In this episode
In this episode of Successful Scales, we sit down with Jimi Gibson, VP of Brand Communication at Thrive Internet Marketing Agency. Jimi takes us through his journey from graphic designer to agency leader, sharing the wins (and struggles) that shaped Thrive’s growth.We dive into everything from building momentum through “microwins” to why Thrive made an intentional shift toward inbound leads and organic growth. Jimi also unpacks demand generation and the operational changes that set the agency up for long-term success.This episode is packed with valuable insights and timeless growth principles you won’t want to miss!
Questions Yoni asks
And I'd love just some insights on what brought on that shift and that focus and and how, if it was sort of in your exposure to it, like how is it actually affected to create that outcome?
Like, what are the things that I guess people listening in should be mindful of of either potentially easy wins for them or things that would make sense for their business, whether they work with Thrive or not?
Like, what are the what are the things that they should be paying it attention to?
What are the things that you know, AIAI AIAI?
But like, what are the things that people should also be equally avoiding?
Those days are uh I I would say thankfully over because it really is about having um adding value and creating stickiness and meaning on those websites. Uh Jimi, uh it was an absolute pleasure. I'm gonna drop all the links, obviously, in the show notes, but should someone want to get in contact with you?
Um, you know, uh who would be appropriate to work with as Thrive as an agency, you know, who should be reaching out if that'll listen to this?
From the conversation
“They only work on our own visibility. And so there's a very focused and scientific approach to that. We have writers, we have SEO experts, we have all the folks that are necessary to bring that to case. We have a separate team that works on the client delivery. But the cool thing is the RD aspect of demand gens the work that we do for the clients because basically we're able to research, try out new things. Um, you know, if we have our core uh traffic channels and we know what our lead…”
“And so when you go through change, there has to be a reason for that change, right? And so there's the old tale about the dog lying on the front porch, and it's whimpering a little bit. And the two old guys are sitting there rocking back and forth and going, Well, why is that dog whimpering? Well, he's laying on a nail. Well, why didn't he get up? Well, I guess the pain in that nail is not enough for him to get up because he's pretty comfortable. And so, what is the level…”
“Um, I won't say it was perfectly smooth, but it was a lot smoother because of all the steps that I just mentioned. And so now like it's functioning like the way we want it to function. And everybody has this common language, and maybe I'll stop there and you can dig in. But um, I tried to explain it as clearly as possible. There were a lot of moving parts. Um, it ended up being kind of fun. It challenged us to think beyond sort of the rut that I think we had gotten…”
“They we have a um a culture where we discourage overtime. We saw that people were putting in more hours that was affecting their home life. So all of these softer things started to bubble up. And then compared to the fact that I mentioned we wanted to double in size, it was preventing us from being able to onboard new clients because our capacity, and it took longer to do things, right? And so our efficiency numbers went down. And so I would say when you mix all that up in a bowl of…”
“And so if you've been doing those things, great, continue to do those things and understand that these large language models are looking for a larger contextual footprint to your brand. And that first search doesn't always return the group. It actually fans out into multiple branches of a tree, and they're checking to see is this brand showing up in all of these places? And so we've seen uh I would say organic social has been a struggle. It's usually the first thing that people cut as a service, and we're seeing that increase…”
Full transcript7,822 words · speaker-labelled source
Today I had Jimi Gibson on the podcast. He brings with him, I believe, 30 plus years of agency experience working his way up from graphic designer all the way through to really leading out the strategy function of Thrive Agency that is a near 200 person, thousand client plus agency that is doing some really interesting things. We talked a lot about what it is to structure an agency and how to go through uh considerable org change to ways in which you can drive demand for your business. So if these are topics that interest you, then this is the one. Get it. Have an enjoyable 30 odd minutes of listening to Jimi. All right, welcome to another episode of Successful Scales. We are right around the 100 episode mark, which is really, really exciting. Uh I'm fortunate today to be sat down with Jimi Gibson, who he's gonna tell you a bit about himself, but before we hit record, we've been going back and forth, and he's got a super interesting career, and I'm always partial to people who are still living that agency life and doing meaningful things. So without further ado, uh Jimi, please uh tell the audience who you are and uh we can uh dive in. Great.
