Successful Scales · Episode 98 · August 27, 2025

Ep 98: How to Win in eCommerce the Wellnesse Way with Founder Seth Spears

A conversation hosted by Yoni Kozminski. Listen above or read the full transcript below.

In this episode

In this episode of Successful Sales, we’re joined by Seth Spears, Founder and Chief Visionary of Wellnesse, a Certified B Corp revolutionizing the personal care space with cleaner oral care products.Seth walks us through his journey from launching digital businesses to building a mission-driven eCommerce brand. We dive deep into how he built a loyal audience, why influence is everything, and what separates brands that scale from those that stall.Whether you’re in the trenches of your own startup or just curious how top founders think, this episode is packed with insight, strategy, and the kind of real talk that’ll get you thinking long-term.

Questions Yoni asks

  1. That is, I mean, that would be in like uh 0.0001% of podcast downloads and even just website traffic. I mean, those are absurd numbers. And, you know, thinking through, you said it was a 10-year journey. Like, what were the what were the critical steps?

  2. Like, how does one even approach building an audience at that level?

  3. What do you what do you think were the things that actually resulted in that outcome?

  4. So it's it's never as bad as we we anticipate. But I'd love to just hear today, like, you know, it sounds like, and I I don't know what your numbers are today or you know how many units you're selling or things of that nature, but what are the things that are actually working for you today?

  5. And then as soon as he opens his mouth and promotes something authentically, you know, everyone's buying it. And so I'd love to understand, you know, obviously you had that 10-year tenure of growing that community. But if you were trying to give someone who maybe doesn't have that, you know, the 10 years of reps done on SEO optimized content into their ICP, like how does someone approach that?

  6. And does influencer marketing play uh uh a part in all of this too?

  7. And if so, how how so and how much?

  8. Are you able to, as a sort of an agreement structure, build it in a way where and I'm I'm coming to you as someone who's done very little. In fact, I've done no influencer marketing for for any of the stuff that that I've worked on. But are there uh opportunities where you can build them on performance basis?

From the conversation

“There's some that are, but less and less are because it's just been billed that, oh, you build a strong following, uh, then people will pay you just to promote something. And so it's not based on a percentage of the conversions. So the a typical like affiliate relationship is if you promote my products, then you're gonna get 15% of every sale. And so, I mean, that's if you're selling a lot, you have a lot of followers, a lot of eyeballs, that could be substantial, you know. But in turn, they're saying, no…”

— Seth Spears

“I think there's always a price component to it to see what the cost is of internal versus external. I kind of weigh the pros and the cons, especially so like for email as an example. Um, we both hired that out externally and then um brought it in internally. And then sometimes we even do like a hybrid of somebody who they're technically external, but they're working on our account almost exclusively. So maybe they have like one or two other clients. So it's kind of it's kind of splitting the difference there. I…”

— Seth Spears

“Yeah, um, I'm trying to think of an answer that is specific to the year and the way things are. I think it's the fundamentals. Everything goes back to the fundamentals. Uh, and I grew up as an athlete, and so you know, it's like you're playing basketball or soccer or baseball, whatever. It's all about the fundamentals. The more you can nail those down, then the better you're gonna be. And it's not just swinging for a home run, uh, but it's learning how to like wait for a pitch that you can hit.…”

— Seth Spears

“This is a great question. And I feel like it's changed a little bit over the years. Initially, when we launched the plan was to build it very big, very quickly, and then sell. Um, and then we launched right before COVID and then the market shifted. And so a lot of things changed. Um, supply chain, pricing, everything. Um also we made some really strategic errors early on because we did, we're not entirely bootstop. We took on a small investment round. And I feel like that created some challenges because whenever you take…”

— Seth Spears

“Listen to my gut. I think we often don't trust our intuition to the extent that we need to because we're looking at the numbers or outside pressure from maybe from a supporter from a board of directors, maybe it's from investors, maybe it's from up just peers in the space and saying, oh, well, these numbers make sense. But then if you feel like something's off, you got to trust that because as an entrepreneur, we're not just numbers based. I mean, at least for me anyway, like I'm very heart-centered and looking at…”

— Seth Spears
Read the full conversation
Full transcript7,589 words · speaker-labelled source
Transcript note: This transcript comes from the Successful Scales production archive. It may contain transcription errors. Exact quotations should be checked against the audio before reuse.
Yoni Kozminski

