In this episode
Our guest today is Brian Harwitt, a partner at CoVenture, focusing on credit opportunities into tech-enabled businesses. Recently, he has led the firm's strategy in the Amazon third-party seller aggregator ecosystem, partnering with 5+ companies in the process.
7:11 Providing financial services to businesses
12:58 What's good investment for CoVenture
30:01 Vetting process & advice on building a company you can sell
Questions Yoni asks
Or did that play into you guys all coming together?
Unreal, uh unreal. So, you know, I I always like to ask that question because I think so much of everything that you achieve is it's always about the people, right?
So I want to hear some of your predictions on sort of a shift in the market over the coming years. I've got a few of my own. But uh in taking all of that, I mean, how many?
I don't know if you can disclose, I feel like you probably could, um, but how many aggregators have you you backed to date?
What are you what are you asking from them?
Like what does uh what does a good investment look like in your eyes?
Yeah, super unique, super valuable, and just uh a ton of insights there. So just to dig a little deeper there, like once you once you invest in these businesses and you know, you've backed that as a potential winning horse. Um what does the the ongoing relationship look like?
You know, is it just we're handing you over the funds, we're making sure that things are going to plan?
From the conversation
“It's any, you know, I don't have a crystal ball or anything, but what I'm seeing is I think the continued professionalization of Amazon as a platform. And I think that's the natural thing that happens as you have more and more statistic aggregators rolling up these different businesses. And so you're just going to see this become highly professional in the same way Airbnb did. So I mean, we probably five years ago when you go to say an Airbnb, it would be someone with an extra room and you could go stay there.…”
“Yeah. Uh it is it can definitely be overwhelming. And the best way to get to us through warm intro. So if someone knows us who we like and we trust, and you know that person, you can see and then they can connect us, right? I think that's the easiest way because then it's vetted through a source. Uh, if you're coming in through my email and I've never met you before, it's harder for me to verify that you know it's a real opportunity and we're already taking 40 meetings a week, and…”
“Like how can you build real durable notes? Some of that's through the ratings and review modes with things along those lines. Um the second thing and relating to that is like don't become overly reliant on PTC spend. Because like if you have to, if you take your foot off the pedal, then all of a sudden your top line is gonna is gonna sink. And that makes it harder for people to want to invest in the business, even if your EVITA margin is improving as you lower your PTC spend. I think…”
“Yeah, yeah. I mean, you you gotta be careful because in they've made examples of a lot of sellers that are sort of based out of China. I mean, we saw that uh huge, huge quantities of sellers that were large sellers um taken down for for TOS violations. And I think they'll continue to make examples of people who do not follow uh TOS or blatantly violating and have multiple violations. So I think that's something that just sort of across the board. And in one other point that I think is worth bringing…”
“I think there were three of us that were doing it out of the gate that have all been sort of in this technology world before. And now we're starting to see really large financial institutions, you know, the Black Rocks, Blackstone, the polos of the world that have been in the asset, you know, alternative business for a long time, uh, starting to participate. And so I think that's sort of the next wave. And then once that's gone, I think you'll start to see uh the banks coming in because we'll see this…”
Full transcript10,222 words · speaker-labelled source
Today I sat down with Brian Harwitt, one of the partners at CoVenture, a venture capital firm who are investing in many things inside of the ecosystem that is e-commerce, namely aggregators. We had a conversation about aggregators and what a 10,000 foot view looks like given that he has unique access, sitting on and listening to many of these founders talk about their businesses and their strategies. Like always, I hope you enjoy this one. For me, it was really cool to get to peer into the lens of what it looks like inside of an aggregator. Welcome to Successful Scales, the show where I talk to world-class professionals on what it takes to scale successful businesses. I dive deep asking questions to people who are running unicorn businesses, to raising funds, to buying businesses, mergers and acquisitions, IP and patent law, what is to manage performance management. I mean, the list goes on. The idea really is how do I create knowledge and learning for you guys listening in and of course myself, getting the floor with people who I, in many cases, would never dream to share a room with. Before we jump into the episode, I've got to give a special thank you to our sponsors. Firstly, over at Global Wide Advisors, a leading digital consumer products investment bank focused on optimizing the sales process. Incredible team, always happy to pick up the phone and educate you or anyone about the sales process and what you should really consider and can obviously help take you to market or even acquire businesses. I ring them for just about everything these days. Us over at MultiplyMii, we are the end-to-end executive search and HR function into the Philippines, helping find better talent and onboarding them effectively. And last but not least, Escala, our management consultancy focused on process improvement, where we help build better systems for your business.
That's all the ads you're going to get from me, ladies and gentlemen. The rest is all about learning. I hope you really enjoy and get as much out of these sessions as I do sitting face to face with some of the world-renowned leaders in their respective fields, asking them the tough questions that they're not often asked. Brian, welcome to an episode of Successful Scales. It's an absolute honor to have you here today, mate. How are you doing? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me. Yeah, mate. I've been really excited about this. And you know, I sort of made it known when we were sitting together in New York a couple of weeks ago that to get your perspective and your insight into so many budding and existing entrepreneurs who are growing businesses really well. Um, it's just going to give a whole different layer. And you know, before we jump into all of that, I love it. For me, Dr. Butcher, your background and for you to actually tell the listeners who you are and you know, obviously a little bit about Co-Venture would be fantastic.