Well, I'm excited, Yoni, thanks for having me. Um, So Thrive Agency uh it's been around for about 20 years. Actually, we celebrate our 20th anniversary in October, which is kind of a uh crazy unicorn in the digital marketing space. Most of my career has been in the agency world. I studied uh creative advertising and graphic design in college and started working at agencies right out of school and um actually started as a graphic designer and always was asking the owners of the agencies like, why are we doing this? Well, what's the point of all this? They were like, well, why don't you go ask the client? And so I guess that inquisitive nature just caused me to always want to be pushing and uh making sure we were stewarding uh the client's money the way that we needed to and getting them the results. Um I was the creative director of an agency that was an omnicom agency, which is basically a holding company for for agencies and ended up having the opportunity to not only be the creative director but run that agency. And I guess the agency life, you know, some people love it, some people hate it.
I always love the speed, the pace, the variety um thrive. We have about a thousand active clients. Um most of them are in the US. We do work with some international companies. We don't specialize in any particular industry or vertical. Um, most of our bread and butter, as they say, is the mom and pop single owner, uh small business, but we do have quite a portfolio of enterprise multi-location franchise organizations. Um, so yeah, I uh love the culture that we have. We might get into a little bit of that. I think when you talk about scaling a business, you have to make sure that you have the right team on board. I remember going to an interview at one agency and they had showers in the creative department. And uh stood there a minute and I'm like, showers in the creative department. What does that mean? Oh, that means I don't get to go home. Um so I think when you discourage overtime, you let people have a good life outside of the agency. Um, just from some of the toxic environments that I've been in, it's uh refreshing to be able to be in that type of environment. So yeah, happy to dig in on any of those points, Yoni.
Awesome. Thanks, uh Jimi. I feel like uh you don't do yourself enough justice in just how uh a broad stroke and some of the exciting things that we chatted about before, but thankfully I took down some notes and I'm gonna inject uh I'm gonna inject them uh into the conversation. Um you are effectively right now at an agency, like you said, a thousand clients and circa 170 plus team members. Uh, you know, you're sort of playing in a range now where you're not a small agency, you're obviously not Omnicon, um, which is just you know, 3M, you know, there's there's a handful of these conglomerates that make up probably 70 to 80% of all of the digital agencies, and then you have sort of all the challenger brands, if you will. And the first thing that really um struck me as really interesting, um, and and I believe it might have been before you joined, but but maybe not. You said that before we hit record from 2016 to 2020, there was a really focused uh effort on meaningful growth. And there was there was a focus on that sort of growth acceleration, and you know, in the in the game for 10, 15 years, and there's this decision to obviously you know rapidly grow. A lot of companies struggle with growth. You know, it's all well and good to have whether it's agency capabilities or a staffing solution like we have, or whatever it is, the product or service that you're selling. Um I think that something material happens when you set a target and you hold yourself accountable to that goal.
And I'd love just some insights on what brought on that shift and that focus and and how, if it was sort of in your exposure to it, like how is it actually affected to create that outcome? And and again, it sounded like you guys actually hit the goal. So I hope I'm not uh taking you down a path where you weren't there and you sort of have to dig deep to figure out and reverse engineer. But um, yeah, I mean, tell me.
No, I mean, it's an important part of the history of Thrive. Um, we talk about it a lot. I wasn't there, I've been with the agency five years. Um there were some other things that happen uh over the last five years that we might get into. But uh so Matt Bowman started the agency in 2005. There was pretty slow growth um throughout that process. And he really he's a multi-generational entrepreneur. So, you know, his father, his grandfather, uh they had businesses, not in marketing. Um, one had a I guess uh basically a country store uh that expanded pretty large. Uh his father was in publishing. But the passion of the company was to help as many business owners as possible navigate the world of the internet. And so if you think back, that was sort of a weird time that people were saying it's not gonna catch on, like nobody will ever buy anything on the internet. And I think we're kind of in that state right now with AI. There was sort of a fork in the road where people were thinking, well, I'm gonna stick to the old tried and true.