Today I chatted with Seth Spears, who has grown an e-commerce business for the past five years, hitting some pretty meaningful milestones from raising capital all the way through to seeing meaningful success and eBed up positive growth. When it comes to Seth, we covered a lot of things that make growth in the e-commerce space important. He has successfully grown his business through meaningful channels over the course of a 10-year period in the blog space that led him to the successful ventures he is now running today. I hope you guys get a lot out of this because he covers the basics of what you need to get right when it comes to growing an e-commerce business and a community to support it. All right. Guys, welcome to an episode of Successful Scales. I'm here with none other than Seth Spears, who will, of course, introduce himself in a moment. But before he does, I just want to share with all of you listening in. I was fortunate enough to make Seth at a community that I joined last year officially after a couple of years trying to uh decide that I had enough time. But uh Seth is part of the Baby Bathwater Institute community.

Yoni Kozminski

And I would say at a at a high level, you should be involved in a form of community. It's been pretty life-changing for me three months in. And you know, as a result, I get to have someone like Seth on the podcast and have some pretty cool conversations. So with that all said, Seth, um, I'd love you to talk a little bit more about yourself and give those listening in some context as to who you are and and uh likely leading to what we're gonna talk about.

Seth Spears

Sure, thanks, Yoni, for having me. Yeah, so uh I'm the chief visionary officer and founder of Wellnesse, which is a B Corporation certified brand of all natural oral care products. Um we've been around for just over five years now, and so we make the cleanest um personal care products, but primarily oral care on the market. So I've done quite a few entrepreneurial entrepreneurial things over the years. Uh, but that's currently my uh my present project right now.

Yoni Kozminski

Talk me through before we jump into your current day, because uh obviously you didn't start your career five years ago. No just a little bit of the journey, a little bit of the journey to getting to current day brand. And you know, I think one thing that instantly stands out to me is the fact that it's a B Corp, um, which has you know a lot of weight today. But before we dive into current day, like give me a little bit of the history and also just from a context perspective, you know, from the conversations that I've had with you, you know, it seems like you've taken a number of e-commerce uh businesses and you know, in the surrounding agency space. You've uh grown, you know, some some pretty meaningful businesses. So would love to just hear a little bit more about their the history.

Seth Spears

Yeah, so I'm trying to see where should I start. Um I started on my entrepreneurial journey um dabbling in a little bit of real estate back like in the mid-2000s and right around the time that the uh real estate bubble kind of burst. And so I kind of got really burnt out on that and had an entreprene uh had a real estate hangover for a long time because of that. Um so I had a real job where I was working for a university. And I got very burnt out on that as well and decided I was gonna go out on my own doing consulting. And so I did that for a short period of time, and that became a digital, a boutique digital marketing agency called Spears Marketing that I ran for years. Uh and I grew up in a family that was very health conscious, um, very health-oriented, looking at alternative ways to stay healthy and uh just live your best life. And so I convinced my now ex-wife to start a blog in the health and wellness space. And so I used that blog as a testing ground for my paying clients.

Seth Spears

And those tests worked really well. And it became a very, uh very large business. The largest health ones website and podcasts, specifically for health conscious moms. Uh and that was my major focus for a decade. Um then fast forward a few years, and I saw an opportunity in the e-commerce space to create personal care products, all natural personal care products, because we had tutorials on how to make them yourself on that website that I had grown so largely. And the audience, they really like those, but they got tired of making it themselves. And so when you hear the same request over and over, well, you just make this and sell it so I don't have to. Then you realize that there's probably an opportunity uh for a business there. Uh and I also started an outdoor equipment company several years ago with my brothers uh called Rewild Gear. And we the whole goal is to get people, uh, men specifically back out in nature into the great outdoors and spend more time there. And so to do that, we uh create really high quality and minimalistic uh durable hard goods for camping hunting, backpacking, so knives and fire stars and backpacking grills and camping utensils. So that's my fun side project that uh that I work on as I have time. Uh, but primarily I'm focused on just growing well and us, which is um our own natural personal care brand.

Yoni Kozminski

Really cool. I mean, I always love to hear a bit of the origin story because in entrepreneurship, nothing is particularly linear. And you know, while I haven't heard the numbers, it sounds like you grew the blog to a considerable uh space and you got a lot of the value added insights and data points that led you to actually building the product. Oh, very much so.

Seth Spears

I mean, like in its heyday, um, the website was uh called wellnessmama.com. Uh, and at the height of it, it was getting 10 million page views a month, just launched a podcast with it back in 2014, and which has had over 200 million downloads. Uh, so it became very popular, very successful.