Yeah. Uh yeah, thanks again for having me on. So Brian Harwood, I'm a partner here at CoVenture. I've been working here uh for about a little over five years. Um before that, I was doing investment banking at uh investment called Guggenheim. Uh and like many of the people at Co-Venture, I went to Cornell. Uh, so so and originally from LA. Uh now for Co-Venture, you know, we are an uh asset management firm that we like to think of as through the intersection of uh finance and technology. So we have a venture capital business called CrossFeam that's invested in a handful of these Amazon third-party solar rollups. Uh, and then we have, you know, Co-Venture, which has our private credit arm, which is where I sit. And so we're providing credit facilities to uh, you know, specially finance like fintech paper businesses, as well as companies that are rolling up or acquiring other sorts of businesses. So the Amazon third-party seller thesis fit squarely in there. It's like, where are you finding businesses that are built on new age technologies, new age platforms that do not have access to traditional financial services because they don't fully recognize these are small businesses, the way they do pizzeria's and corner stores and things along those lines. So that's where we where we really thrive and where we really got excited about this Amazon third-party seller thesis.
Mate, very, very uh modest and very quick background into all that you do. I'm totally going to take the opportunity to start digging in deeper. Um, Let's do it. so I mean, just just uh back to CoVenture for a second. You said that you know you came from a finance background, you uh, you know, you were working in investment banking, and you said a lot of guys work from Cornell. How did how did it all come to be and how significant was the Cornell Connect? Uh, you know, how significant was that? Or did that play into you guys all coming together?
Yeah, so it was uh for Ali and I was everything. So Ali and I, at least the founder and managing partner of Co-Venture. Uh, Kia and I met when I was a sophomore in college at Cornell. Um, I was going out for a business organization called DSP that we were part of. And um, he and I quickly hit it off. I just spent a summer in China firm, firm. And he thought that was really interesting. And so we started chatting. And pretty soon after he was starting Co-Venture, getting it off the ground after doing some other uh tech focused work in his first couple of years at Cornell. And as he was getting it launched, he said, Hey, I want to bring someone on as an intern, someone who can help uh do free work essentially. And so I raised my hand. And for about two and a half years in college, I was providing Ollie with all sorts of free work, whether it was like market research reports that we were publishing and giving to other VCs, uh, helping on portfolio support, deal sourcing, sort of you name it. Uh, and so for about two and a half years of doing that, uh, but decided I wanted to get sort of the hard skill set in investment banking. And then uh, you know, six or eight months into my my job in investment banking, Ali called me up and he's like, Hey, I'm I'm getting this credit fund rolling, uh, and there's no one else I'd want to hire than you. So uh, you know, decided that I wanted to hitch my wagon to Ollie because he's you know incredibly hardworking, incredibly smart, and it was going to be uh knew it would be an awesome ride to work on side of him and definitely uh still feel great about that decision today. He's been uh a great mentor uh in person to work with.
Unreal, uh unreal. So, you know, I I always like to ask that question because I think so much of everything that you achieve is it's always about the people, right? I mean, we can talk about scaling businesses and we can go on and on about that, but um at the end of the day, there's a human and a human interaction and connection. And so it's always very interesting to see how people got their start and how you know they've sort of come together. Uh, I don't know if I ever told you, but Lippy and I, we actually met playing Australian rules football. Oh, we did tell you, we did tell you the story. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.
You explained to me what it was, and I was like, this is an amazing sport, and why is it not here?
Yeah, yeah, yeah. AD is really an amazing sport. And it's a shame because I just think about the American athletes, it would just be a on a different level. Um, but super, super interesting. So you you jumped over a few things, and just so that everyone listening at home is um board or understand. So I'd love to hear firstly, you touched on a little bit around how it's hard for businesses that aren't brick and mortar to actually you know find financial aid or ways in which they can actually uh lend money. So I'd love you to sort of talk a little bit about what that is for people who don't have that visibility and also like what was the thesis coming in?
Yeah, I mean, this and this is something that we had been observing across many different ecosystems prior to uh just being on the Amazon ecosystem. So for the the first exposure to this was Uber drivers. So there was there used to be a timing mismatch in which you would earn your rides and then what you get paid by Uber. And so you had your gas bills, your toll rows, all these things that were adding up, but you were having 14-day payment cycles. And so um there was a company called ClearBank called Clearco that started factoring these Uber receivables. And we started paying attention. We said, All right, this is really interesting because no one's providing or viewing Uber drivers of small businesses when in fact they are small businesses. And the extension then went to Airbnb hosts, um, and those were became sort of small business owners in themselves, as well as e-commerce merchants. And so this extension along those lines of how do you provide financial services to businesses that are built off tech platforms. And I think those were new things that banks and traditional financial services didn't really have a grasp around. And so FinTech and specialty finance businesses came in to actually provide that infrastructure and support. So that was sort of where we began in the thesis.
And then after that, we saw the same thing happening in the creator economy. So whether it was um digital music uh streamers sort of on STEM on Spotify or any of these other platforms, and that's a company called STEM that we work with, um, as well as on the YouTube platform. You know, many YouTubers are making millions, you know, seven, eight figures a year on YouTube, but can't get access to traditional financial services. And so they're not being able to grow their businesses and relying on just cash flow um to reinvest in their businesses, and so finding companies that are helping providing financial services to those creators as well, who are, you know, in some senses much better credit risks and much more profitable than traditional small businesses. And so then, you know, after that, it became Amazon third-party sellers. And so we had spent some time actually in probably 2017 looking in that ecosystem through a couple different lenses, mostly through the lens of how do you provide financing more so than acquis uh acquisition to these third-party sellers. Um a lot of it was speeding up the AR cycle from Amazon to these sellers, they could you know can convert their working capital. Uh, and then as the time went on, we saw, all right, well, there's massing more and more of these businesses. And there became a really interesting opportunity to acquire them, roll them up.