Well, I'm gonna adopt the new technology. And so there was uh a friend, an investor, uh business partner that came into the mix that had that mindset of growth and sort of challenged Matt to take that on as a goal. And you know, I think when a company doesn't set goals, you can just sort of flounder and chase the next shiny object. But there was a formal process of making a yearly plan, measuring monthly, making adjustments quarterly, and so there was a very strict approach to we're gonna hit these goals. And so I remember having this conversation with Matt about what did that feel like back then, and and you mentioned it in your question related to staffing, and there Matt was doing a lot of the sales. There were people that were brought in. And he says, we're gonna grow the sales team to quadruple what it is now. And Matt was like, Are you crazy? We don't have enough room. What are we gonna do? And so all of these tactical, logistical things start to creep in to the owner's mind as reasons why this might not work. And so I think when you have somebody who's been down that path before and walks you through the math of how this is going to work and say, when we hit this goal, we'll hire this person. When we hit this goal, we'll hire this person. Here are the services that will round out um basically a retainer-based business, which most digital marketing agencies are. Here's how we retain clients.
Here's how many clients it's gonna take to make this math work to reach what we need to reach. And so when you break it down, and then you have these micro uh wins on the KPIs that you've developed, then you start to get excited and you go, wow, this can really happen. But I think at the core of it, Yoni, was this belief that we sort of have a secret and we've figured out how to get results for clients, and we really want to help people. And we want to make this world of the internet accessible to more business owners who perhaps don't know what in the world they're doing. Um, so yeah, I would say that's a good description of the setting as to where that happened and uh happy to dig into details.
Yeah, I mean, I mean, one one key thing that I thanks for sharing. Um, one key thing that I take from that, or sort of the subtle shift. And I think that um it's sort of a critical point, I think, when when you look at most businesses that are originally founder-led from a growth perspective that need to mature and find a scalable way in which founder who often acts as salesperson early on in the life cycle of a business, has to move away from that. And so bringing on, you know, quadrupling the size of the sales team, effectively trying to create a systemized way in which you actually sell your solutions sounds to be like one of the critical uh decisions, which is obviously very scary for founders and business owners. I think a lot of people have to get comfortable with the fact that you know your sales team will probably at best capture 70, 80% of what you as a you know, founder-led sales style business will be able to do. But it's about how do you then do, I guess, what thankfully Thrive can do as a business, and that is generate digital uh opportunities for the business to then actually bring it into the sales team and qualify those leads and actually convert them at a at a much more rapid clip. So I think that's a like a that's a fundamental lesson or a fundamental sort of decision that founders need to make at that moment in time where um where the business is big enough or requires that that shift, and it's a really hard one to let go.
One more thing that I wanted to add, which I think is important maybe for the listeners to understand, is there were some non-negotiables and fences that were set up related to the expansion. And you know, when you think about a sales team, you think about a variety of techniques that you could use to get those leads. And many organizations have an outbound approach. And so that involves cold calling, that involves going out uh to various events. Um, the decision was made that we wanted to rely on inbound leads. And so what does that mean? That means that we weren't going to be investing in advertising. We were gonna be really taking advantage of the opportunity for organic growth, which is what our clients wanted. And so we actually expanded our demand gen team. In fact, the person who leads that team now, it was the first employee. He's still here. And so we've spent 20 years basically researching what it takes to drive inbound leads. And if we look at a model on what we would want to do for our clients, it's because we look in the mirror and we've done it for ourselves.
And I think that is a differentiator that was a great decision. And we have um enjoyed the benefit of not only organic inbound leads, but also being able to speak specifically to that when we are in a sales conversation. I can be in a you know, an area of the country we were founded in Arlington, Texas. That's where our headquarters is. I can walk out onto a stage in Raleigh, North Carolina, and people are traveling from all over the country, and I can say, take your phone out. I want you to search for digital marketing agency or SEO agency, and wherever you traveled from, whatever city it is, uh Charlotte, North Carolina, Orlando, Florida, um, go ahead and search. If we don't show up in the top five, come here and see me. I've never had anybody come up and talk to me afterwards, unless it's some really, you know, remote area. And I'll say, okay, well, give me the benefit of the doubt. What's the nearest relatively large city next to you? And that's an impressive thing. And I think that was imperative to our growth and our ability to scale because we practice what we preached.