Yoni Kozminski

That is, I mean, that would be in like uh 0.0001% of podcast downloads and even just website traffic. I mean, those are absurd numbers. And, you know, thinking through, you said it was a 10-year journey. Like, what were the what were the critical steps? Like, how does one even approach building an audience at that level? What do you what do you think were the things that actually resulted in that outcome?

Seth Spears

There's a lot of factors there. Um, being in the right place at the right time, uh, for one, because like so we started that back in 2009. And so my ex-wife, she was uh a journalism major in college who had gone back to school for nutrition. And shows she was a great writer and researcher, and just have a natural curiosity trying to figure out her own health issues and for our family. And so she wrote great content. And then I focused specifically on optimizing all that content for SEO for Google, because this is when you could actually write an article. And if you did you structure things properly, you had your site set up right, you could rank pretty easily. Uh, and so it really wasn't we worked hard for sure. But I would say it was not that hard in order to rank something just because we had had the foundation in place and had done things the right way. Uh you there was there was a time where we ranked number one for the term coconut oil, uh, elderberry syrup.

Seth Spears

You know, all of these like terms and superfoods and things that people were searching for constantly. So we got a lot of traffic in a turn, a lot of affiliate sales because of that. But growing it, it really started very organically, uh, mainly just sharing on social media, sharing articles with friends, commenting on other blogs, uh going on podcasts, and just engaging in the community. So I I've always considered myself kind of like a gorilla marketer, uh, not just looking at what everybody else is doing, but how can I go behind the scenes or do the things that no one else is doing or they're not willing to do uh in order to gain traction and eyeballs. And so we just focus on doing those little things that would bring people in and just built the audience up slowly but surely, started collecting email addresses early on uh and just grew from there. So it was really just doing the right things long enough consistently, which has been my formula for success over the years.

Yoni Kozminski

And and I think to that effect, you know, it's a it's a big proponent of it. It's if you just handle the basics and you get them done really well, you don't need to necessarily try all these, you know, bells and whistles and all, you know, all you know, if you get their basics right, you often you often get better outcomes than a lot of people who are trying to sort of sell you the moon and not not achieve it. I'd love to understand um I want to dive back into that, but I'd rather move a little bit more forward to current day because obviously 2009, very different landscape to today. And you know, I and e-commerce as a general um, you know, uh vertical, it's becoming more and more challenging. You know, we have margin compressions, whether you're selling marketplace or D2C, um, there's a lot of, you know, I mean, we're recording now, just as all these tariffs have been rolled out, and that's it's gonna be an interesting state of flux for a lot of uh e-commerce businesses in the US right now and what that actually means. I actually think it'll be a lot less impactful because you're getting charged on the actual product value creation and not the end product.

Yoni Kozminski

So it's it's never as bad as we we anticipate. But I'd love to just hear today, like, you know, it sounds like, and I I don't know what your numbers are today or you know how many units you're selling or things of that nature, but what are the things that are actually working for you today? And you know, if you're looking at other entrepreneurs who are growing e-commerce businesses, like what are the fundamentals today that you say these are the things that you really need to be hitting, otherwise you're gonna be left behind. Yeah. So I want to preface

Seth Spears

this by saying that every industry is different, every niche, every company. And so I don't think there's a one size fits all. However, I do think that the core things everybody can do is focus on creating the best quality product that they can, especially when it comes to e-commerce. Because there's so much noise out there, whether that's advertising on Meta or TikTok or Google or just in retail, there's so much noise and confusion. And with AI content just getting spread everywhere now, you really have to focus on creating the highest quality product that you can. And I think that's what we did really well. We got our start from very humble beginnings, uh, but the focus was always on creating the cleanest products that work better than the conventional alternatives. So that's number one is just having it being product focused. But then if you have a great product but nobody knows about it, you're not going to make any sales, right? So one of the things that we did, we had a built-in audience because of that other company that I had started, and we had an audience who was already asking for those products, so we can market to them. So I think building an audience before launching or in conjunction as you're starting the company, that is that's if that's not number one, that's number two as far as what what you need to do in order to be successful. Number three would be to get your branding really on point. Make sure it's clean, it's concise, your messaging is clear who you are, who you serve, who that avatar customer is. Because you really need, if you're trying to market to everyone, you're marketing to no one.