And we saw that initially with Frazio. Um, and then obviously, as many of these other companies came along, uh, we started to get more and more excited that it wasn't just one player, that there were many players, and we began to appreciate how really large this market was, where it wasn't just gonna be one winner, that there could be, you know, five, 10, 20 billion dollar businesses built on the back of this ecosystem.
Yeah, super, super fascinating. And I I think what I really like about sort of the thesis or sort of the viewpoint is that you studied other markets that experience these trends early on, and you've replicated the model in something now that you know is really proving out to be, I mean, you know, we talk about Thracio, 3.4 billion raise, and that's the first mover, you know, that they definitely get the first mover advantage. But you know, there are some other very serious players, and serious players that you guys back as well. Um, you know, that that there's a lot of opportunity that's happening here. So, you know, just to sort of set the stage here uh a little further. So you guys are investing in the aggregators or a bunch of aggregators as well as you know, Clearco, ClearBank, and you know, everything that is helping finance, you know, a lot of these incredible entrepreneurs who've had and built great businesses and great brands that exist inside of this three pay, third party um seller platform marketplace that is Amazon and you know, and and beyond now. And I think you know, I'll save it for the end.
So I want to hear some of your predictions on sort of a shift in the market over the coming years. I've got a few of my own. But uh in taking all of that, I mean, how many? I don't know if you can disclose, I feel like you probably could, um, but how many aggregators have you you backed to date?
Yeah, so on the credit side of the business where I sit, uh, it's five. And then on the uh equity side of the business, there's uh a handful more that cover geography is that on the credit side, we just we don't work in yet.
So I guess my the real point there is that it's not one, it's multiple. And you know, we're talking about plus minus a hundred aggregators. So we're looking at, I think uh, you know, about five to ten percent here. Uh, you know, you're you're touching them in some way, shape, or form, which is you know, no small feat here. Um, you know, that shows a whole lot of confidence in it. And so just to take one step back and you know, for anyone who hasn't been paying attention in the space here, you know, there's been accounted for north of you can look at marketplace pulse uh acquirers. I think it's north of 12 billion now, has been invested in in venture and debt. And the objective really is how do we acquire as many of these businesses, these three piece seller businesses and roll them up into something that you know uh financially makes sense. And it's you know, not to discredit it uh in terms of what they're doing, but it's like a bit of financial arbitrage if I'm if I really spoil it down simply is how do I how do I acquire these businesses and then how do I operate them at scale, which you know, I'm talking, yeah, I'm talking it down a little bit as to what it is, but it's a very complex and challenging thing to achieve.
It's one thing to theorize what that is, and it's a very different thing to actually pull it up. So as you, one of the guys actually sitting there on the table having people effectively pitch them on why their aggregator and why their business is going to be one of the five, 10, 15, 20 of the potential hundred uh plus that exist in market today. Like, what are you guys looking for? What are you what are you reviewing? What are you what are you asking from them? Like what does uh what does a good investment look like in your eyes? Yeah.
Yeah, it's it's really interesting. And I think one of our portfolio companies had sort of put this in my brain and it stuck with me is that you're looking for um you know, a core team, and this is how we thought about it, which was you need someone with Amazon expertise and operational capacity. So they have to know the front end of Amazon, they have to know you know, keyword searches, optimizing if you know the A plus content and every everything that goes on the front of the page. I think that's a a really important um skill set. And then there's also you need the person who can get the product to Amazon or to the three PL provider, and that's your supply chain person. And they can go source the products in China or wherever they're getting into streographies, um, they have relationships with brokers, they have relationships with manufacturers, um, they have people on the ground who can you know do QA on the products before it comes to the US when it's easier to rectify any issues and and to avoid any issues from from Amazon dinging you for poor quality of product. Um that's sort of the second prong of it. And the third prong is somebody who can actually execute on the sort of the MA activity, do the financial due diligence, make sure there are no holes in the businesses that you're actually going out and acquiring. So that's that three pronged, and underneath you can have other people like brand managers and head of people and making sure that everything else is is running smoothly.
Um but it feels you know, those three are important. And the thing that one of our portfolio vendors said to us that really resonated was it's not an addition equation, it's a multiplication equation. So if any of those are a zero, your business is a zero because you can't get the product to the US, you can't get the product. It doesn't matter how good you are at selling it if you don't have a product there. And the same thing is if you have a great product but you don't have to sell it, it's worth nothing. And then if you have someone who can't actually execute upon the MA strategy and you're missing key things in due diligence, then the business is going to really struggle. And so those are the things the things that we're fundamentally looking for and to find each of those, how do we test? Who is a good Amazon operator? So that first prom approach. We often ask for the battle scars. And we talked about this when we were at lunch, is like, what are the stories you can tell me about how Amazon took down your listings, how someone hijacked your page, how someone you know put keywords in on the back end that made it sound like you were selling amphetamines or adult products or things along those lines that push you out into out of the main Amazon search. And so I want to know how you resolve those things because when I'm in the battle line sort of on the battlefront with you, I want to know that you can resolve that quickly if those issues were to come up and you know how to look out for them and prevent against them. And so uh that's one thing that I always like to ask. And then another thing within that is sort of straddling between one and three is when you're looking at new businesses, what are the black hack tactics you're looking to identify to make sure when you're acquiring one of these businesses that you're not coming into a business that has a massive liability associated with it, or that is not going to immediately get delisted or deranked because it turns out you were buying reviews or things along those lines.