Yeah, I mean, I'd love to dig into this point and go a few layers deeper. Um, because it does uh piggyback beautifully onto that idea of how do you move away from founder-led growth, building out its sales team requires the inbound or outbound traffic in order to actually justify the the investment and and closing of the deals. Just for those listening, um, obviously marketing as a uh you know, as a uh function in a business has evolved. There's a lot of terms that have now encapsulated under marketing, you know, there's a there's a whole growth function uh that people talk about that is separate to marketing, and there's lead gen versus demand gen that you uh you you indicated. So I'd love you just to help the audience understand when you say that you guys have doubled down and focused on demand gen, what are the types of solutions or capabilities that exist and and what are the benefits of that? Yeah.
So I think you know, if we can just take it down to the basic structure of the word demand gen is how can we create a desire or demand for our services, right? And so we recognized, uh I think you know, I mentioned that Matt started the agency as a web development company, but the client was then going, Great, we got this website, but nobody's visiting. What do we do? And so SEO was a component of marketing. And demand gen can encompass all of the tools that we have: PPC, paid social, organic social, email marketing, all of those things. Um we believed and still believe that content is a differentiator because the footprint of your website, uh, the backlinks to the website, and I know there's some shifts now as we get into AI mode and uh these large language models. I still believe the basics of that remain. There are location specific signals that are triggered in the algorithm that allow us to be able to be quite high in the rankings or present across the country. And so we really took a forensic aspect of analyzing from that Dallas Fort Worth Arlington area, and then basically drew concentric circles around that home base and said, okay, first of all, we need to rank in our own backyard.
Great. Next, we need to spread that radius out a little bit. And pretty soon we got outside of the state of Texas. And then we're like, okay, well, what are the major markets around here? How is the algorithm treating the proximity? What needs to happen to have Google understand that we can do business for people outside of the Dallas Fort Worth area. And I think that was a key differentiator as well, because we did not try to conquer the US in one fell swoop. It was a very systematic approach. And I think that is also a scale mentality. Um you're not going to be able to immediately blow up from 10 employees to 200 employees just because you want to have 200 employees. You'll you'll kill your cash flow, you won't be able to make payroll, you know, all of these things. And so as we expanded our market into these other areas, that gave us permission to then scale. The goal was and you know, you always say um, don't go after the goal, go after the benefit of achieving that goal. And so the benefit of achieving a wider net that we were able to bring these inbound leads from gave us permission to then be able to scale at an appropriate rate. And so basically the demand gen team does not serve clients.
They only work on our own visibility. And so there's a very focused and scientific approach to that. We have writers, we have SEO experts, we have all the folks that are necessary to bring that to case. We have a separate team that works on the client delivery. But the cool thing is the RD aspect of demand gens the work that we do for the clients because basically we're able to research, try out new things. Um, you know, if we have our core uh traffic channels and we know what our lead flow is per month, then we can go, okay, what part of that can work for a law office? What part of that can work for a medical uh facility, what part of that can work for a home service company? Um, how hyper-local can we be with our own work so that if a plumber is trying to get business in a 30 mile radius, because we started at our own location and we branched out in these concentric circles, that gives us the ability to know what to do. So I don't know if I went on a off on a tangent there and that answered specifically what you were asking for. So if I didn't hit the nail on the head, you know, come back with some more clarity for me.
Yeah, I I mean, I'm I mean, I actually probably failed to mention, but I still head up our marketing uh growth uh function internally. So I have a team uh of 10 that sit under me from SEO specialists to content writers, uh webflow developer, HubSpot Engineer, email marketing, like the WEX, uh essentially. I've built my own little agent. Like I said to you at the start, recovering agency guy here. I don't know that I'll ever uh find my way out of it for better or for worse, but uh it I mean it's just you know, I I think you hit on some really good points before all of this. Um it's just so dynamic as a space. I think there's very few functions in a business and specifically in agency land, where you can touch on so many moving parts to create a holistic approach to how you understand and assess performance, feed that in and get that data input, be able to cultivate that into a structured inbound flow, assess which one is working best, and based on their uh, you know, how they're actually discovering you, send them on a specific journey and look to take them from marketing qualified to sales qualified through that that journey. Um so you did answer, you did answer the question, and I was definitely enjoying a lot of um, you know, the contextual insights of how you guys are running your SEO function, and and also you touched on a little bit of uh how the company is structured, which I'd like to dive into uh in in just a moment. To to your point about demand gen and and and for the audience's benefit, you know, there's one aspect is is getting people to find out about you through SEO and now GEO is the new term for uh AI driven, which I mean you kind of alluded to it, but I feel the same. We're seeing a lot of traffic now from perplexity and from GPT and we've not done anything uniquely different to our SEO strategies. So whatever has worked for SEO seems to be translating into GEO, and this isn't the death of uh SEO, at least for the for the minute.