Seth Spears

So you need to be very specific on who that core audience, who that core customer is. Um there's so many different ways we could take this from there, but I feel like those are the top three, and that's kind of just the basic fundamentals, you know, is if you don't have those, yeah, you might get lucky. But I feel like those are the things that you really need to have in place foundationally in order to set yourself up for long-term and continued success and not just overnight, fly by night TikTok growth, and then you're gone the next day.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I think it's it's really refreshing to hear you break it down into you know three really simple buckets, um, you know, from having a great product and having, you know, there's the terminology of uh PLG, product led growth. You know, if you have a fantastic product and you can lean on that, that's huge. Um making sure that you're actually building the audience before you bring product to market and then making sure that that branding actually represents the world class product that you bring to market that can actually sort of uh run through the community and spread like proverbial wildfire is you know three of the key fundamentals. But one thing you said there, or I would say the second aspect of it, um, I think is a trend, um, which probably has always been the case, but I think something that more e-commerce businesses, even beta-b services and and just general sort of growth levers um are now more and more focused on is it's all about eye share, you know. And I'll give the example of the fact that like someone like Joe Rogan, who has one of the largest um podcast followings on the planet, if not the largest, you know, he's very, very good at keeping people captivated, bringing really interesting people on the podcast.

Yoni Kozminski

And then as soon as he opens his mouth and promotes something authentically, you know, everyone's buying it. And so I'd love to understand, you know, obviously you had that 10-year tenure of growing that community. But if you were trying to give someone who maybe doesn't have that, you know, the 10 years of reps done on SEO optimized content into their ICP, like how does someone approach that? And does influencer marketing play uh uh a part in all of this too? And if so, how how so and how much?

Seth Spears

That's a really good question. And I think it's gonna be different depending on the industry that you're in. Unfortunately, influencer marketing has not been a large part of our business model. Uh, you know, I made my bones in like the affiliate space because on that other that other company, we promoted a lot of products and services as affiliates. And that was more in content, some on social media via email and things like that. But that whole game has changed a lot because now things aren't ranking the way they used to. The Google algorithm has changed so much. And so now it's becoming more like the influencer game, where those people who have a large following on social media, and primarily that's Instagram and TikTok, some of the other platforms as well, but those are the two primary ones these days. They just want to be paid based on the number of followers they have, based on the number of eyeballs that are seeing it. But it has nothing to do with conversions, which to me, that's a missed opportunity for them.

Seth Spears

And it's it's worse for everyone. Because you shouldn't get paid just because you have followers. You should get paid because you're actually providing value and they're actually converting to sales, because otherwise it's just wasting money. It's artificially inflating the market. And so we have not had massive success with the influencer game of just getting people to promote. I mean, we're we're working with a few influencers and constantly trying to see what sticks to try to get better conversions and get more eyeballs and things like that. But it has not been as successful as I'd like. There is the part of the game when it comes to just brand recognition. So when if you have unlimited money to spend, uh, then you can just throw as much at as many influencers as you want, as much podcast advertising, as much as Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Google, and you just want to be seen all over the place. But as like a small, primarily bootstrapped company, we don't have unlimited budgets like that. So we have to be a lot more strategic with it and just don't have the cash where we can just throw money at the wall and just see what sticks constantly, you know. So we're very strategic as far as like the influencers that we work with. And we want to make sure that we're not just getting charged because, oh, they've got a million followers, and so you're gonna charge $50,000 for a post. Well, no, but if you have five people to buy, those numbers don't back out. That doesn't work. So we're constantly testing just to see who works and who doesn't. And is it uh is it a fit?

Yoni Kozminski

Are you able to, as a sort of an agreement structure, build it in a way where and I'm I'm coming to you as someone who's done very little. In fact, I've done no influencer marketing for for any of the stuff that that I've worked on. But are there uh opportunities where you can build them on performance basis? So you say, hey, you will take a percentage of you know revenue generated opportunities, or are influencers less inclined to put their money where their mouth is, essentially.

Seth Spears

There's some that are, but less and less are because it's just been billed that, oh, you build a strong following, uh, then people will pay you just to promote something. And so it's not based on a percentage of the conversions. So the a typical like affiliate relationship is if you promote my products, then you're gonna get 15% of every sale. And so, I mean, that's if you're selling a lot, you have a lot of followers, a lot of eyeballs, that could be substantial, you know. But in turn, they're saying, no, I don't want to be pace on paid on those conversions. I want to be paid just strictly because I have a million followers or 500,000 followers or whatever it is. And the problem there is half of those followers could be fake. They could have been bought, they're not even real. Uh, so that's why I don't like that game so much. Um, I think it's starting to turn around a little bit where people are realize or companies are realizing, hey, we're not actually getting the return that we thought. At least those companies that are more profit-driven and not just revenue driven. Uh revenue is great, but if you're upside down, then that you can only do that for so long, unless you have just unlimited venture back funds where you're just trying to hit revenue targets to do your next round or potentially for an acquisition. But again, the way the economy is right now with the terrace and everything else, who knows what's gonna what's gonna happen with with that market?

