh around that. And I said one's not better than the other, it's just different different routes and different outcomes depending on what you want. Um I think as well, what's what's also been quite difficult uh for me is um you know, determine I keep saying that determination is one of the most important things, but actually how long do you carry on doing the same thing if it's not working? Right. So um, and you actually need to change the way you do it. You need a pivot or I don't know, there's there's something else that that that's you need to need to do. And so it's all very well being determined, but there's also a point where you're just hitting your head against the wall over and over again, right? And saying, So determined is not necessarily doing the same thing over and over. Like you okay, you you're tweaking something and seeing if it works. I'm not saying you're just doing the same thing over and over again. But at what point do you actually step back and say, actually, the approach is different?
I mean you just completely change track here. Um that is still very determined, right? It's still um, you know, persistent death generally, you you you're headed in the right direction. Uh it's not determined in in the sense of like I'm just fixated on derivatives, for instance, in media camera.
Yeah, and then just hitting my head against wall on that. So I actually read something really interesting yesterday. Um, it's called uh decision journal, where um what you can do is you actually write down um your what you believe to be true, your prediction, and then you set a review date. So, you know, yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, really putting down the logic as to what's my thesis in market, what's the decision I'm making today, and then you know, set a fine time, six months, twelve months down the track and say, is it true? Okay, maybe it's time to reassess or so.
That's super interesting, like a much uh smaller version I should say of that is you know, I was talking about how we consistently run experiments in the in the company, like pretty cheap, small um things to do. Before anyone actually does any of these things, that there's actually an hypothesis document that someone has to fill out. So basically we'll say, we believe, and then you fill it in, right? We believe uh, I don't know, mobile traffic is gonna result in better, you know, higher lifetime value customers or whatever it is. Um then you're gonna say, we're successful if, right? What is the actual success criteria? Um if we're successful, what are you actually going to do about it, right? Okay, we're gonna shift budgets, we're gonna do this, we're gonna do that. Um, and then you know, some details on on on how you're gonna test it, um, around I don't know, here's the creative or uh or the budget or whatever it is. But it's such a it's a very, very formal process around uh building up the cumulative knowledge of the business, ultimately, because you're gonna have you know, people people join the business who's gonna have similar ideas, and you're like, well, here's a here the experiments, you know, a hundred experiments we've been doing over the last I don't know, six months or whatever it is. Um and here's the cumulative that for me is the IP of the company, right? Like the technology is one piece of it, sure. But actually, that body of knowledge um sitting in those experiments around what's working, what isn't working, how we've tested it, and trying to get that sort of across everybody. That for me is like the the real IP of the company.
Hey, that is brilliant advice, and you know, that's gonna help a ton of people. And I would love to sit here and record for the next hour with uh just I
think uh I feel like we're just getting started, so we'll definitely do a part two. If I didn't have a call to get to in a second, I would have definitely uh kept running with this. But but before I let you go today,
if people are interested in understanding how they can truly understand the LTV of their like we haven't even stopped to talk about just how incredible that is and how all of a sudden the you know anyone who I came from the world of you know now it's like D2C. It's like well, there was e-commerce before marketplaces were a thing. And like all this like external traffic was just like Facebook media and Google AdWords. Like they they existed before external traffic became a thing. And so you're effectively sort of thinking forward. I I I'm looking at it almost as like a real-time live Nielsen type experience where I have like the real, I mean, you know, to to a a version or a level. Um but yeah, anyway. I'm I'm excited as to see how far you guys push. If anyone wants to get involved and try nozzle, how does it work?
Uh yeah, I mean you can uh go to nozzle.ai, n o double z dotai. Uh you can start a 14-day trial. Um, but you know, equally just reach out to me on on LinkedIn. It's probably the or email uh rail.client at nozzle.ai. Um and I um I might just do a magic trick on the call as well.
Um I'm I'm definitely reaching out then.
Railway, I should say. was It was uh awesome having you, mate. Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day. And uh mate, thank you. Thank you so much for having me. That's great. Cool.
Episode details
- Series
- Successful Scales
- Host
- Yoni Kozminski
- Episode
- 66
- Published
- December 15, 2021
- Transcript
- 11,777 words