Um on the contrary, I feel like we've found a whole new lead source that uh is proving more valuable than traditional SEO, which is pretty cool. Um we could probably have a whole episode on on that in and of itself. But oh yeah. Um I wanna I want to change gears um a minute here. Um we talked a little bit about, or you're sharing a little bit about how you have effectively like your internal stakeholders who are building and delivering and executing, and then you have a client-facing team that's really sort of the you know, the conduit between service delivery and the actual insights, and then there'll be a whole lot of different elements I can only guess internally to go from you know from paid to search to all the different pieces of information you strategically need to assess all of it together to create that that uh complete picture. Um, You know, we chatted before we hit record, and you were talking about the fact that two years ago you went through a quite a um intentional and and large shift in how you were operating as an organization.
I'd love you just to talk through um that process, that journey and that decision. And I'll preface it with I have this conversation a lot with people, so much so that we have an ebook on our website to address specifically what roles make sense to hire in the Philippines in a agency. And what's more is what are the different ways in which you can structure your organization, whether it is a client-centric, I forget the name that the other one's called, but where you actually have a traffic manager and it all flows through the traffic manager. And so it's it's shared resources, client success or client uh management team will work with the clients, but you're trafficking it all through. And then there's a hybrid model, which has sort of the best of both worlds where you have people working really closely with the clients, but you have subject matter experts that sit across that are bringing in the knowledge. And so um, I'm particularly interested. It's something that comes up uh all too often. So it would be really nice to be able to point them to an episode, especially from a company that's likely far larger than where they're at to understand the journey. So with all of that, um I yeah, take it away, Jimi. Okay.
Let me make sure I don't get too uh off too many exit ramps here. So um I guess um when I came onto the agency, I came on to start the strategy department. Not that we didn't do strategy before, but it wasn't really a formalized process. And I guess if you take personality test or strength finders or anything like that, um futuristic always comes up online, and I'm always looking towards the future, and then also maximizer comes up. And so I think in an organization, you have obviously lots of different people. You have people with um skills and abilities and experience and and all that kind of thing. And so I felt like I because I was newer and we had experienced all of that growth. It was really holding on to a rocket and trying to just get the workout, the best that could be done. And I just saw a lot of tired people. And I started researching and you know, being in an agency background and setup, you have various players, which you mentioned, you have the sales team, you have account managers, you might have project managers, you have the folks who actually do the work in a boutique agency. Typically you'll have somebody who is multidisciplinary and they can do SEO, they can do paid media, they can do all of that. We wanted to have a group of folks that really knew their area in a big way, but would be able to have meaningful conversations and collaborate with people to get the best output. And so I think the best work comes out of that elbow rubbing and friction and challenging your coworker. And I talked earlier about culture, and I think we opened up the door for permission for people to challenge their teammate and you know, really have that as a method of sharpening our skills.
And so when you go through change, there has to be a reason for that change, right? And so there's the old tale about the dog lying on the front porch, and it's whimpering a little bit. And the two old guys are sitting there rocking back and forth and going, Well, why is that dog whimpering? Well, he's laying on a nail. Well, why didn't he get up? Well, I guess the pain in that nail is not enough for him to get up because he's pretty comfortable. And so, what is the level of pain of that nail that you're lying on? Well, the pain of that nail for us was the fact that we had account managers and project managers trying to figure out this spaghetti bowl of who was connected to what project. You had team members who were not understanding who else was on the team working on a client project. You had clients asking who's working on our account. Could I speak with the person who does this work? And so these repetitive conversations kept coming up, and we realized that we were not positioned for growth. Now, when I came in, my brain was thinking we want to be double the size that we are in a certain period of time, right? And so all of the planning in my brain was we want to be double the size.