And so we're trying to always make sure that you're protecting your business, whether it's once you're operating assets or when you're acquiring the assets. And that a lot, I think anyone would say that requires a lot of scar tissue and operating experience within the Amazon space to perfect that.
I'm amen. I mean, it's like I'm I I told you at lunch when you were telling me that how brilliant it is. And it's really one of those things where like if you know, you know. And if you've had those moments in time where, you know, you've been kicked out of Amazon, you've saved this very uh frightening. I mean, you know, the phone call is like the the most terrifying, which I've experienced. Um, but you know, the the messages of stop, you know, stop this activity, et cetera. Um, you know, I told you a little bit about my backstory. And one of the original founders was not the most white hat of uh characters. Um but uh anyway, um I think
that those things those things evolve over time, right? Like you can't be uh only focused on what the black hat tactics were in 2017 because they change every year and people get smarter and Amazon evolved and these sellers evolve. So uh it it really is amazing uh the creativity and ingenuity that people come up with to you know to win in this platform.
And you know, and that's the real beauty of the entrepreneurs driving a lot of these businesses and coming up with the ideas and building the brands to a position where you know they can no longer really scale it, whether it's a capital problem which you guys are addressing or an operational problem, or you know, there's I mean, a million things, like you know, it's compounding complexity as you grow the business. I think one of the things I really find interesting, or um, I think one of the key differences that I want to call out, and I think what's so cool about what it is you you get to actually do day in day out is that unlike um the companies that you financially back, you're looking at the actual founders and the core team, and your decision rests heavily on the people, whereas their decision and sort of where the market sits today is very much on the product and the brand. It's the acquisition of the asset, not the people. And, you know, I mean, I'm trying to think off the top of my head. I would say backing the people is much more challenging than it would be backing the actual product because if you understand Amazon, if you understand the strategy, if you understand the aspects around supply chain and you know, the acquisition tactics, et cetera, uh, you know, you're you're acquiring the assets. And if you can integrate them into the business, then you're gonna be successful. But um, you know, it's a green psychology there as well.
Yeah, oh, it's it's really it's really fun. I mean, we feel very fortunate that the flood of entrepreneurs that came into the space. Um, and sometimes when there are these hot markets, there's a lot of opportunists that come in who might not necessarily have the best background or be the most sophisticated. In this instance, we kept running into people like, oh my God, these entrepreneurs are unbelievable. They are really top-tier, high caliber individuals. And so it's been super fun to get to know them and to build relationships with these people who are um you know really, really impressive. And one of the groups we just uh you know announced with is a group of, you know, two or 23 and 24 year olds, and they built a business from college and they've you know scaled this business. And you know, we've had other folks that are not much older and that are building even bigger businesses or the same size businesses, and and it's really fun to see uh the quality of talent that has come into the space. And so uh we spent a lot of time with each of these management teams prior to making investments and went through this really rigorous process of multi-weeks up front and then confirmatory due diligence after signing a term sheet and then post uh just monitoring the day-to-day performance. You know, we have seller central logins and are looking at uh sales on a daily basis. And so there's there are a lot of things that we have access to and and updates that we get to see in dialogue with the company that I think is is really unique for the position that we get to be in.
Yeah, super unique, super valuable, and just uh a ton of insights there. So just to dig a little deeper there, like once you once you invest in these businesses and you know, you've backed that as a potential winning horse. Um what does the the ongoing relationship look like? You know, is it just we're handing you over the funds, we're making sure that things are going to plan? Are you a little bit more involved in it? Are you actually getting eyes in in perpetuity? Like, are you gonna log into seller central on a on a semi-annual, semi-regular basis? Like, what does that actually look like? Yeah.
So the really unique thing about being a lender versus being an equity investor is you are much more involved in these businesses on a daily basis. Um the company is either growing past the current size of the facility, they need flexibility on certain competence. Um, the market is changing fundamentally, and you have to rethink certain elements of how the loan is actually operating. You have to monitor the performance because you know, in equity, you can lose money just based off of the return profile in debt, you can't. Um so you're mitigating for downside risk. And so the the relationships we have with our founders is some of them we're talking to them most of them every other week on a call, getting updates on brand performance, pipeline of acquisitions, things along those lines. Um we're also on a monthly basis logging into seller central. So that's every month uh and corroborating top line reporting from our underlying borrowers and making sure that ties to seller central. And that's one of the themes that we really like about this this thesis is like in traditional small business rollouts, you're sort of relying on self-reported financials, and it's easier for there to be some you know accounting nuances that are going into this that make it harder to understand how the actual performance is. In this, you can go and see exactly what top line revenues are within a few percentage points because there are some reconciliations that happen there.
And then you can see exactly what the Amazon expenses are, you can see what the advertising expenses are, and you can pretty easily see what the landed cost of goods will by doing a reconciliation of the invoices that you have from the company. So that's a really interesting thing that we can do, and we're obsessive about it. Like we want to make sure that we stay on top and understand the performance of everything that's going on within our portfolio companies. In addition to that sort of like in-depth in-depth monitoring that we're doing, we're also sitting as board observers on most of these companies so we can hear the board level discussions that are happening. Uh, we're approving deals that are going outside of concentration limits or outside of eligibility criteria. We're doing, you know, we're we're pretty active, I would say, talking to most companies multiple times a week, um, if not every single day. Uh so it's it's a really accurate relationship and allows us to see a lot of what's going on in the market in real time.
Unreal, unreal. I just wonder, how do you, I mean, how many hours do you work? Because you guys are on a huge team, right?