Yoni Kozminski

It also feels to me like those days. I mean, we came up a lot in this, you know, in the time of the e-commerce aggregator uh model where you know there was just an obscene of capital thrown out of space where you know money was free and it was just uh it was it was insanity from sort of 2019 through 22, and then that bubble burst sort of early 23, where where the whole uh e-commerce universe changed. So it you know, now no longer feels to me like it's growth at all costs and acquisition and and and that pathway. Like I was saying before, and you know, you're likely living it. There is a tremendous amount of margin compression, and there's a whole lot of competition that exists today that you know three and five years ago uh were not the case. And out of curiosity, it sounds like you're you know, a guy in the details where you know you're talking about the actual strategy that you're executing on, you're managing it sounds to me, like the actual influencer marketing side. Um, I've definitely seen, I would say, like the next rise of uh it wouldn't be a vertical, but a service providing support function in agencies. I'm seeing more and more agencies popping up.

Yoni Kozminski

And I know you came through that journey of building your own, but from operational complexity, are you looking to largely build your capabilities in-house, or are you tasking a series of agencies to actually do the execution work and operating more like a um, you know, more like a um you know a big corporate essentially, where they're not delivering on the work internally, but they're briefing it out and having executional support.

Seth Spears

Yeah, that's a good question. We do a little bit of both. So I have some of that done internally, and some of that is managed outside via agencies. Um, any of the agencies that I work with, I like small boutique ones because I need better hand holding, uh, they're able to understand the brand better, the messaging and what's needed. Um so if I can, I'd like to keep it in-house. But sometimes you know, there's a lot of training involved, and okay, Jilly, it just makes more sense to just hire that out. But specifically with paid ads, um, had that internal for a while, and that just did not work out so well. And so I found that by working with smaller boutique agencies who this is what they do. That's what they specialize in. Um, And they may not know the brand as well as somebody that they're full time. But because they're working with other clients also, they're seeing what's working in other industries or in similar ones. And so they're gaining, they're able to leverage that knowledge across all those different brands that they're working with. And that can be that can help speed up the process and create efficiencies. But you know, but then there is a trade off when sometimes they don't get the messaging quite right because they don't know all the ins and outs, like somebody that is internal that is working on it day uh day in and day out.

Seth Spears

So again, there's there's pros and cons to it. And I think it just depends on where you're at company wise and what your goals and objectives are. Um if you need somebody that that's all they do, they're just full time, then you could hire someone to do that internally. Uh or sometimes it makes sense just to hire out um an agency, um, at least just to start it and then bring somebody in internally from there.

Yoni Kozminski

So you you sort of led into what my next question would be here. But when you're sort of deliberating between external agency provider versus in house role, what are the key things? You know, what would your advice be to someone who is growing their e-commerce business? You know, what would be, and I appreciate that it you know might be different to different verticals, but in general, what what's your sort of decision making waterfall here as to in house, external, and what do I bring in first?

Seth Spears

I think there's always a price component to it to see what the cost is of internal versus external. I kind of weigh the pros and the cons, especially so like for email as an example. Um, we both hired that out externally and then um brought it in internally. And then sometimes we even do like a hybrid of somebody who they're technically external, but they're working on our account almost exclusively. So maybe they have like one or two other clients. So it's kind of it's kind of splitting the difference there. I I think it's it's really just gonna depend on the company and what they're selling and how they're doing it because it's it's gotten so complicated, uh, especially when it comes to the paid ads, because not only do you need the creative, you know, the actual the visuals, the images, the graphics, the videos, you need the messaging, what's being said. Um, and then you need like the the technical know-how as far as how much you're scaling up or scaling down, how much you're spending, um, who are you targeting? So there's there's three components of it, and those are different sides of the brain, you know, creative versus technical. So it's it's hard to find one person that can do all of it.