Well, how are you going to get to be double the size when all of this, and I won't say instability, but I would say um angst or friction was happening, uh, maybe some loose bolts that if we layered on more growth, it would sort of crumble. We would lose good people, we would lose clients, all of that. And so in researching various organizational structures, I came across one that folks can look up. It's called the matrix organizational structure, where it's different than a hierarchical make matrix structure, hierarchical is basically top-down, looks like you know, a typical organizational chart. Um, you have the person at the top, then you have the next layer and the next layer and the next layer. Well, the more layers you have, um, I would say the more dysfunctional, especially when it gets to be a large organization. And so when you have an organization that has many different locations, typically it's organized by location and they might report to a regional director. Well, we didn't have that. We had um folks that were basically required to do the work and be part of this huge team. And so we made the decision to split the company into four teams.
And effectively what we were doing was creating four boutique agencies, getting the best of a boutique boutique agency approach in a larger organization. Well, obviously, the best time to do that is when you start, not 18 years later. But we said, well, if we're going to grow and for the benefit of all the things that I just mentioned, we need to do this. And so there was a lot of planning. Um, I would say eight to ten months of planning until we were ready to bring it to the rest of the company. And I sort of championed a PR tour, and we went around to every department and explained that when the company started, everybody was sitting next to each other, and there was this feeling of we're part of this team helping out these clients. And did anybody else out there feel like that we had gotten away from that, even if you just joined? Or are you feeling a little disconnected from the rest of your team and your client? And so pretty much everybody agreed that was the case. And so conceptually, everybody understood.
Of course, there were a million questions. And we also admitted the fact that this is not going to be easy, and there are going to be things that feel painful. And we would like to invite you to give us feedback about what is painful, what is not working, and what have we missed along the way? And so we opened the door for a feedback channel. We had a specific process where you would provide that feedback. And then we decided, well, we're not going to launch all four of these teams. We're going to launch one team, and we're going to work out the kinks. And the number one goal is we don't want to lose any employees and we don't want to lose any clients. So, how are we going to do this so that we mitigate those two risks? We started in March. We decided we would launch on March 1st, and we would see how it went. But our goal was to run that group. Um we called it basically a league. We had lots of sports analogies uh throughout the process uh because we wanted that team mentality. So we had a whole language around uh we actually had a glossary that we sent out. And when somebody refers to this, and so there was a common language that we wanted people to adopt so they understood and they could get it straight in their head.
Um, you know, when you work with a bunch of smart people, they got to have something to grab on to. So uh we wanted to create that structure and that language. And we thought we would be ready to launch the other three leagues um at the end of July. Well, what ended up happening was that first league loved it so much, they became evangelists for the process. They would talk about how wonderful it was and why didn't we do this sooner? And on company meetings, we would have representatives talk to the rest of the company. Um we did another PR tour of that league and various stakeholders in that league that went around and talked to the rest. And so what ended up happening was the rest of the company was like, when can we launch? When can we launch? And then we were like, Well, you know, it's going to be messy, you know you're going to go through some pain. Here's what we've learned. And we were actually able to launch those other three leagues at the beginning of June. So we beat our intended time frame by a couple of months.
Um, I won't say it was perfectly smooth, but it was a lot smoother because of all the steps that I just mentioned. And so now like it's functioning like the way we want it to function. And everybody has this common language, and maybe I'll stop there and you can dig in. But um, I tried to explain it as clearly as possible. There were a lot of moving parts. Um, it ended up being kind of fun. It challenged us to think beyond sort of the rut that I think we had gotten ourselves into. And um, yeah, it was it was a good story that we can tell at this point.
Yeah, no, that's uh super insightful, Jimi and a lot to unpack the questions. I mean, the many questions that the first question that I have is when you define, well, let me just restate a few things here uh for the audience. So, on the one hand, what we're talking about is um business transformation and business transformation as it relates to uh operational, like a considerable operational change. And as a result of that, there's a lot of change management that needs to go into this. Um, from what I could gather, the league, the first league was essentially like the beta test of it, and you moved kind of like your SEO strategy. The idea was to move in these concentric circles and continue to bring more people into it. Um, it sort of caught like uh wildfire in the best possible way here, and everyone wants to get on board um earlier. Just looking at the the functional like setup and the and some of the decisions around the change. And this is for anyone who's going through some of these, you know, uh growing pains. And I think a lot of what you've shared with your shift in business operation um has applications to how we're operating as a sub slightly just under a hundred person company now, is that you know what you often find is that you used to have this degree of uh fluidity and ability to just you know uh launch and go down a path, but now there's so many stakeholders involved in critical decisions that you know a lot of these things tend to get labored.