Uh we have, you know, we've I feel very, very lucky. We have a really great group of people that works super hard and gets along really well and is working towards a common goal of just growing this uh you know, the this fund. Uh so it's it's it's been it's been really awesome. And so you know, we have a couple people on our team who are mostly focused on the Amazon thesis. And uh they're they're the ones who are really driving the ball forward here. And then we also work with uh third party and third-party service providers like the center of Is of the World to help us in areas in which we have less operational capacity um to free up some of the bandwidth, like for auditing uh invoices and PO, that's something that we probably won't do, but we'll we'll hire a third party to help us work on that with.
Yeah, that sounds like a much smarter investment than that, even you looking at someone's invoices. and POs. So you know, you guys have really been, I mean, you've been at Covenure five years now. You guys have backed in a number of these aggregators, and you have really built a thesis on the industry and its trajectory and where it's heading, so much so that you actually have sway and influence into sort of where it, you know, where it goes, which is a pretty cool thing to have influence in when so many people's lives are impacted by it. And you know, by you guys actually jumping in, um, it creates a whole lot of opportunity, which to me sounds like that was the whole initial thesis. So what I mean, what do you foresee over the next 12, 18, 24 months? Like, are we gonna see more aggregators diving into the space because the market's ripe? You know, are we gonna see, you know, what's the end game for a lot of these aggregators? You know, I I'm gonna let you talk to this because I could start throwing out uh my ideas, but yours are gonna be better.
It's any, you know, I don't have a crystal ball or anything, but what I'm seeing is I think the continued professionalization of Amazon as a platform. And I think that's the natural thing that happens as you have more and more statistic aggregators rolling up these different businesses. And so you're just going to see this become highly professional in the same way Airbnb did. So I mean, we probably five years ago when you go to say an Airbnb, it would be someone with an extra room and you could go stay there. And it was sort of like a you know, a little bit of an odd process. And now you feel like you're going to a hotel if you're saying an Airbnb. You have a property manager, everything's clean, they have a welcome gift. It's really nice. And so I think the way the Amazon ecosystem is it's going to professionalize in the same manner, and there's no choice because it's going to get more and more competitive. Um, and these aggregators have resources and abilities to deploy strategies that and more importantly, working capital that mom and pop operators don't necessarily have access to. And so I think that's sort of the primary thing that we'll see. And from that, it's going to be ideally a better shopping experience for consumers because you're going to have better products, more consistency, uh, better customer service, things along those lines. And ultimately, I believe that will translate to you know, further growth and sales within the third-party seller ecosystem and platform itself. Uh COVID had a really interesting impact on e-commerce where it pulled forward, I don't know how many years of sales uh to, you know, in behavior. And I think there was a little bit of softness coming out of COVID as people started going out and shopping more. I think that's the one thing that we'll we'll be curious to track is like where does consumer demand go from here?
Is it going to continue up and slowly get back to the peaks of the COVID bump, like people would say, in in sort of March and April of last year, or is it going to plateau here for a bit? And so that's one thing that I'm less certain about.
Uh but there's just so much. What's your take? What's your take on that? I mean, I'm just, I'm just uh I'm just listening to you talk about it. I know it's something that we all talk about, you know, queu two and three, fairly soft in this space, but you could hypothesize that right, we were all cooped up at home. We had nothing to do, we spent a whole lot more money online. I mean, I didn't, I live in Israel, so I'm lucky if anything actually gets there. But if I was living in the, if I was still living in the US, I'd probably be in like minus a million dollars right now. Um but you know, I find it very hard to believe that we live in a reality where when consumers who are not exposed to an online retail experience long term will not take that convenience over the desire to go and be inside of brick and mortar, maybe specific verticals or you know, let's say shopping for clothes, which actually, you know, especially in the US, uh, the return policies and the simplicity of it all is is there that you don't really need to worry, but I just find it hard to believe that you know, this this softness that we've experienced is not just a true reflection on the emotional tax of being inside for so many months on end.
I think you're probably right in in that it's a temporary softness. Uh and I agree with you. I think Amazon is a tremendous resource. And I think there was a couple things that came from it. I think there was probably a big push to support local businesses that were struggling during the pandemic. And I think that probably drove some traffic there. Uh, I think there was a big push to try to regain some sort of normalcy and going to shopping malls was, I think, in a weird way, a nostalgic way of returning to normalcy for a lot of people is is going back and being in person. And so those are probably um some motivating forces. I think that the messaging, I think Amazon has had a hard time controlling the messaging on the business as a whole. And one thing that they need to really focus on is we they are empowering small businesses. They are Amazon third-party sellers that are making millions of dollars a year off of Amazon's platform, right? And so I think that they uh there's a lot of negative publicity said, you know, by local not basos. And I think a lot of that is very fair and warranted. Um, and but I think Amazon needs to do a better job communicating that we're actually empowering a lot of small businesses along the way.
Um, and so I think like they can get that messaging, and I'm hoping that drives more because there's there's, you know, there's the macro level demand on an e-commerce perspective, and then there's sort of the consumer, the consumers who are saying, all right, do I want to buy from Amazon or do I want to buy from my local person and some of the impacts and associations with that?
Yeah, I I would uh I would tend to agree with all the points that you've just put out there as well. So I I want to go back to uh sort of your your day-to-day or you know, what you guys are seeing really, because for me uh on a personal level, it's super interesting, right? I think I honestly think you guys have one of the most interesting jobs because the deal flow that you see is you really get to see business ideas and incredible entrepreneurs and existing business owners coming with how do we really take this to the next level and the next level and really blow it out of the park. So I mean, I know one of the things when you talk about, you know, credit uh, you know, and debt providers and when you talk about venture capital, you know, deal float, it can be overwhelming for some, um, probably most. So I'm curious, like, what is that process look like for you guys? Like, how does someone get on your radar? Um, how do they get your attention? What is uh an interesting acquisition target for you guys?