Seth Spears

And so trying trying to bring that in-house to to find somebody that's great all of those is very, very difficult. And that's where like an outside agency or a small boutique, or maybe even a couple people that you bring in, and maybe they're doing other things for your company as well. So, like if you have someone that's working on the creative for your paid, maybe they could work on the creative for your email as well. Somebody's working on the messaging for your paid, they could also be doing the messaging for your emails or for your website. So I think that can be a good way to break into it. So they're doing double duty.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, that's that's really good insight. So just to restate for those listening, you're either looking at boutique, smaller agencies that are going to help give you sort of that white glove treatment that are experts in uh specific niche. So let's say they're doing maybe medads and or meta and Google ads, and that is what they specialize in because you're able to go broader with deep skill sets and then looking at multiple accounts. So effectively, they're gonna get really good at it, and maybe there's not enough work to justify having a full-time person buying media if you're only spending you know three, four, five grand a month as an example, having someone full-time on that sort of becomes disproportionate, unless you're maybe considering getting offshore talent to to be that person, then maybe it starts to make sense. You would still need to have the now in how to guide them or at least share that brand messaging. Whereas you're bringing internal in the times where there's either maybe the start a little bit of role splitting, so maybe you can have someone who's good at the content side from a creative, and maybe they can handle a bit of the video work and a little bit of the design work, and if you're really lucky, a bit of the you know, the copy, but not necessarily then rolling them into paid media and web design and development. That's probably where it gets a little bit expansive. Yeah. That'd be a fair uh fair assessment.

Seth Spears

Yeah, I think so. And so something that I like to do when it comes to hiring is every new hire, start them, no matter what the role is that they're gonna do, start them off in customer service. Because especially when you're product focused, you want them to understand the ins and outs of the company of the product and the customer, because that's going to inform everything that you do. Like, what are the pain points of the customer? What's working, what's not? Where do we need to change things or tweak things and how can we optimize or look for new areas for growth? Is there new products that are being requested? Are there the same question or complaint over and over that needs to be addressed? Um, whether that's in our marketing or messaging or just in the product design or manuals or things like that. So I think there's the big opportunity whenever uh someone is hiring, is to start them off, like in that customer service world, just so they can really understand the core of the business and who that customer is. Because at the end of the day, every company is become uh customer focused, just because without a customer, you don't really have a business.

Yoni Kozminski

I mean, that's great advice. That's where you're gonna get to the to the depths of it, and especially when you're at a point where there's you know, material volume. I think for a company at your sides and experience five years in, I'm sure you're dealing with, you know, a healthy number of, you know, whether it's positive, negative insights, questions, et cetera, you're having a healthy amount of dialogue, and that's gonna give you sort of the, you know, the foundation to start to ask the right questions and have the right impact internally. I must ask, you know, we're in 2025 now. I have to look at my calendar to make sure I was right on the year. But we're in 2025 here, and you know, there's been interesting headwinds in in, you know, I would say in 23, it was quite a shock to the system where interest rates went from zero to 7%, and all of a sudden, you know, capital became no longer free but expensive, and you know, that that obviously hurt a lot of people.

Yoni Kozminski

What are you seeing as sort of the um you know current state of play for 2025? Like, what does someone need to do to be successful in their e-commerce venture? And we can stay in your vertical, um, but but I would say I think a lot of it is likely gonna be um, you know, universal when it comes to building an e-commerce business.

Seth Spears

Yeah, um, I'm trying to think of an answer that is specific to the year and the way things are. I think it's the fundamentals. Everything goes back to the fundamentals. Uh, and I grew up as an athlete, and so you know, it's like you're playing basketball or soccer or baseball, whatever. It's all about the fundamentals. The more you can nail those down, then the better you're gonna be. And it's not just swinging for a home run, uh, but it's learning how to like wait for a pitch that you can hit. Um So I think the biggest thing right now, at least the way I look at it, is differentiation. How can we differentiate from our competitors? How can we set ourselves apart from everyone else and what everyone else is doing so that we are seen as better? That we we really want to, we want to differentiate enough so that there's no confusion. When a customer comes to our website versus someone else's, they can see how different we are and what makes us better and why they would want to purchase from us as opposed to somebody else. For example, like our toothpaste. So uh 85% of our businesses in the Oreo Care market.