And so I guess the first the first sort of response from a question perspective I I have for you is what was the major driver behind the decision and were they lead or lag measures that resulted in you guys making the decisions to make that change for anyone listening, you know, when is the right time to reassess and reorg is really what I'm trying to understand and what information were you tracking to initiate an understanding of there might be a better way. Yeah.
I think it's probably three. Um typically they tend to be uh uh lag measures because that's where you start to look at data. Um I would say a couple of those were, and we've always had great um client retention, but that number started to shift a little bit, which we started to go, oh, why is that happening? The other thing is in an agency environment, you know, when you talk about folks leaving, that's either an indication that they're not happy or there's something attracting them outside the organization. Typically in an agency environment, it can be 30 to 50 percent annually. Um, we float around voluntary tenure at about 5%. And so we're like, okay, well, we we don't want that to change. And so we keep an eye on that. I think the biggest thing was, and I mentioned it before that we have a culture where folks feel like not that they can complain, but they can have constructive criticism. You know, all of our managers are trained that if somebody comes to them with a problem, then their immediate responses, well, what would you do about it? And so we had the client experience team, which are basically the account managers, being very frustrated because they could not figure out who was working on what job. And we're like, okay, that's bad. They're not able to do their job.
They we have a um a culture where we discourage overtime. We saw that people were putting in more hours that was affecting their home life. So all of these softer things started to bubble up. And then compared to the fact that I mentioned we wanted to double in size, it was preventing us from being able to onboard new clients because our capacity, and it took longer to do things, right? And so our efficiency numbers went down. And so I would say when you mix all that up in a bowl of soup, it didn't taste too good. And again, how much pain are you willing to put up with? You can just sit there and go, well, I don't care. That's what you signed up for. Go do your job. I don't care what it takes. Or you can listen and go, well, what kind of company do we want to be? Who is this hurting the most? And it we believed it was hurting the clients. We believed we're not able to do the best work for them. Um we believe we were taking people through too many steps. Um, and because at our core, we wanted to be able to help more businesses, we weren't able to grow because of all of these things. And so you have all these competing things that caused you to come to a point to say something's got to change. Yeah.
Um very, very clear. Um very clear. I mean, having your client's best interest at heart while overlaying that with your internal team member and the required uh ways in which you need to show up, particularly in uh a space like agency land where the average tenure, at least while I was like very heavily in the game, was about 18 months. So you you threw out five years and and how you approach it, um, you know, these are all really important uh measures, particularly for agency client relationships and you know, the the things that I think universally you can draw from these insights is that if something doesn't feel like it is operating at the level from a service delivery perspective uh that you would hope for, then it probably isn't. And it's really something that you need to dig into to understand how you can how you actually meeting your clients where they're at and delivering at the level of speed, you know, cost and value that you've set out to to achieve in in this uh in this state. Um I'm just mindful of the time here, and uh it is uh it is skipping along here. I've got a few um I've got a few more questions though before we uh before we we wrap up here.
Sure. There is obviously a considerable shift uh going on right now as it relates to SEO. Um there's obviously always been an appetite for agencies. Um there's perpetual shifts that exist in you know, from Facebook or Meta, as they as the kids call it uh these days, and you know, what paid media looks like and its effectivity and the wars between iOS and Facebook and not wanting to let each other in, you can't track someone's data across platform and all of these things. And I'm sort of 10 years out of agency, like, you know, running being a part of an agency. And I've seen a big rise. Actually, one of our major uh ICPs are agencies because we stuff so many of the roles that are high value delivery to agencies. And I'm just curious from your lens, you know, you're working at a you know a mid-sized agency. Um, there's a lot of shift. What are some of the the key markers or things that you're seeing with all of this new technology and the shifts in paid media and the value? Like, what are the things that I guess people listening in should be mindful of of either potentially easy wins for them or things that would make sense for their business, whether they work with Thrive or not? Like, what are the what are the things that they should be paying it attention to? And what are the buzzwords? What are the things that you know, AIAI AIAI? But like, what are the things that people should also be equally avoiding?