Yeah. Uh it is it can definitely be overwhelming. And the best way to get to us through warm intro. So if someone knows us who we like and we trust, and you know that person, you can see and then they can connect us, right? I think that's the easiest way because then it's vetted through a source. Uh, if you're coming in through my email and I've never met you before, it's harder for me to verify that you know it's a real opportunity and we're already taking 40 meetings a week, and it's hard to sort of carve out the time for something that uh the value is unclear. Um, also getting people reaching out on LinkedIn, uh, which is a good channel because you can sort of vet the legitimacy through their LinkedIn profile and see whether or not it's something that's that's worth our time. But now we have uh five people on our investment team on the dead side, um, adding a six and hopefully a seven soon. And so we we sort of split up the responsibilities and uh some in some cases by region, uh in some cases by stage, uh, who on the team takes that first call and then move the ball sort of through the process at that point in time. Uh, but a lot of it is you know gonna come down to you know how how high fidelity the sources that the it's coming through, um, the stage, the operator, uh, and and all those sort of factor in there.
Yeah, and and like when you look through the vetting process. So, you know, someone's come in, they've had their first call, they've been warm intro, they're going through that process. Like, do you guys have a very stringent criteria? Like it has to, I mean, I understand, right? Like when it comes from an operator perspective, you know, for the Amazon thesis, like, okay, have to have someone who understands supply chain, has to have someone who is an MA background and someone who has the true Amazon battle scars and have been through it. But you know, are you guys? I know I always I always look at like how do I scale this? Like, how do I turn, how do I turn the 40 opportunities that you see a week into 400 opportunities and how do I automate that whole thing? So I'm just curious, like what does that next layer look like for you guys?
Yeah, no, it's it's really interesting because um we spend a lot of time looking and analyzing like where's your deal flow coming from and of the so it like we do some reports on like where is our total deal flow coming from, and then where are the deal, where's the deal flow that actually became actionable that was term sheets for um closed transactions? And it turns out that most of them come from venture capitalists. And so um we spend a lot of time building relationships with VCs. I think we're in a unique position because we can be the voice that tells them about what that capital markets is gonna you know provide on these companies. And so it's it's a really unique, unique place to do where you can provide equity and debt. And so right now, that's the highest fidelity source of deals. Some other sources have you know some some interesting things. Um actually entrepreneurs that we also back or other entrepreneurs in the ecosystem are also very high fidelity sources. Uh, and so it's like how do you double down and continue to build relationships in those ecosystems because those have proven out to be the highest ROI you know sources for deals.
Yeah, and that makes and that makes a lot of sense, you know, coming back to the original discussion point of like business and investing in people versus acquiring a product or a brand at the end of the day, it's always going to be about the people and so understanding who you can trust and how they operate together is such a fundamental thing. And I think something that you can never take away that human component of what it is, you know, it's not just you know numbers on a spreadsheet that's crunched, you know, uh, you know, to spit out a you know, an eBITDA that looks attractive or doesn't, right? There's a whole lot of additional factors that exist. So come back to it. Um what, you know, what sort of advice would you give to people who are looking to find themselves in a position to be a potential target for you? Or, you know, I would say what's probably going to be most interesting for the listeners as well. And I'm certain you have a pretty good insight in terms of you know what brands uh make sense for the portfolios that you invest in, and what are the things that they can do to really make them an attractive offering to, you know, to to do something, you know, either way, life changing. Yeah.
I'll I'll start with that one. And I think um there's definitely a lot of interesting things, and a lot of it comes down to we're providing the capital to the aggregators and we have a say of what they can and can't purchase, right? And so um a main thing that we're focusing on is evergreen. We don't want anyone buying um trendy or fatty things, things that are electronics that could go away or or are could be irrelevant. Uh and so focusing on evergreen uh sources of of products that will be around forever because we want to look at these as annuity streams. We don't want to look at these as sort of like fuses that go out over a couple of years. And so that's that's one thing is like build uh products in in in categories that are durable. I think that's really important. And and build genuinely differentiated products that can't be competed away by your next competitor, uh you know, either ramping up their PPC spend or lowering their price or some combination of the two.
Like how can you build real durable notes? Some of that's through the ratings and review modes with things along those lines. Um the second thing and relating to that is like don't become overly reliant on PTC spend. Because like if you have to, if you take your foot off the pedal, then all of a sudden your top line is gonna is gonna sink. And that makes it harder for people to want to invest in the business, even if your EVITA margin is improving as you lower your PTC spend. I think that if you become overlay on a PPC and you drive revenues up and then it comes back down, it can be negative signal for some folks. Uh another thing that we've seen as a struggle at the finish line as you're getting your business acquired is who's responsible for buying that next inventory purchase. I think something that we've seen across aggregators, especially with the supply chain crunch, is you buy business, you say, Oh, it's only going to take me, you know, a month and a half, two months to get stock in for my next order, then it ends up taking three, four months, and so you're stocked out for a month or two. And so, how do you work with the aggregator to make sure they feel comfortable with your inventory supply plan, whether it's what's at your 3PL or Amazon things along those lines? So those are some really uh some good ones, a couple a couple things to keep in mind as sort of you're growing your businesses.