Seth Spears

And so we sell a whitening, remineralizing toothpaste, which is our best seller. We use an ingredient called microhydroxiapatite. There's two types of hydroxyapetite. And hydroxyapetite is a naturally occurring mineral that we source that your teeth, your bones are made of. And so it helps to remineralize your teeth. However, there's also uh in in the space, there's a nano hydroxy appetite, which is lab created. And so we're we want to focus on all natural ingredients whenever possible. And so nano, since it's created in a lab, there are studies coming out that are now saying that it can cross the blood brain barrier. And so we don't know what the long-term implications are of that. So our differentiating factor is we don't use fluoride, which uh is we're seeing how bad that is for you and the the long-term effects there. So we want to be as natural as possible. And so, but we're taking a step further than just using any hydroxy appetite, but using micro, which is naturally sourced, so that we can differentiate from all of our competitors who are primarily using nano. So that's just one example of what we're doing. But I think any time you can set yourself apart and show like us versus them and how we're different, that's uh gonna be one of the big factors.

Yoni Kozminski

Yeah, I mean, just listening to you speak, Seth, it seems like you are heavily invested in, you know, I mean, you're talking differentiation, but it's really what is your brand messaging? What is your brand promise? What are the things that truly set you apart so that your audience, you're you're set your selling or sending rather a uniform signal of we are a B Corp that sources natural products that are going to be better for you in the long run. And that is sort of what you you live and die by. And I think for anyone listening in and looking to build their brand, there's the term and you use something different, but it's like jack of all trades, master of none. If you're trying to sell to everyone, then you're not gonna sell to anyone. And so if you are, or what it sounds to me like you're doing is you're niching down so intentionally on what your ideal client profile looks like and building that avatar and working backwards and saying to the nano versus micro uh uh hydroxy, I can't remember the exact term. Hydraxyapetite. Hydraxy appetite, like you are breaking it down and educating the audience in stating, hey, this is lab built, and this is naturally occurring.

Yoni Kozminski

Pick your own adventure, but we are we are all natural and we're gonna do everything to support you on that journey of health, healthy, better oral care. Yeah, exactly. That's exactly what we're doing.

Seth Spears

Um I think when you're launching a company, and and we did this. When we started in 2020, we uh we looked at we were gonna be personal care brand. So oral care, hair care, and skincare. And so we launched with just oral care and hair care, uh, and then got into the skin uh site as well with like a hand sanitizer and deodorant. Um, but we quickly saw that oral care was our signature. That's what people are going for. And so now 85% of our business is in the oral care space. So we've niched down. Um, and I think sometimes that's what it takes in order to figure out where your sweet spot is and what you're gonna focus on, especially when you launch with multiple products, because there's two different ideas you could do here. You can launch with multiple products and see what's what's what works, or launch with like one or two, and then see how that does, and then what the customers want and then expand from there. Uh you know, two different different philosophies around it. And I tend to think it makes sense to maybe split the difference uh somewhere, don't launch with like a ton of SKUs, but probably maybe launch with more than just one, depending on what you're selling, what industry you're in. I mean, for us, it made sense to launch with with hair care and world care, just because that we already have the demand from the audience from the prior company that I had.

Seth Spears

So that's how we uh base that decision. But if you don't have an audience already and you're not getting feedback and you don't know what they want, and you're just going by what you see in the market, then sometimes you kind of have to take an educated guess and just kind of throw it at the wall just to see which of the options is going to work out best and sell the best.

Yoni Kozminski

I think that's great advice, especially for people who are trying to find their position in market, and you know, you you test to see what the market wants, and then you can niche down on it. Um I'm mindful of the time, but I just have a couple more questions for you before I let you run that has been sitting on my mind, particularly for all business owners, but I think in the e-commerce space uh in particular, and you know, we saw this uh pretty insane boom through that sort of aggregated space where multiples went from, you know, one and a half to up to north of seven. And I'm talking about small businesses, you know, that might be doing five million in revenue and hitting multiples at that level. Seems like the market, you know, once we start going north of 10 million in revenue and you know, two million in eBITDA, then the multiples obviously shoot up again. But I'm curious for you, for any business owner, are you starting with the end in mind? So are you looking at this and saying, hey, I'm building a lifestyle business and I want to have 30% net profit margins and that'll fuel my life. Are you looking at it and saying, I want to run this for five years? Well, you're over the five year, but you know, 10 years and have a liquidity event. Like, are you sort of building it in a way that you're you're very intentional, or you found your way 10 years, building an audience from the audience, there's the product need. And you know, so I'm just curious, like, how far into the future are you planning?