Um, I said I was typically future paced. I'm not a futurist, so I don't have the crystal ball, but I can tell you some things that we're seeing that we're excited about. It's kind of weird. Um, you know, and I hate to age myself, but when I started out, um some of the behaviors that were the way that you got attention to your brand are now coming back around. So they say fashion always repeats itself. Um, I think core principles repeat themselves. And in this world of AI, I think brands have gotten used to the easy button and they're putting out garbage content. And so I know recently uh TikTok and Instagram have announced that um content on those platforms are showing up in organic searches. They're also being cataloged by LLMs. Um brand mentions are more important than ever. And I would say that's an old PR term, like used to send out press releases to get a mention in some publication. I would say the world of backlinks has changed. Um you really want to continue to have those, but you don't want them on sites that are irrelevant to your core business or contextually or wrong for the business. And so that goes back to the White Hat versus Black Hat, right?
And so if you've been doing those things, great, continue to do those things and understand that these large language models are looking for a larger contextual footprint to your brand. And that first search doesn't always return the group. It actually fans out into multiple branches of a tree, and they're checking to see is this brand showing up in all of these places? And so we've seen uh I would say organic social has been a struggle. It's usually the first thing that people cut as a service, and we're seeing that increase now because it is a platform where uh those brand mentions and things can happen. I would say customer reviews are also extremely important. That's a huge thing for these large language models to understand what the sentiment is of the organization. And the other thing that we're seeing, and this goes into the acronym that Google uses to qualify the reliability, and I would say other large language models as well is the EEAT or EAT, which is experience, expertise, authority, and trustworthiness, right? And so when you start spitting out this garbage content that does not feature a subject matter expert, whether they be a department head, whether it be the founder, the owner, whomever, somebody on the team, um, and there is content that is basically paper thin, you're gonna lose.
Like it's just flat out. So I think the opportunity for organizations to feature their expertise is more prevalent than ever. Um, personal branding for founders and owners and executives is so much more important now. Um and so I think those are things that folks can lean in on. Um yeah, I don't know if that gave enough nuggets, but those are the things that we're seeing.
It gave it gave some great nuggets and definitely the trends and things that I I also believe to be true. You know, I I think the simple fact is uh on two of the, you know, two of the two of the great uh insights you gave there is one um it's not brand selling to brands, it's people selling to people. And so being able to humanize it and having your key people actually, you know, you getting on a podcast like this, having a conversation and people connecting with you, you know, in a meaningful way is different to Thrive Agency and go to Thrive, you know, as a, you know, so I so I definitely align with that and the subsequent content that will come out uh of this session um, you know, creates that value and that that humanity behind the brand and also um do real work essentially on the SEO or GEO front, you know, don't just like back in the uh good old days where you could keyword spam the absolute shit out of a website and it would just pick up all that stuff and you know, and off you go.
Those days are uh I I would say thankfully over because it really is about having um adding value and creating stickiness and meaning on those websites. Uh Jimi, uh it was an absolute pleasure. I'm gonna drop all the links, obviously, in the show notes, but should someone want to get in contact with you? Um, you know, uh who would be appropriate to work with as Thrive as an agency, you know, who should be reaching out if that'll listen to this?
Yeah, well, I'm pretty um active on LinkedIn. Uh post every day some sort of tip or something that would be helpful. Um, happy to take a DM from somebody, follow me, um, and then I can point you in a direction. ThriveAgency.com is the website, and we've got lots of resources that are free. I do a article every month that is accompanied by about a 20-minute video on education about the whole space. Um and obviously there's lead forms on there if somebody wants to fill those out. But if they want that personal connection, I'm happy to handhold anybody or be a second opinion. If somebody's trying to investigate what route they should go, would be happy to help anybody. Um kind of an uh southern born and southern bred guy and uh like that personal connection. So awesome.
It's all about the hospitality. Well, Jimi, you've been uh very hospitable with your time today and I uh and and and all the answers and the value that you've been able to create. So thank you very, very much and uh looking forward to both staying in touch and uh who knows, maybe we can have that second follow-up uh on one of these deep dive topics, maybe around the uh evolution of SEO or something to that effect.
Yeah, but love to do that. Thanks for having me, Yoni.
Thanks, Jimi.
Episode details
- Series
- Successful Scales
- Host
- Yoni Kozminski
- Episode
- 99
- Published
- August 27, 2025
- Transcript
- 7,822 words