Yeah, great insights. And you know, I speak to a lot of the uh you know, MA, MA guys inside of a ton of aggregators, and like that's one of the big challenging points is like, okay, we're under LOI, we've got, you know, we've got 30 days, and it's like, well, I don't really want to ramp my ad spangs and I don't really want to reinvest all this money into you know bringing more products over like it's their problem now. But in reality, and this is why, you know, this is why stability payments uh you know effectively came into play is like how to aggregators protect their interests and you know, align the interests effectively of the seller as well.
And so, you know, and and when you have to report to your lender, like when we're seeing the reporting packages that come in as the LIs are executed, and if we see a downward trajectory, we're like, what's going on here? Like, is there some underlying reason that this business is struggling? Or, you know, is it just a PPC pullback? Is it stock out? And so we're always trying to find the root cause of it. And is it something that is terminal to the business, or is it something that's temporary? And so I think those are the things that we're trying to sort out. And so the better job that they can do on that front and on that front will make it easier for them to sort of smoothly go through the process with uh the aggregators.
Yeah, I mean, absolutely. Well, well, on that point, like what are some of the one are some of the mistakes, or let's say, like the short, yeah, I would say almost like short-sighted mistakes that sellers like brands make thinking like I'm gonna squeeze that little bit out, or I'm gonna like what are some of the big mistakes that buy sellers, you know, sellers of brands who are selling to aggregators comes to buy them in the ass.
Yeah, I would say hiding things. Don't hide things because most of these uh people that you're selling to are very experienced in understanding the tips and tricks of Amazon. So if you are uh using a PayPal account to buy reviews or you know, reimbursing people for product, um, giving out gift cards, things along those lines, and you're not disclosing that, uh, you're gonna get caught. And when you get caught and haven't disclosed it, the aggregators or whoever's buying the entity is going to think that you're doing this elsewhere elsewhere in your business. And so it's sort of where there's smoke, there's fire. Uh in the in, and I would say just make sure you're disclosing what you're doing. Uh a lot of people's like not paying their duties and sort of the the tariffs and taxes associated, like pay those, um, make sure that those are being resolved uh because that creates a headache at the one-yard line uh and and complication as it relates to that. Um I think those are those are the main sort of the main things I would think about is just like being you know, just be be open kimono with it, be full disclosure, because you don't want to be in a situation in which you're getting close to the finish line, you think you have a deal here.
This is your deal and your one-to-one, whereas this aggregator might be buying five deals at a time and you don't want to be in a situation where something that they found out later on in the process, once you've already feel like you have that money in your pocket, is taken away from you because you didn't disclose something that was material to them. Um that's that's what I'd say is my biggest advice.
Yeah, yeah, great advice. And I think I heard um I think Stephanie Lay from she's the COO over at Thrace uh on a on a clubhouse back when that was in vogue. And she was talking about like just tell us if you guys are buying reviews, literally, just tell us because it's you know, you're gonna inherit that. And at the end of the day, and you know, if you've been through this process, you never forget it. It's it's harrowing, you know, to to put uh to have to submit your um your POA, uh, your effectively the actions that you're gonna take to resolve anything that might have gone wrong. And, you know, for anyone listening as well and anyone selling on Amazon, like there's been some pretty heavy changes to the you know, the the TOS right now in how you actually sell on Amazon, everything that relates to review manipulation and rank manipulation, like they've platforms like tech platforms have been kicked off of the actual ecosystem, which is you know, the first that I've heard of this magnitude and like in the community that I'm aware of. So yeah, I mean, uh again, just great advice.
Yeah, yeah. I mean, you you gotta be careful because in they've made examples of a lot of sellers that are sort of based out of China. I mean, we saw that uh huge, huge quantities of sellers that were large sellers um taken down for for TOS violations. And I think they'll continue to make examples of people who do not follow uh TOS or blatantly violating and have multiple violations. So I think that's something that just sort of across the board. And in one other point that I think is worth bringing up that I I failed to mention earlier on about like sort of where the crystal ball moment is I think that the aggregators will continue to have to differentiate themselves in ways that is not just financial engineering, like we're talking about at the beginning. And so that's gonna be either developing or buying um software or or tools that actually enable them to analyze businesses better, grow businesses better, improve their return on ads, then things along those lines. And so I think that also goes into the compliance piece of it is like how are you making sure that you're staying on top of Amazon terms of service and how are you are you making sure that when you're buying businesses, that there's not all sorts of fake reviews.
I mean, what was it? Review meta was just bought by I think one of the aggregators and uh other tools along those lines, I imagine will will find their way into their hands.
Yeah, absolutely. I I think as well, while we're while we're peering into clip crystal balls here, I think one of the interesting things that uh I believe will come to pass is that the focus to date has been very much on the acquisition side. How do we buy these brands? How do we operate them? And then how do we grow them? Whether it's you know through additional marketplaces or countries or D2C or any way in which we can grow those businesses. But I think like as we see the evolution of the industry, you know, PNG, they invest extensive amounts of money into product development. And so, you know, the the second coming, if you will, will definitely be, in my opinion, on how do we actually operate at scale, which is what everyone's trying to figure out right now. But then once we do that, it's not gonna be enough to just have a product that lives in market for the next 10 years. I mean, you can build something super evergreen, but there has to be a degree of innovation.
You know, Apple isn't the brand it is, and a lot of great brands because they had one product that sat there or a suite of products, you know, every year, like clockwork, there's an upgrade to the iPhone, to the iMac, to the MacBook, to the you know, the entire product suite. So I'm I I'm interested to see what that looks like.