Seth Spears

This is a great question. And I feel like it's changed a little bit over the years. Initially, when we launched the plan was to build it very big, very quickly, and then sell. Um, and then we launched right before COVID and then the market shifted. And so a lot of things changed. Um, supply chain, pricing, everything. Um also we made some really strategic errors early on because we did, we're not entirely bootstop. We took on a small investment round. And I feel like that created some challenges because whenever you take on money, you you have a fiduciary responsibility to those shareholders, to those investors. And but then there's also pressure to spend that money. So we made some strategic errors in hiring and hiring someone who to basically run the company as COO, who um was out over their skis a little bit, um, made some poor hiring decisions herself, and so ended up leaving early on and left us very much in a financial bind. And so we had to turn things around, turn the ship around, and we've done that. Um, and because we almost went belly up within the first first year or so.

Seth Spears

Uh, you know, if you can typically most companies they fail within the first five years. And so we're past that. Uh, but we haven't hit those numbers that we're hoping for early on. So it's kind of changed from like let's grow at all costs and then sell to hey, let's just let's perform a strong business fundamentals back to profitability. Uh, you know, we're like uh just over 10% EBITDA. Uh so we're seeing strong and consistent growth, but we're gonna run it for profit, but then potentially down the road, sell once it makes sense if we get a solid offer. But I feel like we still have there's so much opportunity still in the market. There's so many things that we can still do growth wise. And because in the oral care space, it's uh 20, 20 billion dollar a year industry, I believe the last number that I saw. So there's so much potential there. And especially with the way the economy is, people waking up around their health and how natural products are better. I think we have a big opportunity to continue to grow and take every market share and then down the road sell for a much larger multiple than we could now, just because I still feel like we're a little bit in the turnaround phase of the business. And so while you know, we've had some nice growth and um are profitable for the past three years, uh, we're still not where I'd like to be. So I think every company's gonna differ on that in their perspective.

Seth Spears

Um, and mine's shifted a little bit. I mean, I've always thought of my my goal is always to been let's build it the right way and be profitable. And then if we get an offer, we can. But instead of like that's the end goal, it's like, okay, well, let's build a nice business. It's gonna throw off some cash, and then if we do get an offer, then we can evaluate it from there.

Yoni Kozminski

Love it. Love it. I mean, that's that's really it, right? You have to adapt and change, and that is the perpetual reality of any entrepreneur, and particularly in the e-commerce space, um, and also taking on capital and you know that there becomes a whole other uh equation, which I wish we had more time to go deeper into that one. But before I let you go, Seth, I'd just like to ask the question for anyone who is it doesn't even need to be necessarily like just at the starting out phase, but like if you were to look at yourself five years ago with the knowledge that you have now, that's on the back of your agency, on the back of the blog, on the back of everything that you've done, what would be the advice you would give a younger self on how do I actually get this right? Like what are the things or or what's the biggest mistake that you made that you wish you you had um course corrected or not gone down that path?

Seth Spears

Listen to my gut. I think we often don't trust our intuition to the extent that we need to because we're looking at the numbers or outside pressure from maybe from a supporter from a board of directors, maybe it's from investors, maybe it's from up just peers in the space and saying, oh, well, these numbers make sense. But then if you feel like something's off, you got to trust that because as an entrepreneur, we're not just numbers based. I mean, at least for me anyway, like I'm very heart-centered and looking at am I doing the right thing? And maybe we can make more money by doing this other thing, but it just feels off. It doesn't feel like it's the right thing, but I have to trust that. And every time that I don't listen to that, I end up regretting it. Um, and sometimes it can be the right decision in the moment, but then it changes, and so you need to course correct and go from there. So I think it would be just to trust my gut more, hire slower, and not just make decisions based on pressure from others. Because when it's the right, if it's the right decision, you'll know it, you'll feel it. And so don't shortchange that by listening to what others who you respect say, because at the end of the day, if it's your company, the buck stops with you and the decision is on you. So yeah, listen to myself more.

Yoni Kozminski

Great advice. Seth, thanks so much. I mean, I got a lot out of this personally, and I'm sure those listening in will uh as well. Uh, I'll ask as well if there was somewhere that people would want to find you, you know, where do you live online and what would be the best way to get in contact? Sure.

Seth Spears

Yeah. So my personal website is just Seth Spears.com on Instagram at Spears Marketing. Um, and then my company is Wellnesse, um, W-E-L-L-N-E-S-S-E.com.

Yoni Kozminski

Beautiful. Seth, thank you so much. Thanks, Andy. Really enjoyed it.

Episode details

Series
Successful Scales
Host
Yoni Kozminski
Episode
98
Published
August 27, 2025
Transcript
7,589 words