It's I mean, I mean, you're starting to see it. The low-hanging fruit there is just more variations, colors, sizes, packs of different things. Like that's sort of the low-hanging fruit. Um, and then the next lowest hanging fruit is people are complaining about my product, let's fix the tweaks. How do we make it such that you know our sizes are more you know fit to norm? Um, and then beyond that, it's all right. Well, I own a business that sells uh knee braces, how how do I make ankle braces, or how do I make uh things for people with tendonitis or things along those lines where you can actually build off of the brand that you have in a way that Amazon, you haven't historically really thought about branding besides just having nice pictures and A plus content? So it's gonna be really interesting to see. And I think the big thing that has hold held that back historically is access to working capital and access, because right now, I think we talked about this before, launch like you are putting six to nine months of inventory on a shift to get here. You don't have a lot of extra money to you know come up with new ideas for products or invest in new products. You're just trying to stay in stock. Uh and so I think as the supply chain is right size, and I think as everything has gone uh gotten a little cleaner, that's gonna be the other place where I think people will have more time and opportunity to explore that.
Yeah, I think that's that's gonna be interesting. Uh so at what point do you see that you know traditional institutional capital and banks are actually going to say, okay, we no longer need to worry that there's a physical brick and mortar store. Like this isn't going anywhere. Like when are they going to really start to come to the party? Do you think that'll happen ever?
Yeah, I think it will in they'll tow in in certain ways. I think that for Thrasio is an obvious way for JP Morgan and I think there's a couple other banks involved in that syndicated debt. That was more so from like uh enterprise value, at least that was my perception of it, um, or like venture debt type of loan. Um, and that's they had a billion plus of equity in the business. And so you're looking at it more from the lens of like the capital structure looks like a traditional growth equity, private equity-owned uh company. And so I think there are ways that they're participating. I imagine they'll be participating in other ways in working capital. Um, I've seen them in small sizes um providing AR lines and borrowing-based facilities um to these businesses, but nothing of of you know substantial yet or relating to the cash flow of the businesses. I think that uh we're still a little ways away from from seeing meaningful participation beyond small, you know, small loans um for working capital. But um I think that we're seeing larger funds move in.
I think there were three of us that were doing it out of the gate that have all been sort of in this technology world before. And now we're starting to see really large financial institutions, you know, the Black Rocks, Blackstone, the polos of the world that have been in the asset, you know, alternative business for a long time, uh, starting to participate. And so I think that's sort of the next wave. And then once that's gone, I think you'll start to see uh the banks coming in because we'll see this has a bit more data, uh, you know, five years of operating experience and you know, hundreds of millions or billions of dollars of opportunity in front of them. I I I don't think they can ignore it for much longer.
Yeah, I mean, I can't wait to have you on again, Brian, firstly, because I just think that like when we have a conversation, let's say a year from now on the same topics, like that's another year of data that we have in reality. You know, Thrass raised its first bit of capital probably three and a half years ago, maybe four would be my guess. You would probably know.
Um Yeah, unfortunately, fortunately, yeah, because we had to pass on it a few times, but yes, yes.
I Well, I didn't want to, I didn't want to rub that one in in uh but but you know, realistically, it's not that long. Like, you know, when you think about traditional businesses, no one's really making acquisitions on businesses that have had at least three years in operation because you want to understand that it's not really a business that you know had its moment, like there was some significant moment, it grew, and then you know, it was sort of my dad he he his saying always comes into my head, but it's a terrible saying he calls them like fly by nighters, where they sort of, you know, they went up and then all of a sudden it just sort of crumbles. So we're still so early, it's still such a nascent space. And so it's just exciting. It's exciting to hear from your lens what it looks like right now. And yeah, I mean, I'd love to have you on again a year on and see where it sits.
We'll see whose crystal ball is more accurate at that point in time. We'll see uh what comes true.
My crystal ball, I think is probably years out. Um honestly, you know, we had a bit of a we had a bit of a conversation, but that's one of the things that I'm actually backing in heavily is that there's not you, you know, when you take the founder out of the business, they are the engine room to build new product. And so while you can run and manage and make slight differentiations around the product until you build or recreate that engine room, then you know, you're losing, you're losing a key function in the business to drive that forward. So, you know, I mean, we talked a little bit about it. I'm not gonna go into too much detail here, but the thesis is if we can build assets that are more attractive and create more time for potential aggregators to work with them so that they can figure it out in their own time as opposed to like holy shit, we've just acquired an asset and you know, we're we're plumb out of ideas here. What do we do?
We have to go and build these departments, then um, you know, that's that's gonna buy them time, and time is a critical function here. But anyway, uh I digress, mate. I digress. Um Brian, it was an absolute pleasure having you. Thanks again. Uh and how busy your days are. Um, I've loved every second of this. And uh mate, uh to the best of luck to all of the companies that you've invested in. I mean, I've met I've met Ali, I've met uh a couple of guys on the team, and you know, you guys are all wicked smart. So I I'll be surprised. Uh I'll be surprised if you know, if you're not backing lots of winning horses here. And I guess the beauty for you guys is not well, when it's debt, I guess it does have to be. It does have to be a winner, right? Right.
Um but we have we've got Ollie's guys equity stuff as well. So we're we're we're covering all of our bases here.
No, no, no surprise to me right there. But uh again, thanks for coming on and uh it was uh it was a pleasure.
Likewise, thanks so much for having me on. A lot of fun.
Episode details
- Series
- Successful Scales
- Host
- Yoni Kozminski
- Episode
- 69
- Published
- January 14, 2022
- Transcript
- 10,222 words